Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

What the gameing community is saying about Lotro

JackdogJackdog Member UncommonPosts: 6,321

since MMORPG.com gets more than it's fair share of trollsone would think that there is not a game outr there worth playing if all you had to go by were the posts here so to balance it out a bit here is a article from a site with some good quotes on LoTRO

kotaku.com/gaming/hard-hobbit-to-break/lotro-tops-pc-sales-in-usa-and-europe-259346.php



?? The New York Times proclaimed LOTRO as "a major achievement of interactive storytelling, the first game truly worthy of the 'Lord of the Rings' franchise and a must-play for just about anyone with an interest in Tolkien or the future of online entertainment."

?? GameSpy awarded the game its prestigious Editor's Choice award with 4.5 out of 5 stars.

?? Computer and Video Games, a leading UK gaming site, rated the game a 9.2 out of 10 and said "LOTRO presents a stunning and evocative world of Tolkien magic to explore."

?? GameDaily, a leading US gaming site, rated the game a 9 out of 10 and calls the game "a hot contender for PC game of the year."

and a quote from Jeff Anderson



"This outstanding start sets the stage for a bright future," said Jeffrey Anderson, president and CEO of Turbine, Inc. "This is only the beginning as we embark on an incredible journey with our players to expand the world of Middle-earth with the release of regular content updates."

"Following the most successful North American pre-order program in Midway's history, The Lord of the Rings Online is off to a great start," said Steve Allison, chief marketing officer, Midway. "As the positive reports and reviews continue to come in, gamers are settling into the game and experiencing Middle-earth as never before."

I miss DAoC

Comments

  • RagewindRagewind Member Posts: 90


    I think they pretty much nail it.  I mean i play the game i like it so far..  Maybe not that great or revolutionary but it works pretty well for the average consumer. 



    About all the forum trolls arround.. well its meaningless.  The such called "hardcore" crew are nothing but no life geeks and nerds with an atitude problem, I do think they are a minority.



    The irony about this people is that in real life they are mostly complete losers, so they show here trying to show its"superiority" over average gammers, arguing a excuisit taste that can be only achieved by expending most of your life infront of a pc screen.
  • StanlyManlyStanlyManly Member Posts: 181
    Remember, similar things were said about AC2 upon release, and it also received very high review scores.



    And why post something the head of the company says about the game?  I'm sure he's just more than a little biased...

    Equal opportunity troll.

  • RagewindRagewind Member Posts: 90
    Originally posted by StanlyManly

    Remember, similar things were said about AC2 upon release, and it also received very high review scores.



    And why post something the head of the company says about the game?  I'm sure he's just more than a little biased...
      Now, are you talking about beeing biased? ... equal opportunity troll.
  • HadesPvPHadesPvP Member Posts: 33
    I think it will do decently. Definitely not going to compete with World of Warcraft, but it will beat AC for sure.

    image

  • antoniuspiusantoniuspius Member Posts: 55
    Originally posted by HadesPvP

    I think it will do decently. Definitely not going to compete with World of Warcraft, but it will beat AC for sure.



    I think it will surely beat Vanguard and DDO

    And WoW will fall twhen the Gondor expansion comes out

    yes, Stanly I'm a fanboi and I'm proud of it
  • ConleyConley Member Posts: 195
    I don't see it beat WoW either, for one because its PVP options are very limited. But its perfectly clear that LoTRO is set out to be the big number 2 competitor, at least until AoC/Warhammer arrive on the scene. You can spin it right or you can spin it left, but when i see LOTRO consistently on number 1 on American and European software charts its obvious to me that Turbine has nothing to worry about and doing quite well.
  • JackdogJackdog Member UncommonPosts: 6,321
    I don't think the game will ever "beat" WOW, different crowd od players. I se LoTRO in with a comfortable subscription base of a few hundred thousand. Between WAR, AoC and LoTRO though I am sure Blizzard will see a pretty good migration.

    I miss DAoC

  • ZsavoozZsavooz Member Posts: 532
    It doesn't have to compete with WoW to survive. I'm not sure what the minimum number of subscriptions a game like this needs to break even, but I'll assume 100K and up. LOTRO already has that, I'm sure. This game is great on its own merits and will continue to thrive. The word of mouth on this game is keeping the servers hopping. Last night on Arkanstone I had a message that the server was overwhelmed. I wouldn't be surprised if they  open new servers with the content update in June.
  • StripeStripe Member Posts: 3
    Its a good game.  Great is some aspects poor in others.  Better than some but worse than others.



    It has some fun things like the titles and deeds.  And surprisingly, Monster Play (LOTRO PvP part) is suprisingly fun.



    Still, I'm hesitant to call it great or awesome.  Maybe when I get to higher levels that'll change.



    I will say its definately a competitor with WoW.  We'll see how it fares when AoC/Warhammer come out though. 
  • icewindshadeicewindshade Member Posts: 5
    LOTRO is doing a good job of keeping the game an interesting, immersive experience. Whether it "beats" WoW in the long run is irrelevant. Honestly, I'd rather see this game and every other new upcoming MMO out there be successful while still remaining under WoW's numbers. After all, WoW has become stale due to the sheer amount of player base. When a game has to please so many people it has a hard time keeping up and ends up only pleasing a select few. WoW never really had any rivals until LOTRO came along...and with other great MMO's over the horizon it's going to have even more competition. Competition is a good thing for gamers though since it creates more innovative content, lower subscription prices, etc.  No matter what MMO's are available, there will always be dedicated LOTRO players, just as in every other MMO.
  • DaMaDoDaMaDo Member Posts: 19
    I played WoW for 2 years and many other MMOs and I'm enjoying LOTRO right now. I love the books and movies and so it's a special value to me. The world really feels immersive...it feels huge too and I love how you can see things from far away such as a castle on a cliff in the far distance etc....adds to the scale feeling.
  • arakelarakel Member Posts: 14

    lotro is a disaster.

     

     

  • JagRawrJagRawr Member Posts: 10
    arakel just because you dont like a game doesnt make it a disaster..........
  • PalantronPalantron Member Posts: 5

    LotRO is basically a very good game.

     

    Its fun, easy to learn and the quest lines actually make sense. They have a plot, storyline and immersion and anyone new to the game will probably find that aspect of the game both interesting and entertaining for at least the first month.

    The feat system, where achieving reknown as an explorer of a certain area or slayer of certain types of monster is actively rewarded with skill boosts that help your character be stronger is extremely appealing and well presented.

    The classes are reasonably well balanced individually and integrate well with each other in a variety of combinations. No calss is the n=be all and end all in the group setting, which is a great bonus when you are playing at 4am and there are not so many players online, thus fewer options in what class you can group with.

    Each class has a lot more depth than is initially apparent, since, as you level up and complete feats, you get a variety of class specific feats that allow you to tailor your character toward different styles of play.

    The ingame atmosphere is quite buoyant and more fun oriented than many games that I have played, with the result that the RP servers are well populated and RP on the PVE servers is common and often very funny to join or watch.

    Players are reasonably well behaved toward each other and unpleasant incidents are rare.

     

    On the downside, the crafting system is not well designed. Creating good craft items requires exceptionally rare items and skilling up is expensive and a bit of a grind. Once you get there, your crafted items are practically useless because the quest rewards are generally excellent and, personal opinion, far too good to justify the relatively low effort you put in.

    Some aspects of the economy are not well balanced, which is not uncommon but, given that crafting redundancy is part of the reason for this, makes this a fairly major downpoint in the game.

    The game has a good range of content most of the way to level 35 which means you wont be bored doing the same thing over and over. There are lots of ways to get there and different places to quest in. But, at 35 the options become much more limited and levelling up becomes quite a grind, with many people currently complaining that finding a group is very difficult.

     

    You'd have to agree that LOTRO is one of the best games on the market. Its fun, has an immersive setting and great graphics. The class system is much deeper than it appears to be at first sight and the quests are generally fun and interesting.

    The content is a bit limited in some ways, but even hardened gamers should get a good two months of good gaming on their main character from LOTRO.

    The forthcoming update in June will hopefully bring that a bit closer to three months and, if they gauge the next upodate properly I think it would be fair to say that, at that point, LOTRO will become a fairly well rounded game.

  • deplorabledeplorable Member Posts: 418

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnUvw1rzziE

     

    enough said, i'd rather they made it about the 2nd or 4th age using the book and making it original...

    the actual storyline sucks.. seriously use griffins, drop ring... go home

  • JackdogJackdog Member UncommonPosts: 6,321
    www.gamingillustrated.com/lotro.php



    Although we are only at level 14 with our character, we can say that LOTR Online is just a plain FUN game to play. The quests are pretty varied so far, and the graphics and environment of Middle Earth, coupled together with the overall theme of the War for the One Ring makes this the most gratifying MMORPG we’ve played to date. There’s a fantastic community of players online that are willing to help newbies, as well as plenty of sites with huge databases full of information if you get stuck. Although we plan to report in once a month from LOTR Online, we can say after playing it for a few weeks that this is the definitive new MMORPG to play in 2007.



    I agree it is not perfect and needs work in some areas but considering what else is out there it is pretty damned good





    I miss DAoC

  • HairysunHairysun Member UncommonPosts: 1,059
    Originally posted by Jackdog

    www.gamingillustrated.com/lotro.php



    Although we are only at level 14 with our character, we can say that LOTR Online is just a plain FUN game to play. The quests are pretty varied so far, and the graphics and environment of Middle Earth, coupled together with the overall theme of the War for the One Ring makes this the most gratifying MMORPG we’ve played to date. There’s a fantastic community of players online that are willing to help newbies, as well as plenty of sites with huge databases full of information if you get stuck. Although we plan to report in once a month from LOTR Online, we can say after playing it for a few weeks that this is the definitive new MMORPG to play in 2007.



    I agree it is not perfect and needs work in some areas but considering what else is out there it is pretty damned good





       I completely agree, it is't a perfect game.  From what I hear about Turbine, they seem to be one of the better companies as far as patches and content updates go.  As I've said before, this game will do nothing but get better and better as time goes on.
  • JackdogJackdog Member UncommonPosts: 6,321
    What continually impressed me throughout the beta was that the Devs seem to listen to us and respond, sometimes they would just tell us to suck it up, it was working as intended . However  for the most part  they paid attention to what we were saying and responded. Here is one example



    forums.lotro.com/showthread.php





    they also have a new public test server



    forums.lotro.com/showthread.php



    so any changes and expansions are first tested by the Dev team then a hand chosen group of testers on a closed server then it is put on the preview server for anyone who wants to test, then once they are satisified they will patch it into the regular servers. While I am sure that a occasional bug will slip by they are doing a hell of a lot more to ensure a quality product than most companies do.

    I miss DAoC

  • ReklawReklaw Member UncommonPosts: 6,495
    Overall the community (beta as far my exp with lotrO go for now)of LotrO has always been a good one, forumwise even best experiance for beta, far better for the most part then the community i saw in beta with Vanguard  luckly that changed for me atleast when Vanguard opened EU servers (Not to be harsh towards my fellow US gamefriends but whooohiiee ingame atmosphere was pretty hostile in beta especialy with open beta and yes that actualy only been times i read lots of ingame people saying "go back to wow" which i honosly not have read or might have not noticed on the EU after release , so might afcourse changed aswell in US server, anyway LotrO really deserves the credit it is getting, compared to Vanguard its pretty obvious that LotrO stands out not only because of great performance, but also how the game is put together. I said it in other topics  you have to be blind not to see that LotrO is a good game. Unfortunaly even here you see trolls with nothing to do than flame at whatever game they don't seem to like. Its sad but looking on the Vanguard forums here still has a larger dose of ignorant people then here, lucky for you fans atleast. But fact remains LotrO is a very well published/developed game it does justice to Tolkien (some tolkien fans might disagree) but looking from a mass-appeal point of view they done  great job. Still not installed cause even though the game is good i prefure other things in a mmorpg which LotrO just not has for me.
  • sadnebulasadnebula Member UncommonPosts: 263
    Vanguard deserved the rage.  lotr, Naa, nothing to rage about. Even if you don't like it there's still nothing wrong with it. Turbine put out a well thought out game that the fans are enjoying.  Me, I stopped playing right after release,  just not my cup of tea.
Sign In or Register to comment.