Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Is Throne of Chaos the same game as Mouring?

I'm aware that Mourning became Age of Mourning then became Thone of Chaos.  I'm also aware that's there is some dispute as to whether Throne of Chaos is helmed by new developers or it's the same shady guys hiding behind a new name.

MMORPG.com listed Age of Mourning then shortly after, removed them from the list due rudeness and legal threats made by the, supposedly new,  Mourning developers.   Now the game is called Throne of Chaos and is not listed on this site, as one might imagine.

Here's the weird part, I just saw an ad, a "special offer", on this very site, for Throne of Chaos.  This game is still, as far as I can find, not listed on this site yet they have ads here?   Given what happened between the MMORPG.com staff and the Mourning/Throne of Choas people, this seems very strange to me. 

So what has happened?   If Throne of Chaos is really under new mangement then why not list it since their ads are here anyway?   But if it's the same old scammers from Mouring running the show, why has MMORPG.com allowed them to advertise on this site?

Any info would be appeciated.   Thanks.


Comments

  • DamonVileDamonVile Member UncommonPosts: 4,818
       Here's a long thread from the New Devs of ToC

    i r a noob and can't get it as a hyperlink sorry you'll have to copy and past it.

    http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/thread/87465





  • TorakTorak Member Posts: 4,905


    Originally posted by DamonVile
       Here's a long thread from the New Devs of ToC

    i r a noob and can't get it as a hyperlink sorry you'll have to copy and past it.

    http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/thread/87465


    Put a space after the link
  • OculitusOculitus Member Posts: 203
    Thanks for the link.   Obviously, I missed that thread.

    Still, it seems strange that MMORPG.com would let them put ads up but not list the game.  I guess it's a matter of "we don't like enough to give you free publicty, but we're willing to let you pay us for some."


  • OwynOwyn Member Posts: 337
    No, it's more a matter of "this is an entirely new team that bought the game from the jerks who originally were such a problem, let's give them the benefit of the doubt."

    It seems at least like this new crew is totally unrelated to the old dev group.  It hardly seems fair to blame the new folks for the old owners' misdeeds.  They're planning to set it up with a free trial - NO credit cards to try it, specifically because of the scam the old owners pulled.  They came on these forums - which are definately Mourning-hostile-central! - to answer questions directly, which impressed me.

    I'm still skeptical about TOC, mind you, but I'll keep an open mind til I see the game.


    Owyn
    Commander, Defenders of Order
    http://www.defendersoforder.com

  • DeletedAcctDeletedAcct Member Posts: 883


    Originally posted by Oculitus
    Thanks for the link. Obviously, I missed that thread.Still, it seems strange that MMORPG.com would let them put ads up but not list the game. I guess it's a matter of "we don't like enough to give you free publicty, but we're willing to let you pay us for some."

    At this point, they have shown nothing different from the last devs except a better social grace when fleecing, er, I mean convincing people to give them a shot. So for now, no. They can pay all they want but they do not deserve to be listed here.

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182

    Altough they say otherwise, I personally think its the exact same company. As I have seen posters in diffrent forums (other then mmorpg.com, but it happens here as well) that randomly post the link to www.throneofchaos.com in new threads. now I know every game has its fans, but I have never seen a vanguard fan post a link to the vanguard website in diffrent forums in new threads, all starting: "this is a true pvp mmo" or "this is a much better game".. or a Warhammer online fan. if you ask me, its the same company with the same dirty trick.
  • KhaelSUNKhaelSUN Member Posts: 394

    Ya it's pretty weird, over on the Darkfall boards, alot of new posters have started showing up posting links to TOC hyping it like there was no tomorrow - it's quite annoying... It might just be clueless fanbois, but we haven't been bothered before, and now they are suddenly all over the place.

    image

    Khael[SUN]
    SUN - peekayin since pong
    Webdeveloper on:
    http://www.guildofsun.com
    http://www.bloodmonarchy.com

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182


    Originally posted by KhaelSan

    Ya it's pretty weird, over on the Darkfall boards, alot of new posters have started showing up posting links to TOC hyping it like there was no tomorrow - it's quite annoying... It might just be clueless fanbois, but we haven't been bothered before, and now they are suddenly all over the place.


    Well It also started to apear on the codemasters forums. all starting with "this is a better pvp game: www.throneofchaos.com". I doubt these are just clueless fanbois, I think they are staff members.
  • paadepaade Member Posts: 471
    If i remember right, last time it was listed here, they (developers) said its a whole new group of people making the game. That was the reason they got listed again, they lied to mmorpg.com staff about this. Later the staff found out that it was infact the very same group of assholes as before and they got booted again.
    And this was just couple of months ago, so in that time the old team quit but managed to find a new developers to continue making the game?

    Everything is of course possible but no thx, i dont buy it. Especially when mmorpg.com forums seem to be infested with countless trolls advertising ToC like no tomorrow.

    Its still Egomancer & Co.
  • OculitusOculitus Member Posts: 203
    Frankly, I assumed that Throne of Chaos and Mourning were the same people.  But regardless of what I think, I can't determine what MMORPG.com's postition is.   Call me naive, but it should be fairly black and white.  

    If MMORPG.com believes that Loud Ant and Throne of Chaos are really completely different people from those Mourning folks, then they're a legit game and company and should be listed along with allowing them to advertise.

    If MMORPG.com thinks, or at least suspects, that the Throne aof Chaos and  Mourning devs are still the same con artists, then they are right not to list them, but should clearly not allow their ads on this site.   To do so would be hypocritcal and irresponsible.

    Putting  their ads up without listing them makes little sense to me.   It sends a mixed message.  Perhaps MMORPG.com is unsure as to what is the truth.   Even still, I'd appeciate it if they took some postion even if they don't yet know all the facts.


  • BuZZKilgoreBuZZKilgore Member Posts: 525

    I'll bet this game will be released sooner or later (probably later) but will be in a terrible unplayable, unfinished state (just like Roma-Victor). Only the hardest-core fanbois will be saying "just give it time it has potential" (just like Roma-Victor). The game will lose what little fan support it has and fold (just like Roma-Victor is going to).

    I do hope they release the game and just get it over with.

  • TorakTorak Member Posts: 4,905

    Roma-Victor released???

    That snuck in under the radar.....So I'm guessing it didn't go good, BuZZKilgore? I guess we can chalk it up to another "quality release" I can use to bang over the heads of people who claim western games are so superior lol.

    Thats to bad, there where alot of people watching this game to. Boo for devs making more crappy, incomplete games.

  • abbabaabbaba Member Posts: 1,143


    Originally posted by BuZZKilgore

    I'll bet this game will be released sooner or later (probably later) but will be in a terrible unplayable, unfinished state (just like Roma-Victor). Only the hardest-core fanbois will be saying "just give it time it has potential" (just like Roma-Victor). The game will lose what little fan support it has and fold (just like Roma-Victor is going to).
    I do hope they release the game and just get it over with.



    Wow, you really hate Roma Victor...do you need a hug?

    D&L is the king of failure when it comes to MMORPGs.

  • BuZZKilgoreBuZZKilgore Member Posts: 525


    Originally posted by Torak

    Roma-Victor released???
    That snuck in under the radar.....So I'm guessing it didn't go good, BuZZKilgore? I guess we can chalk it up to another "quality release" I can use to bang over the heads of people who claim western games are so superior lol.
    Thats to bad, there where alot of people watching this game to. Boo for devs making more crappy, incomplete games.


    Yeah it released but it's still in Alpha (if you know what I meen). Head on over to the RV forums and check it out. There's a couple of fanbois over there who are good for a laugh or two.
  • ShrubberShrubber Member Posts: 219

    I guess I am not the only one getting fun emails from londant.:)

    I find the whole thing strange so far. The first post (someone already linked) wasn't in anyway about truth and honesty. It was shameless advertising for the new mourning. Besides that, loudant was very unable to answer the questions of me, Norked and others. These were about a lack of named publisher, lack of any creditations (shell companies), strange advertments for programmers and lack of a real location (google map and other mapping programs return nothing or private one-room homes).

    These new trolls that have shown up advertsing Mourning are strange as well. This Phil guy is recommending ToC constantly and flaming similar mmorpgs.

  • SuitepeeSuitepee Member Posts: 921

    Well we have 7-8 months to find out. (Q1 2007 release date)

  • JelloB2000JelloB2000 Member CommonPosts: 1,848

    Same game? YES , Quote: "We are looking for volunteers to work full-time or part-time to finish Thrones of Chaos. The title has been in development for 4 years and is around 90 percent finished; it has cost nearly 1.5 million to develop thus far." from http://greenville.craigslist.org/sof/?displayMode=printFriendly

    Same team? My bet is yes, mmorpg.com says no (but has been a yes in the past).

  • lysandinglysanding Member Posts: 154

    "Ya it's pretty weird, over on the Darkfall boards, alot of new posters have started showing up posting links to TOC hyping it like "

    what about the Age of Conan Dev that was making posts on the darkfall boards??  and if you don't believe that theres an archived post on the AoC forums where a Funcom company guy actually confirmed it was TRUE. no one seems to be talking shit about that "100% FACT".  because no one cares cause darkfall is vapor i guess.


    Same game? YES , Quote: "We are looking for volunteers to work full-time or part-time to finish Thrones of Chaos. The title has been in development for 4 years and is around 90 percent finished; it has cost nearly 1.5 million to develop thus far." from http://greenville.craigslist.org/sof/?displayMode=printFriendly



     

    LoudAntSoftware
    vbmenu_register("postmenu_1980", true);

    Developer

    in a childish attempt to make us look bad. Craiglist already removed the numerous posts in question and is investigating the issue. I would suggest letting them know that taking part in activities like this is not only extremely non productive but does also include a hefty fine by craiglist.



    Besides that, loudant was very unable to answer the questions of me, Norked and others.

    why does anyone need to answer your quesions? who are you?   and why do you need an office building to build a game???  if 20 ex blizzard guys got together to build a game and didn't have an "official" building somewhere would it make any difference??   no.    A building doesnt give people skills.

  • JelloB2000JelloB2000 Member CommonPosts: 1,848


    Originally posted by lysanding
    (...)
    LoudAntSoftware
    vbmenu_register("postmenu_1980", true);
    Developer
    You may not have but the individuals at the mentioned site surely have done so and also linked back to said post on their site which is still listed on the main page in a childish attempt to make us look bad. It's plain as day.
    Craiglist already removed the numerous posts in question and is investigating the issue. I would suggest letting them know that taking part in activities like this is not only extremely non productive but does also include a hefty fine by craiglist.
    and on this note I will be closing this thread because I do not really see much good coming of it any longer.(end forum text).Besides that, loudant was very unable to answer the questions of me, Norked and others.
    (...)

    http://www.thronesofchaos.com/community/showthread.php?t=233&page=2&highlight=craig

    Thats the thread (& I added the entire post), the dev thinks mmorpg.com users put up the craigslist ad & thinks its "a childish attempt to make us look bad. It's plain as day." Well Im convinced he has had pr-training from Egomancer.

    Cant see why that thread got locked since it was a discussion about open-gl versus direct-x (& was good) until Rapture started taking a dump on the thread (which didnt even get a warning? heh), looks like D&L-moderators have a new challenger for "moderator discretion" in official game forums.

  • SuitepeeSuitepee Member Posts: 921


    Originally posted by lysanding

    what about the Age of Conan Dev that was making posts on the darkfall boards??  and if you don't believe that theres an archived post on the AoC forums where a Funcom company guy actually confirmed it was TRUE. no one seems to be talking shit about that "100% FACT". 


    Yeah,when I posted my intro on the ToC forums I was told about this. Seems VERY unprofessional of them to go around criticising Darkfall and then making hash apologies. (I'd still love to see the posts on that)

    Something tells me it was an act of 'fear'. (of competition?) A shallow assumption,but why else bother? AoC has huge support,moreso than Darkfall at the moment I would reckon. No need to act like fools. It'd be like ToC fanboys flaming on the Darkfall forums. (hint hint!) Only harms your own game end of day.

    Regardless,I never saw AoM,so I'll be judging this game on its individual merits. I must admit though for a game with a Q1 2007 release date (giving them 7-8 months in theory),there does appear to be a HUGE GAP missing information-wise. Of course,in 7-8 months,if not less there could be a running beta of ToC.

Sign In or Register to comment.