Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

X-Box or Playstation 2?

EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384

Ok, I need to buy one of these consoles (not both) as my new job pretty much means that I have to know a lot about console games (although I do know alot about these games, it would be nice to have a console to go with my games...which I get for free now)

I know the bad points and the good points of both. For example

X Box

Good -- You can pretty much customize the inside of the console, etc etc. Also the graphics on an X-Box is a bit better than a PS 2

Bad -- Since Bill Gates tend to be greedy, he only wants games to be on his console and noone elses....which basically means less games as game developers tend not to like being confind to one console only.

Play Station 2

Good -- Sheer amount of games is staggering. A lot more RPG games in PS2 compared to Xbox (which seems to be mostly Sports and FPS/military games...for the most part). Also the system is backwards compatable which means it can play both Ps2 and Ps1 games. When PS3 comes out they can play PS3, PS2, PS1 games, etc

Bad -- Since I now have a geforce 6500 vid card, the graphics in a playstation really looks dumb down.


PSP and Nintendo DS:

I don't need any of these as I have a Pocket PC that has a better video card, memory, and speed than both of them put together...now PocketPC just needs to make more games.


What do you all think? Xbox or PS2?

People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

«1

Comments

  • SerienSerien Member CommonPosts: 8,460

    If you buy xbox, we can play together on xbox live!

    and you can meet practically my whole school! lol

    (what I'm aiming at is that xbox live's community is a lot larger and better than ps2's)

     

  • methane47methane47 Member UncommonPosts: 3,694

    I have to tell you get a PS2... because there are just soo much more good games then on XBox....

    If i think about the really good games for XBox i could probably name them all...
    If you ask me to name all the good games for PS2 i would settlle for killing myself to end the pain, Just too much going through my head....

    Definitely go for PS2.

    image
    What's your Wu Name?
    Donovan --> Wu Name = Violent Knight
    Methane47 --> Wu Name = Thunderous Leader
    "Some people call me the walking plank, 'cuz any where you go... Death is right behind you.."
    <i>ME<i>

  • admjn65admjn65 Member Posts: 253

    I vote xbox, simply because of
    HALO 2 !!!!!!!!!!!!

    but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2 and supposedly the xbox graphics are better but my 20/20 vision can't really tell the difference.
    It's really a tough call. I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller. ps2 plays dvd's while with xbox u gotta buy the little controller thing for like an extra $30 which is pretty gay.

    again, I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2 (on xbox live)

  • methane47methane47 Member UncommonPosts: 3,694


    Originally posted by admjn65
    I vote xbox, simply because of
    HALO 2 !!!!!!!!!!!!but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2 and supposedly the xbox graphics are better but my 20/20 vision can't really tell the difference.
    It's really a tough call. I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller. ps2 plays dvd's while with xbox u gotta buy the little controller thing for like an extra $30 which is pretty gay. again, I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2 (on xbox live)

    "but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2"
    I have to argue against that statment... well unless you're talking about sports games...

    "supposedly the xbox graphics are better"
    This is true.... Morrowind is just BEAUTIFULL

    "I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller"
    Definitely argue this... Unless you're talking about the smaller controller... which in that case they both have their strengths and weaknesses...

    "I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2"
    Well I can't call you wrong for that.. Halo 2 is awesome....

    image
    What's your Wu Name?
    Donovan --> Wu Name = Violent Knight
    Methane47 --> Wu Name = Thunderous Leader
    "Some people call me the walking plank, 'cuz any where you go... Death is right behind you.."
    <i>ME<i>

  • admjn65admjn65 Member Posts: 253


    Originally posted by methane47
    Originally posted by admjn65
    I vote xbox, simply because of
    HALO 2 !!!!!!!!!!!!but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2 and supposedly the xbox graphics are better but my 20/20 vision can't really tell the difference.
    It's really a tough call. I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller. ps2 plays dvd's while with xbox u gotta buy the little controller thing for like an extra $30 which is pretty gay. again, I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2 (on xbox live)

    "I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller"
    Definitely argue this... Unless you're talking about the smaller controller... which in that case they both have their strengths and weaknesses...





    yea I meant the smaller xbox controller... The reason why I like it more than the playstation controller is because the actual handle part is like fatter, I think it fits in your hands better. and also the left joystick is up higher where on the PS controllers the joysticks are right next to each other. I'm actually running on the cordless Logitech controller, it's very nice!
    ::::09::
  • SerienSerien Member CommonPosts: 8,460



    Originally posted by methane47




    Originally posted by admjn65
    I vote xbox, simply because of
    HALO 2 !!!!!!!!!!!!

    but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2 and supposedly the xbox graphics are better but my 20/20 vision can't really tell the difference.
    It's really a tough call. I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller. ps2 plays dvd's while with xbox u gotta buy the little controller thing for like an extra $30 which is pretty gay.
    again, I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2 (on xbox live)


    "but besides that you can generally find the same games on xbox as on PS2"
    I have to argue against that statment... well unless you're talking about sports games...

    "supposedly the xbox graphics are better"
    This is true.... Morrowind is just BEAUTIFULL

    "I think the xbox controller has a nicer feeling than Playstation controller"
    Definitely argue this... Unless you're talking about the smaller controller... which in that case they both have their strengths and weaknesses...

    "I'd say xbox just cuz of halo2"
    Well I can't call you wrong for that.. Halo 2 is awesome....



    Controllers aren't an issue

    get the "Smart Joy keyboard and mouse adapter" I'm ordering it soon.

  • KiamdeKiamde Member CommonPosts: 5,820


    Originally posted by Serien
    If you buy xbox, we can play together on xbox live!
    and you can meet practically my whole school! lol
    (what I'm aiming at is that xbox live's community is a lot larger and better than ps2's)


    That would be boring since right now you only talk on vent when you are asked a question.::::39::

    I would not buy a system if I were you. The next gen systems are all coming out in QIIII-QI2006 so I am saving for one of those babies...most likely the next gen PS.

    "Whoever controls the media controls the mind..-'Jim Morrison"

    "When decorum is repression, the only dignity free men have is to speak out." ~Abbie Hoffman

  • EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384

    ok PS2 seems to be in the lead


    I may get that

    People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

  • OrccOrcc Member Posts: 3,043

    I love my PS2. For one it has a lot more games and a lot more companies backing it up, and online is free. You dont need to pay monthly/yearly like with Xbox live. Just have to buy the network adapter and youre good to go.

    image
  • grimweepergrimweeper Member Posts: 2,047
    trust me ps2 is WAY over-rated

    image

    image
  • methane47methane47 Member UncommonPosts: 3,694

    "trust me ps2 is WAY over-rated"

    LOL

    Wow i dont think anyone is overrating the PS2
    We all know that XBox is more powerfull than the PS2 and no-one is doubting that...
    But hey look at the numbers and sales figures... they must speak for something... PS2 may not be the strongest thing on the market... But if games were a weapon GameCube would have a PP7, Xbox would have a lazer, but Playstation would have a BFG....

    And we all know what a BFG is

    image
    What's your Wu Name?
    Donovan --> Wu Name = Violent Knight
    Methane47 --> Wu Name = Thunderous Leader
    "Some people call me the walking plank, 'cuz any where you go... Death is right behind you.."
    <i>ME<i>

  • SatansDiscipleSatansDisciple Member Posts: 2,782

    Well, buying the Xbox for online is dumb if you already have a good gaming PC (seriously, what the hell Murt!). PS2 has alot more games, and though the graphics aren't as good, they are generally more fun. That and you also open up the vast library of PS1 games, which I have recently gone back to (PS1 RPG's rock!). So... PS2 is my vote.

    --------------------------------------
    image

  • Rikimaru_XRikimaru_X Member UncommonPosts: 11,718



    Originally posted by En1Gma
    X Box
    Good -- You can pretty much customize the inside of the console, etc etc. Also the graphics on an X-Box is a bit better than a PS 2
    Bad -- Since Bill Gates tend to be greedy, he only wants games to be on his console and noone elses....which basically means less games as game developers tend not to like being confind to one console only.




    I am really tired of people saying the X-box is bad becuase of Bill Gates. He didn't even make the X-Box! Don't you think every game system or should I say ever product is made with the need for money? Money = Exictment, usage, etc. Money makes the world go round. I don't know . . . If you don't have an X-Box, don't judge it based of other peoples opinions. It's just degrading the fact that you beleive what comes out of everyones mouth and I'm suprised to hear this from you En1. Oh yeah, hope your not running on microsoft. If you think Gates made that out of greed (well, he did kinda "stole" from Apple (or was it IBM...)) you might as well stop using that computer. No offence man but I'm tired of the "false" hate going to X-Box.

    -In memory of Laura "Taera" Genender. Passed away on Aug/13/08-
    |
    RISING DRAGOON ~AION US ONLINE LEGION for Elyos

  • vestanivestani Member Posts: 28

    Voiding my opinion.

  • vestanivestani Member Posts: 28

    Voiding my opinion.

  • Rikimaru_XRikimaru_X Member UncommonPosts: 11,718



    Originally posted by vestani

     
    ***X-box has a good handful of RPGs and some on the way. KOTOR/KOTOR II was great and Jade Empire/Still life is also on the way.



    Don't forget that X-Box has one of their best selling RPG's The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind. Platnum Hit. (I don't think Fable has beaten it yet)

    -In memory of Laura "Taera" Genender. Passed away on Aug/13/08-
    |
    RISING DRAGOON ~AION US ONLINE LEGION for Elyos

  • FinweFinwe Member CommonPosts: 3,106



    Originally posted by Rikimaru_X



    Originally posted by vestani

     
    ***X-box has a good handful of RPGs and some on the way. KOTOR/KOTOR II was great and Jade Empire/Still life is also on the way.


    Don't forget that X-Box has one of their best selling RPG's The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind. Platnum Hit. (I don't think Fable has beaten it yet)


    Which both KoTOR and Morrowind are on the PC. So it makes it pretty worthless.

    Unless your PC is archaic.

    "The greatest trick the devil played on humanity in the 20th century was convincing them that he didn't exist." (Paraphrasing) C.S. Lewis

    "If a mother can kill her own child, what is left before I kill you and you kill me?" -Mother Teresa when talking about abortion after accepting the Nobel Peace Prize in 1979

  • EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384


    Originally posted by Gunblade
    Your comment about your pocket PC is hilarious to..."If only they came out with more games" your multimedia and speed of your Pocket PC is irrlevant to games almost. The nintendo DS and PSP regardless of tech specs kick the shit out of your Pocket PC in terms of gaming. However your Pocket PC does a hella lot more usefull stuff than the those two. Browse teh web, documents, cellphone, etc...The difference is one is made for gaming the other is for work. Last why no gamecube? Cause that is a great console to.


    While I do appreciate your comments, I have to disagree about the PocketPC. Mine is literally better than the PSP (yes, in terms of gaming too).

    Here are the specs:

    Processor
    Bullet Intel® XScaleTM PXA270 624MHz

    Operating System
    Bullet Microsoft® Windows MobileTM 2003 Second Edition with Windows Media Player 10 Mobile

    Memory
    Bullet RAM: 64MB SDRAM
    Bullet ROM: 128MB Intel StrataFlash® memory

    Display
    Bullet TFT Color 16-bit, Touch Sensitive, Transflective LCD
    Bullet 3.7 inches
    Bullet 480 x 640 resolution at 65,536 colors (VGA)

    Graphics
    Bullet Intel® 2700G multimedia accelerator with 16MB video memory

    Control and Lights
    Bullet 5-way Navigation button
    Bullet Wireless On/Off Button
    Lock Switch
    Bullet 4 Program Buttons: Calendar, Contacts, Inbox, Home
    Bullet Voice Record Button
    Bullet Reset Button
    Bullet Backlit Power Button
    Bullet Event Notification
    Bullet Charge Status
    Bullet Wireless Status

    Expansion Slots
    Bullet 1 CompactFlash Type II Card Slot (3.3v)
    Bullet 1 Secure Digital / SDIO Now / MMC Memory Card Slot (3.3v)

    Ports and Connectors
    Bullet Standard v1.2 (115 kbps) Infrared Port
    Bullet 36-pin Cradle/Sync Connector
    Bullet 3.5mm Headphone/Headset Jack

    Dimensions
    Bullet Length 119 mm (4.7 inches)
    Bullet Width 73 mm (2.9 inches)
    Bullet Height 16.9 mm (0.7 inches)
    Bullet Weight 175 grams (6.2 oz)

    Audio
    Bullet Audio Controller I2S Codec, WM8750 sound chip
    Bullet Stereo Conversion 16-bit stereo; 8.0, 11.025, 22.05 and 44.1KHz sample rate
    Bullet Full Duplex Record and Playback
    Bullet Integrated Microphone and Speaker

    image

    Not that I am bashing the PSP...I like the PSP...but buying one is sorta pointless for me. Also, there are a ton of games being developed for the Microsoft portable platform right now....since Im not in a hurry for portable gaming, PSP is out of the question.

    Why I don't consider the gamecube? Well, for the most part a good majority of all games developed for the gamecube are geared towards kids. Just the sheer amount of younger kids buying gamecube games versus the PS2 and Xbox at my store shows me that.

    Also, the speed and graphic performance really isn't that significantly more than the Nintendo 64. I just bought the Nintendo 64 for 14 bucks plus Mario Smash(?), Legend of Zelda Ocarina of time, Rogue Squadron, Megaman 64, SHadows of the EMpire, Turok 1 and 2, Golden Eye, and Mario 64 for another 15 bucks total and my kid loves it (so do I lol).

    So, while I don't think the game cube sucks in any way, I just don't want it. (even though Resident Evil 4 is for it)

    People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

  • EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384


    Originally posted by Rikimaru_X

    I am really tired of people saying the X-box is bad becuase of Bill Gates. He didn't even make the X-Box! Don't you think every game system or should I say ever product is made with the need for money? Money = Exictment, usage, etc. Money makes the world go round. I don't know . . . If you don't have an X-Box, don't judge it based of other peoples opinions. It's just degrading the fact that you beleive what comes out of everyones mouth and I'm suprised to hear this from you En1. Oh yeah, hope your not running on microsoft. If you think Gates made that out of greed (well, he did kinda "stole" from Apple (or was it IBM...)) you might as well stop using that computer. No offence man but I'm tired of the "false" hate going to X-Box.

    Well, can you explain why the game ratio of Xbox and PS2 is like 1:8? There are easily 8 times more games in PS2 than in Xbox. And very good titles too.

    I didn't mean to slam Bill Gates, but why is the X-Box so picky with wanting "X-Box only developers"?

    People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

  • vestanivestani Member Posts: 28

    Voiding my opinion.

  • methane47methane47 Member UncommonPosts: 3,694


    Originally posted by Rikimaru_X
    Oh yeah, hope your not running on microsoft. If you think Gates made that out of greed (well, he did kinda "stole" from Apple (or was it IBM...)) you might as well stop using that computer.X-Box.

    Hmm i dont really know about that comment....
    Because #1 Microsoft doesn't make computers..
    they just make the OS And there are plenty of other OS's besides Windows
    #2 Gates actually put in millions of dollors into Apple in the late nineties...
    Apple was dieing and Microsoft gave them the help they needed to bring them to where they are now....

    image
    What's your Wu Name?
    Donovan --> Wu Name = Violent Knight
    Methane47 --> Wu Name = Thunderous Leader
    "Some people call me the walking plank, 'cuz any where you go... Death is right behind you.."
    <i>ME<i>

  • vestanivestani Member Posts: 28


    Originally posted by Gunblade
    Plus I saw somone post that the xbox is totally awsome for adventure? What are you joking?

    I own around 40 X-box titles. Over half of them I would consider action/adventure. You typed "totally awesome" I didn't. So much for giving my completely unbiased two cents about the system I own. This thread is turning into a pissing contest for a piece of plastic and metal bits. Or, perhaps a three page consumer support group for people who need positive reinforcement behind their initial purchase.

  • vestanivestani Member Posts: 28

    Voiding my opinion.

  • SaigonshakesSaigonshakes Member Posts: 937

    X-Box.

  • SerienSerien Member CommonPosts: 8,460

    I see a lot of people are voting for ps2 because of the single player games. I myself have almost no fun in single player games, online is the way to go for me.

    And frankly, xbox live does tower over ps2 connect (or whatever it's called) There's just a more advanced online community, adding more fun to games.

    If you like to socialize and play online = XBOX (if so, my gamertag is "Serien")

    If you like single player games = ps2

Sign In or Register to comment.