Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

If you havent done so, please go redo review for SWG. No way this game deserves a 7.0

Friend of mine visited this site to see what potential mmorpg might be next to play. He noticed the rating of 7.0 and assumed my opinion was biased.

After 2 days playing the free trial he realized how right I was and how wrong that rating score is. Do new players a favor and redo your review. Im sure many (like me previously) forgot to change their score. Heck, my score was an 8.2 because the review was unchanged since Oct 2003

«1

Comments

  • scaramooshscaramoosh Member Posts: 3,424

    You didn't look at the score it deserves then, because they rereviewed it!

     

    Maybe you thought it deserved higher that what they gave the NGE.

    ---------------------------------------------
    image
    Don't click here...no2

  • RekrulRekrul Member Posts: 2,961

    7.0 from review, 7.0 from players. Although vets would rate it much lower.

    And if it weren't Star Wars, it would be much lower.

    Sad thing is, not much has changed since the review. Last publish fixed a few bugs, added a few specials, but it's a drop in the ocean of incompletness.

    If there were a category of unfulfilled promises, it would rank 11.

    Compared to other games, it is a much worse product. But if you like it, one review shouldn't bother you.

  • cumbomcumbom Member CommonPosts: 544

    I redid mine the day NGE went live I gave it a whopping 0

    SWG RIP
    moctodumegws
    Can't WAIT!

  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    I have done so.

    /sign

    COME ON PEOPLE GET OVER THERE AND DO IT.

    It takes a couple seconds.

  • azgarthazgarth Member UncommonPosts: 188
    I know what you mean, but we only reviewed the started kit Pos NGE, so what you are seeing is the reviews of the early game.
  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    how the hell is it rated at 7.0?????

    goal: get it below 6.0

  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    /bump

    COME ONE - how is it possible that SWG still has a 7.0?

  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    move it move it move it move it

    the SW community can make its own mini movies...but we cant get the rating under 6.0?????

    ::::12::

  • dolaniousdolanious Member Posts: 186

    I like this thread, everyone who is a member of this site should review this game.

    I tried giving it all zeros (justifiably) but the lowest I can go seems to be all ones? Anyone tell me how I can make them zeros?

  • rq542rq542 Member Posts: 11

    I was just about to redo my review, but i havent been here for a while and i don't have enough points. now i have to post things and such to redo the review, because i said the same things, no way that this game deserves a 7.0 after NGE.

  • digrizdigriz Member Posts: 254

    Should pre-NGE reviews be allowed to stay posted?? The game doesn't exist as it once did. It is a different game. Powers That Be, can they be deleted? Then at least anyone using this site to research the game would have a more up to date overview of the game itself. image

    [edit] to strengthen this arguement, i just ordered DAoC on the basis of this sites reviews and would be a tad upset to load it up and  find that there had been upgrades changing the game beyond the all recognition from the reviews. If i were not a regular here, the overall rating page would have been my first port of call.

  • Neurox1Neurox1 Member Posts: 260

    i think we should give ALL soe games ratings of 1's to be honest ... that how much i think the company sucks ...

    and now SOE is trying to destroy city of heros/villains with its new Bullsh*t DC comic universe game ...

    more license BULLSH*T.. to sucks players away from GOOD games to follow the franchises they've been fans of since their little ...

     

  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    /BUMP


    Come on ... this needs to get done.

  • NasindorNasindor Member Posts: 67

    I gave this game an honest assessment, and a review. I saw the "passing grade" it had, and thought, this is utterly ridiculous. In all honesty, I had to rate graphics kinda high, cause even if SOE ruined the game, the graphics are still pretty good in my opinion, but I threw alot of 1s and 2 for the obvious fatal flaws that SOE injected into "the best MMORPG ever made", converting it to trash data, deserving to be scrubbed from their servers, and replaced with Divix episodes of Barney.

    For the record, I don't look into any new MMORPG anymore without giving various Forum pages a thorough scan, to see just how much the Company developing the game is working with those players posting legitimate concerns. If I see a # of flames that reach a threshold, I write it off as a no-go.

  • @Large@Large Member Posts: 101

    ..

  • duncan_922duncan_922 Member Posts: 1,670
    I did mine... It's down to 6.9 now!

    SOE knows what you like... You don't!
    And don't forget... I am forcing you to read this!

  • GkarrGkarr Member UncommonPosts: 46

    /agree - Already changed my rating months ago. $OE = image

    /bump

  • pirrgpirrg Member Posts: 1,443

    10's across the board. Great game.

    _____________________
    I am the flipside of the coin on which the troll and the fanboy are but one side.

  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    COME ON COME ON COME ON

    do what it takes

    we are at 6.9 !!!!

  • ArvadArvad Member Posts: 107
    Star Wars Galaxies Sci-Fi LucasArts / SOE Final Released
    makeBars(6.9,0,'6.9',1,0)
    6.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.9
    6.9
    image
    Dragon Raja Fantasy Esofnet Final Released
    makeBars(6.9,0,'6.9',1,0)
    6.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.9
    6.9
    image
    KAL Online Fantasy Inixsoft Final Released
    makeBars(6.9,0,'6.9',1,0)
    6.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.9
    6.9
    image
    Mystic Journey: Fairyland USA Fantasy CiB Net Station Final Released
    makeBars(6.9,0,'6.9',1,0)
    6.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.96.9
    6.9

     

    MMORPG.COM 6.9 standings for a reference.

    "Fairyland USA", that's cracking me up. ROFL

     

  • SonOfAGhostSonOfAGhost Member Posts: 383


    Originally posted by Arvad
    "Fairyland USA", that's cracking me up. ROFL
     

    San Francisco?

  • anarchyartanarchyart Member Posts: 5,378



    Originally posted by cumbom

    I redid mine the day NGE went live I gave it a whopping 0



    You think WoW is the best MMORPG so far? **** that. Anyways, SWG deserves an 8, SOE and LA deserve the low score for going about the NGE the way they did.

    image
  • maxantomaxanto Member Posts: 778
    I rated it honestly... gave it decent marks for graphics, community (whats left of it) and sound (even though that sw's music played over and over sytarted making me even more crazy at times) but very low marks for, fun, value, and customer service. Over all my rating was a 3.4 if I recall. Yea I think its a fair rating considering.
  • AnkorAnkor Member Posts: 258

    bump

  • pacashe109pacashe109 Member Posts: 41
    you guys know SOE is not gonna change the game so don't worry about it find something else to do its annoying listening to this crap.
Sign In or Register to comment.