Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Graphics or gameplay? Which one is it?

13»

Comments

  • winterwinter Member UncommonPosts: 2,281
    Originally posted by Scaredgirl


    Graphics or gameplay? Which one is it? You can't have it both ways.
    Some people say you can have both. They are wrong. What people consider "good graphics" nowadays is something like what Age of Conan has. The problem is that with todays technology it's just not going to happen. There are no 300vs300 epic battles in AoC, or not even 100vs100. You know why? Because the engine, servers and users computers can't handle it. There would be huge lag and crashes, it would be unplayable.
    Seeing people here complain about DF graphics really pisses me off. I've seen many here say how they prefer gameplay over graphic but once we see a new video what is the first thing they complain about? Yes, graphics. This is so dumb.
    I do agree with most people that Aventurine needs to work on the animations. I hate it when in the videos all the characters had this "bounce" in their running. Hope they can fix that.
    If you want to see what happens when an MMO is all graphics and no gameplay, I suggest you go subscribe to Age of Conan. Sure the game looks pretty but is mostly a boring, instanced, single player game which has no soul. You really want that?
    We don't know much about the gameplay in DF but if they can make it fluid and fun, graphics are acceptable. At least for me.

     Well the 2 italians that got to do a short open Beta declared DF graphics beat any game currently out or some such. The DF Fans took this to heart and posted a thread here stating DF's graphics were better then AoC's or LoTRO's, but then the Italian beta testers released their video which IMO doesn't look anywhere as good as AoC's or even LoTRO's but i'm sure their are many fans which will just call anyone that disagrees with their assessment that DF has the best graphics ever as trolls. (as seen in this thread already)

     

      As a general rule I try never to argue with crazy people because well you know they are crazy

  • winterwinter Member UncommonPosts: 2,281
    Originally posted by originalegg

    Originally posted by Gajari


    I don't get it. To me, Darkfall looks amazing and one of the better looking games in development. I don't understand how people think it looks bad.
    Though characters do look a bit slow and stiff as they move around, that's my only complaint, but I'll wait and see how it plays out (if it plays out at all.)

     

    You aren't alone.  Majority of people agree with you.  It is just the very vocal minority that want any reason to bash this game because they enjoy being internet tough.

    It drives them crazy that DF is comming out and that people are excited about it.



     

     Yeah, yeah right, as to coming out how is that Open beta doing anyway, not much time left there as it ends in early december and the game will be launched in what the next 3 weeks? (assuming Aventurine takes time off for the holidays which seems reasonable as they took a 2 week summer vacation before releasing their video in August.)

  • downtoearthdowntoearth Member Posts: 3,558
    Originally posted by winter

    Originally posted by originalegg

    Originally posted by Gajari


    I don't get it. To me, Darkfall looks amazing and one of the better looking games in development. I don't understand how people think it looks bad.
    Though characters do look a bit slow and stiff as they move around, that's my only complaint, but I'll wait and see how it plays out (if it plays out at all.)

     

    You aren't alone.  Majority of people agree with you.  It is just the very vocal minority that want any reason to bash this game because they enjoy being internet tough.

    It drives them crazy that DF is comming out and that people are excited about it.



     

     Yeah, yeah right, as to coming out how is that Open beta doing anyway, not much time left there as it ends in early december and the game will be launched in what the next 3 weeks? (assuming Aventurine takes time off for the holidays which seems reasonable as they took a 2 week summer vacation before releasing their video in August.)



     

    who cares it has public beta testers that all thats matters

  • EvasiaEvasia Member Posts: 2,827
    Originally posted by Scaredgirl


    Graphics or gameplay? Which one is it? You can't have it both ways.
    Some people say you can have both. They are wrong. What people consider "good graphics" nowadays is something like what Age of Conan has. The problem is that with todays technology it's just not going to happen. There are no 300vs300 epic battles in AoC, or not even 100vs100. You know why? Because the engine, servers and users computers can't handle it. There would be huge lag and crashes, it would be unplayable.
    Seeing people here complain about DF graphics really pisses me off. I've seen many here say how they prefer gameplay over graphic but once we see a new video what is the first thing they complain about? Yes, graphics. This is so dumb.
    I do agree with most people that Aventurine needs to work on the animations. I hate it when in the videos all the characters had this "bounce" in their running. Hope they can fix that.
    If you want to see what happens when an MMO is all graphics and no gameplay, I suggest you go subscribe to Age of Conan. Sure the game looks pretty but is mostly a boring, instanced, single player game which has no soul. You really want that?
    We don't know much about the gameplay in DF but if they can make it fluid and fun, graphics are acceptable. At least for me.



     

    Darkfall have both superb grafhics and awesome gameplay:)

    Games played:AC1-Darktide'99-2000-AC2-Darktide/dawnsong2003-2005,Lineage2-2005-2006 and now Darkfall-2009.....
    In between WoW few months AoC few months and some f2p also all very short few weeks.

  • EvasiaEvasia Member Posts: 2,827

    Games played:AC1-Darktide'99-2000-AC2-Darktide/dawnsong2003-2005,Lineage2-2005-2006 and now Darkfall-2009.....
    In between WoW few months AoC few months and some f2p also all very short few weeks.

  • Loke666Loke666 Member EpicPosts: 21,441
    Originally posted by Evasia
    Darkfall have both superb grafhics and awesome gameplay:)

     

    So you're in the beta then I guess? I wasn't so impressed by the graphics in the movie but off course they will probably use more effects on the final game so it might look better at release. Gameplay I have off course no clue about since I'm not in the beta.

    Other games with both great gameplay and graphics will come out next year, Guildwars 2 for one.

    I don't see why we can't have both, MMO devs have gotten lazy with the graphics since "Wows graphics isn't so hot so why would we have to spend so much work on it then?".

  • PezheadPezhead Member Posts: 149
    Originally posted by mcpoopypantz


    Personally never understood people's obsession with graphics. Thats whats wrong with games today... we have all this gamers who arent true "Gamers" and are more along the lines of "Art Appreciaters" Yet the gaming companies make games for them since there are more of them.
    A true "Gamer" cares about the gameplay over the gfx. Wow better looking pixels.. who cares??

    Now this post was pretty much the only one that annoyed me in the entire forum.  "True gamer"?  By your standards, what is a "true" gamer?  Are we talking SlayerS_BoxeR making millions of dollars playing starcraft with APM(actions per minute) well above 500, are we talking hours spent? Number of games played?  Specific games played?

    Seriously, I'm no gaming elite, I know that for sure, but I have a solid history of games, I've played through upwards of 75(non-browser based) on the PC alone.  I am active on 18 atm. Does that make me a "true gamer"?  I like graphics, and I like gameplay, I can stand bad gameplay to an extent, and I can stand bad graphics to an extent, does that mean i'm not a "true gamer"?  What games do you play? How many have you played?  How good are you? How FAST are you? Could you play on a professional level?  Does ANY of that make you a "true gamer"? 

    It's almost 2010, and I am just not wiling to tolerate clunky graphics while being told that "gameplay is more important than graphics". That excuse won't wash with me any more. I expect my games to have both good graphics and good gameplay.
    -Quote Isoke(VN boards)

  • DarthRaidenDarthRaiden Member UncommonPosts: 4,333

    *True gamer (related to MMORPG/FPS genre)

    True gamer , is not expecting any in game tutorial or any explanation on "what should i do"..

    he finds out himself and the write a guide in the forum (if he want to tell others at all)

    True gamer like to enter game  open for him to explore  with nothing known beforehand and willing to be part  of a world he don't know their rules but try to find out and to accept them.

    True gamer, accepting to get full loot after get defeated and don't blame the game mechanics but try to learn about them better so he can master in game skill  over time.

    True gamer know that the the most pretentious game design is that of an open world, open  to  the possibilities but also to the casualties, best realized in sandbox design.

    True gamer know that  the very fundamental point in playing an MMO is to share anything with other players. He accepts that online gaming involves others and that his reaching his goals will and should  depend on others also.

     

    -----MY-TERMS-OF-USE--------------------------------------------------
    $OE - eternal enemy of online gaming
    -We finally WON !!!! 2011 $OE accepted that they have been fired 2005 by the playerbase and closed down ridiculous NGE !!

    "There was suppression of speech and all kinds of things between disturbing and fascistic." Raph Koster (parted $OE)

  • mcpoopypantzmcpoopypantz Member Posts: 272
    Originally posted by Pezhead

    Originally posted by mcpoopypantz


    Personally never understood people's obsession with graphics. Thats whats wrong with games today... we have all this gamers who arent true "Gamers" and are more along the lines of "Art Appreciaters" Yet the gaming companies make games for them since there are more of them.
    A true "Gamer" cares about the gameplay over the gfx. Wow better looking pixels.. who cares??

    Now this post was pretty much the only one that annoyed me in the entire forum.  "True gamer"?  By your standards, what is a "true" gamer?  Are we talking SlayerS_BoxeR making millions of dollars playing starcraft with APM(actions per minute) well above 500, are we talking hours spent? Number of games played?  Specific games played?

    Seriously, I'm no gaming elite, I know that for sure, but I have a solid history of games, I've played through upwards of 75(non-browser based) on the PC alone.  I am active on 18 atm. Does that make me a "true gamer"?  I like graphics, and I like gameplay, I can stand bad gameplay to an extent, and I can stand bad graphics to an extent, does that mean i'm not a "true gamer"?  What games do you play? How many have you played?  How good are you? How FAST are you? Could you play on a professional level?  Does ANY of that make you a "true gamer"? 



     

    LOL i didnt bother to read your post because I was more or less kidding. I just love when people use terms like "True Gamer" Dont take it to heart kid I was just messing

    Also yes... im def a Ture Gamer cuz I liek a challenge now OMGZ WOW EZ MODE.

  • winterwinter Member UncommonPosts: 2,281
    Originally posted by downtoearth

    Originally posted by winter

    Originally posted by originalegg

    Originally posted by Gajari


    I don't get it. To me, Darkfall looks amazing and one of the better looking games in development. I don't understand how people think it looks bad.
    Though characters do look a bit slow and stiff as they move around, that's my only complaint, but I'll wait and see how it plays out (if it plays out at all.)

     

    You aren't alone.  Majority of people agree with you.  It is just the very vocal minority that want any reason to bash this game because they enjoy being internet tough.

    It drives them crazy that DF is comming out and that people are excited about it.



     

     Yeah, yeah right, as to coming out how is that Open beta doing anyway, not much time left there as it ends in early december and the game will be launched in what the next 3 weeks? (assuming Aventurine takes time off for the holidays which seems reasonable as they took a 2 week summer vacation before releasing their video in August.)



     

    who cares it has public beta testers that all thats matters



     

     Well i would agrue that if your gonna post everytime that DF is coming out in 2008 as egg's avatar does that it would matter? I've seen the "DF is coming" arguement since sept of 2007 it gets alittle old especially when the fanbois always follow it with the same tired tinfoil hat aguement that everyone with doubts is somehow trying to win a interent arguement or prove they are internet tough, just makes the fans that post such crap look incredably swallow and dim witted. Personally I don't get paid more or less in my RL job if I win or loss a internet arguement, nore does it get me more women. Debating a point can be interesting but win or lose it really doesn't matter DF will succeed, or fail on its own merits (or lack of)

  • ScaredgirlScaredgirl Member Posts: 313
    Originally posted by joelfilho


    This can lead to diferent reviews on games. For example:
    - Game A review: the graphics are stunning and amazing. I really felt like I was walking inside the forest and stuff, but meh, the gameplay is horrible. There is no huge battle and I couldnt get past 30 minutes of play due to lack of gameplay.
    - Game B review: the graphics are good, not a top end graphics if compared to Game A, but if compared to the medium games in market, it does it job. And man! The gameplay is amazing! I was in a huge battle with 500 on each side and I could feel what I felt when I was reading that epic book. Playing this game is so awesomesauce, it got me right on the toes! The interactivy, the character development, the monster AI all gets me stuck.
     
    Now, is it possible to name Games A and B?

     

    Game A is Age of Conan.

    Game B does not excist.

    -----------------------------
    Originally posted by Frobner
    "Massive sieges" "mounted combat" and "spellweaving" are just few words that spring to mind when I hear the word AOC.... But the word FAILURE will always top the list.

  • Larz89Larz89 Member UncommonPosts: 45

    i don't get it, what's wrong with darkfall's graphics?



    ok its not crysis but damn, it looks better then WoW and WAR and those were nice mmo gfx too.

    for me a 3D mmo doesn't need high-end graphics, they need a good atmosphere of the world. WoW did that alright, same with WAR.

    AoC at the other hand had great graphics but a terrible atmosphere. i quited AoC for that reason, i need orcs 'n elfs :)

  • BlackthorneVBlackthorneV Member Posts: 16

    Gameplay.  

  • SupderDSupderD Member Posts: 243

    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

    it just means, that I should enjoy playing the game.. and not marveling at the beauty.

    "Luckily I know that while you make nonsnese baiting threads that get locked....threads I make get sticked by the mods on this forum...." -imbant (greatest board warrior EVER)
    Darkfall Countdown: http://darkfallreleasedate.com/

  • ScoorgeScoorge Member Posts: 142

    Gameplay.

    nothing else to add there.

  • xbellx777xbellx777 Member Posts: 716

    gameplay but graphics r a nice plus

  • GiveMePvPGiveMePvP Member Posts: 240
    Originally posted by SupderD


    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

     

    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

  • jy88902jy88902 Member Posts: 293
    Originally posted by Bros89


    i don't get it, what's wrong with darkfall's graphics?



    ok its not crysis but damn, it looks better then WoW and WAR and those were nice mmo gfx too.

    for me a 3D mmo doesn't need high-end graphics, they need a good atmosphere of the world. WoW did that alright, same with WAR.

    AoC at the other hand had great graphics but a terrible atmosphere. i quited AoC for that reason, i need orcs 'n elfs :)



     

    If you want to know what's wrong with Darkfall's graphics, look no further than the two screenshots in part 1 of the preview by the Noob webcomics people that was just released today. Someone on another thread picked the screenshot apart mercilessly, and not surprisingly, none of the fanboys can come up with any clever comebacks so it was simply ignored.

    It truly boggles the mind of anyone with a shred of common sense that this is all they have to show less than a month before a "promised release".

  • PezheadPezhead Member Posts: 149
    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by SupderD


    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

     

    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

     

    12 million WoW subs says otherwise

    It's almost 2010, and I am just not wiling to tolerate clunky graphics while being told that "gameplay is more important than graphics". That excuse won't wash with me any more. I expect my games to have both good graphics and good gameplay.
    -Quote Isoke(VN boards)

  • tombear81tombear81 Member Posts: 810

    I think its about a good balance. Simple as. Anyone with an ounce of sense will understand there is a tradeoff between graphical complexity and issues like nubmer of players on screen in the same area

    Overall though  I'd rather have innovative gameplay than major uber pretty graphics. As long as they are adequete. That said animations are more important in some ways.

  • DameonkDameonk Member UncommonPosts: 1,914
    Originally posted by Pezhead

    Originally posted by GiveMePvP
     
    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

     12 million WoW subs says otherwise

     

    Britney Spears as sold over 80 million records worldwide but I personally wouldn't consider it good music.

    According to RPG Vault Maple Story has around 50 million subscribers worldwide.  So using your logic this would make Maple Story's graphics almost 5x better than WoW.

    Personally I think it's a case where people can overlook not having the best graphics when the game will run decent on their system and they find it fun.

    "There is as yet insufficient data for a meaningful answer."

  • GiveMePvPGiveMePvP Member Posts: 240
    Originally posted by Pezhead

    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by SupderD


    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

     

    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

     

    12 million WoW subs says otherwise

     

    WoW was the first mainstream MMO. Its' not a game, it's a social phenomenon. Rules that apply with other MMO's don't apply with WoW.

    Remember this old marketing saying: "It's better to be first then to be better".

    I do believe if WoW would launch today, people would absolutely hate it. It would probably get 10k subscriptions and go FTP after the first month. Gamers expectations are different today then what they were when WoW launched.

  • jy88902jy88902 Member Posts: 293
    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by Pezhead

    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by SupderD


    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

     

    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

     

    12 million WoW subs says otherwise

     

    WoW was the first mainstream MMO. Its' not a game, it's a social phenomenon. Rules that apply with other MMO's don't apply with WoW.

    Remember this old marketing saying: "It's better to be first then to be better".

    I do believe if WoW would launch today, people would absolutely hate it. It would probably get 10k subscriptions and go FTP after the first month. Gamers expectations are different today then what they were when WoW launched.

    Just like how Diablo and starcraft with their 20th century graphics would get put into the bargain bin if it released today right?

    Do you have any idea what common sense is?

     

  • GiveMePvPGiveMePvP Member Posts: 240
    Originally posted by jy88902

    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by Pezhead

    Originally posted by GiveMePvP

    Originally posted by SupderD


    Gameplay.. bu t that doesn't mean the graphics have to suck either.

     

    Problem is that most gamers think anything less than single player rpg graphics = graphics suck. They want it all and they don't understand why they can't have it.

     

    12 million WoW subs says otherwise

     

    WoW was the first mainstream MMO. Its' not a game, it's a social phenomenon. Rules that apply with other MMO's don't apply with WoW.

    Remember this old marketing saying: "It's better to be first then to be better".

    I do believe if WoW would launch today, people would absolutely hate it. It would probably get 10k subscriptions and go FTP after the first month. Gamers expectations are different today then what they were when WoW launched.

    Just like how Diablo and starcraft with their 20th century graphics would get put into the bargain bin if it released today right?

    Do you have any idea what common sense is?

     

     

    Do you have any idea what I was trying to say? I guess not.

Sign In or Register to comment.