Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Best Storyline???

I haven't played an MMO that had a strong background/underlying storyline since FFXI with its missions that really created a sense of playing a game with a purpose and true story unlike other games where its all about mindless grinding. Anyone have any suggestions for any good MMOs that have a good storyline and are FUN to play???

Comments

  • ViolentYViolentY Member Posts: 1,458


    Originally posted by Niix
    Anyone have any suggestions for any good MMOs that have a good storyline and are FUN to play???

    Lineage 1 had a good story, but not so much the second part.

    _____________________________________
    "Io rido, e rider mio non passa dentro;
    Io ardo, e l'arsion mia non par di fore."

    -Machiavelli

  • RK-MaraRK-Mara Member Posts: 641

    Bah, I gotta say this:

    WoW has long story line with the Warcraft RTS games.

    And there's coming LOTRO next year. It will be based on the books. Not movies.



    image

  • GRIMACHUGRIMACHU Member Posts: 528


    Originally posted by Niix
    I haven't played an MMO that had a strong background/underlying storyline since FFXI with its missions that really created a sense of playing a game with a purpose and true story unlike other games where its all about mindless grinding. Anyone have any suggestions for any good MMOs that have a good storyline and are FUN to play???

    Ryzom won the best storyline MMORPG award thingy.

    Postmortem Studios
    Roleplaying games to DIE for
    Shop here

  • KibsKibs Member Posts: 411
    Agreed, Ryzom has a superb storyline and won the MMORPG.com award last time it was run

    -----------------

    Kibs

    Avatar by Ema

    Playing: The Saga of Ryzom since march 2004

    image

  • FlabshabFlabshab Member Posts: 26
    Theres City of villians thats got a heaps good storyline cause its my third fav game

    image

  • AwesomeoAwesomeo Member UncommonPosts: 133
    Guild Wars has cut scenes and meaningfull quests which gives it a story line. It has none of that collecting and killing bullshit thats completely pointless and drives it away from a story. Although when i say Guild Wars i don't think thats what your looking for.
  • hadzhadz Member Posts: 712

    Ryzom has a storyline??? Not when I played...

    GW has the best storyline, by a longshot (3 storylines, counting the chapters seperately). In fact it's almost single-player-RPGesque in its cut scenes, PC centred story-progression, and coherent and connected quests and missions.

  • DarkeOneDarkeOne Member Posts: 36
    Theres a whole bunch of MMO games out now that have pretty decent story lines; WoW, EQ2, Ryzom, COH/COV, GW,EQ1, hell even the current SWG. All of these games have in depth sotrylines and backhistory to them.

    As for decent to play, I think that's a matter of personal preference. All of these games offer something to players.What is it that your looking for spefically in gameplay?


    D

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182
    Obviously World of Warcraft has a strong storyline, with the books, and other warcraft games, no other MMORPG can compare. 2nd is Lineage 2 for me.

  • frkhot97frkhot97 Member Posts: 393


    Originally posted by hadz
    Ryzom has a storyline??? Not when I played...GW has the best storyline, by a longshot (3 storylines, counting the chapters seperately). In fact it's almost single-player-RPGesque in its cut scenes, PC centred story-progression, and coherent and connected quests and missions.

    Well...

    Ryzom has a great storyline actually, but I don't think it's what the OP wants. Let me explain.

    I haven't played the Final Fantasy MMO, but if it is anything like the FF singleplayer games then the roleplaying aspect is very different from sandboxes games like EVE and Ryzom. Final Fantasy has always had a strong story, but little room freedom for the player. Ryzom gives max freedom for the player while the storyline takes the backseat. It doesn't mean it's not good (it's great) but unless there are more official events that lets the players affect the outcome (like EP 2) the storyline is almost invisible.

  • GRIMACHUGRIMACHU Member Posts: 528


    Originally posted by hadz

    Ryzom has a storyline??? Not when I played...


    Then I submit that you weren't paying attention.
    You seem to be a quester, Ryzom progresses with live events.

    Postmortem Studios
    Roleplaying games to DIE for
    Shop here

  • SuaveSuave Member Posts: 150


    Originally posted by frkhot97
    I haven't played the Final Fantasy MMO, but if it is anything like the FF singleplayer games then the roleplaying aspect is very different from sandboxes games like EVE and Ryzom. Final Fantasy has always had a strong story, but little room freedom for the player. Ryzom gives max freedom for the player while the storyline takes the backseat. It doesn't mean it's not good (it's great) but unless there are more official events that lets the players affect the outcome (like EP 2) the storyline is almost invisible.


    Final Fantasy XI's storyline is in no way comparable to singleplayer Final Fantasies.  While it is a common belief that Final Fantasy XI must have a compelling storyline, due to the nature of its license, this is very far from the truth.  Yes, it does have a unique storyline with what one could consider "cutscenes"; however it is very lacking.  A player can only progress through the main storyline by partaking in "missions", which do not occur in frequent succession.  You may do one mission one day and find yourself not able to do the next one for another month.

    If you were able to progress through FFXI's storyline one part after another, it would be a fairly decent plot.  However, due to the nature of a player's progression through the game, it doesn't make for a very good storyline.

  • AelfinnAelfinn Member Posts: 3,857

    Guild Wars is the only one that really has a storyline as I usually think of it. Unfortunately, the story is pretty short, and once its over, the game has little continued playability for most people.

    Anarchy Online has an excellent background story, and its always changing, moving forward with the players.

    No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main. any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.
    Hemingway

  • AmaraoAmarao Member UncommonPosts: 650
    I think PSU is gonna own the story department with the single player. But right now I guess Lineage.

  • Well there is back story and then there is storyline.  Guild Wars has the best storyline bar none because it has a mechanism in place to enact the storyline.  And factions campaign very much enforeces that storyline even.

    But many games have quite good backstory.


  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182
    guys, he asked which MMO has the best storyline. that means GW is not included, or else we might as well add Diablo and Neverwinter nights while we're at it.



  • Originally posted by Gameloading
    guys, he asked which MMO has the best storyline. that means GW is not included, or else we might as well add Diablo and Neverwinter nights while we're at it.



    Oh right  I forgot, you don't agree therefore it must be disappeared.  Down the memory hole, Winston Smith?
  • DismantledDismantled Member UncommonPosts: 121
     For me its EVE.....Why?
    1:) it can actually happen
    2:) the players influence it more then any other game ive seen or played.
    3:) Normally i hate fanfare writings but the ones for EVE are usually pretty good.
    4:) Ive never seen so much backstory and history for a game before.


  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182


    Originally posted by gestalt11

    Originally posted by Gameloading
    guys, he asked which MMO has the best storyline. that means GW is not included, or else we might as well add Diablo and Neverwinter nights while we're at it.


    Oh right  I forgot, you don't agree therefore it must be disappeared.  Down the memory hole, Winston Smith?


    Its kind of unfair because its much more easy to tell a story in an instanced enviroment then in open enviroment. Wow, that was hard to understand, wasn't it, Watson?
  • CowinspaceCowinspace Member Posts: 671

    If you are looking for a running storyline, then Guildwars is what you want. OK its not a true MMOG, but its story beats the heck out of others, even ryzom, eve, wow, etc.

    As for Background, stories and general Info, Eve has about the most directly available stuff I have seen (ie. you don't have to go off the main site).

    Chronicles : Small single page stories (currently at 93 chronicles)

    Short Stories : 6 short stories and 2 novellas

    Scientific Articles : Similar to short stories in length detailing the science of the Eve universe

    Races : Some information on the 4 main races (use the left hand menu to navigate, also some small info on jove)

    Organisations and Factions : Information on the NPC factions and corporations

    Player Alliances : Information on the player alliances



    image



  • Originally posted by Gameloading

    Originally posted by gestalt11

    Originally posted by Gameloading
    guys, he asked which MMO has the best storyline. that means GW is not included, or else we might as well add Diablo and Neverwinter nights while we're at it.


    Oh right  I forgot, you don't agree therefore it must be disappeared.  Down the memory hole, Winston Smith?


    Its kind of unfair because its much more easy to tell a story in an instanced enviroment then in open enviroment. Wow, that was hard to understand, wasn't it, Watson?


    WoW has extremely substantial instanced environments.  In fact the major storyline elements such Kel'thuzad occur in raid instances.  WoW could easily have virtually the same storytelling mechanisms as Guild Wars in addition to its outside instance questing mechanism.  They simply choose not to.

    It doesn't matter whether GW is a true MMO or not its mechanisms are certainly possible since many of these games make heavy use of instances.  Further you could certainly have the cutscene mechanism in an open environment if you wanted, especially with the skip option.

    No its not hard to understand that you are wrong.
  • SheistaSheista Member UncommonPosts: 1,203
    I will always stand by Asheron's Call 1 as having the best, and most immersive storyline in any MMO.  When I started playing, it was so easy to get into and has been the only game that I have actually -wanted- to follow the story in.

  • MajorBiggsMajorBiggs Member UncommonPosts: 709
    Neocron and Asherons Call 1 i'd say have the best storyline.
Sign In or Register to comment.