Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

What do you think the subscriber floor is for them to do classic servers?

Wildcat84Wildcat84 Member Posts: 2,304
It's pretty apparent that they are returning pre-NGE features based on how low the subscriptions fall, not based on what we want.  We all recall when the Devs said these things would never be re-implimented:

1. Firing specials from the keyboard
2. Target locking
3. Auto aim
4. Auto fire
5. Resizable radar
6. Double toolbar rows

They still say "NGE is here to stay" but they said that about the CU as well.  They keep saying no classic servers, no multiclassing, no combat queue, no new professions, etc, but I think everything is on the table as the subscriptions continue to fall.

So, at what threshold do you think they do classic servers, which is clearly the quickest and easiest way to boost subscribers at this point?



«1

Comments

  • RekrulRekrul Member Posts: 2,961
    The classic servers would need to attract between 2-6k for a frozen, fixed publish, 1 server pre-cu version.

    The rest depends on the license.



  • tjvoodootjvoodoo Member Posts: 293
    Atm i would have to vote never not even by (quack quack) looks like another duck got shot for dinner .

  • ObraikObraik Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,261

    Yeah, they said they wouldn't roll back to pre-cu from the CU and they didn't ;)  They're more likely to do another overhaul then revert to classic servers.

    I'm honestly not seeing the "dramatically decreasing populations" you keep posting about, at least on Chilastra anyway.  People are re-subbing to check out the new stuff that comes with each publish.  Before you say they're not staying, that doesn't matter.  They've paid for at least a months subscription and that counts towards the total.  Chapter 2 impressed alot of people and there were posts all over the forums from people expressing this.  If they get Chapter 3 right with the smuggling system, it's guaranteed to bring in ex-smugglers to check it out.  Whether they like it is a different topic.  Chapter 4 is going to be another high-profile thing with the Crafter revamp and a supposed new high end content area.

    image

    image

  • Wildcat84Wildcat84 Member Posts: 2,304


    Originally posted by Rekrul
    The classic servers would need to attract between 2-6k for a frozen, fixed publish, 1 server pre-cu version.

    The rest depends on the license.





    It wouldn't stay that way for long.  When the population shifted to the classic servers (which we know it would), they'd have to start work on it, at least in backporting the expansions and other stuff from the NGE that we'd want (such as the quests and the battlefields).

  • Wildcat84Wildcat84 Member Posts: 2,304


    Originally posted by Obraik

    Yeah, they said they wouldn't roll back to pre-cu from the CU and they didn't ;)  They're more likely to do another overhaul then revert to classic servers.
    I'm honestly not seeing the "dramatically decreasing populations" you keep posting about, at least on Chilastra anyway.  People are re-subbing to check out the new stuff that comes with each publish.  Before you say they're not staying, that doesn't matter.  They've paid for at least a months subscription and that counts towards the total.  Chapter 2 impressed alot of people and there were posts all over the forums from people expressing this.  If they get Chapter 3 right with the smuggling system, it's guaranteed to bring in ex-smugglers to check it out.  Whether they like it is a different topic.  Chapter 4 is going to be another high-profile thing with the Crafter revamp and a supposed new high end content area.


    I saw a surge of new people on Bloodfin (which has always been a larger server than yours, btw) when Restuss came out, then a smaller one when this publish came out.  But the active population is quickly sinking back to what it was before both.  I'm even playing less, and I'm right now deciding which accounts to get rid of, I can't justify all of them anymore, especially since only my Jedi and BH are worth even bringing to a fight now, and they are both on one account.

    Right now you can't find populations anywhere except Eisley.  You might run into some people at a battlefield, and that's about it.  Restuss is dead, overrun by NPC's.


  • ebenholtebenholt Member Posts: 312

    My gut actually say never as to SOE might think about the losing face thing... /shrug

    I did choose 40k as to stay afloat a MMO that sold +1 mill boxes don't need that many subs to show black numbers instead of red. I read about sub numbers at f13 (think) a while back and the subs needed are extreamly low with a fair box sale in the past

    In this case we are talking Star Wars and as I have no clue to what LECs demands are so...?

    "There are two kinds of spurs, my friend. Those that come in by the door; those that come in by the window"

  • Wildcat84Wildcat84 Member Posts: 2,304


    Originally posted by ebenholt

    My gut actually say never as to SOE might think about the losing face thing... /shrug
    I did choose 40k as to stay afloat a MMO that sold +1 mill boxes don't need that many subs to show black numbers instead of red. I read about sub numbers at f13 (think) a while back and the subs needed are extreamly low with a fair box sale in the past
    In this case we are talking Star Wars and as I have no clue to what LECs demands are so...?


    That is the kicker, LEC.

  • ObraikObraik Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,261


    Originally posted by Wildcat84

    Originally posted by Obraik

    Yeah, they said they wouldn't roll back to pre-cu from the CU and they didn't ;)  They're more likely to do another overhaul then revert to classic servers.
    I'm honestly not seeing the "dramatically decreasing populations" you keep posting about, at least on Chilastra anyway.  People are re-subbing to check out the new stuff that comes with each publish.  Before you say they're not staying, that doesn't matter.  They've paid for at least a months subscription and that counts towards the total.  Chapter 2 impressed alot of people and there were posts all over the forums from people expressing this.  If they get Chapter 3 right with the smuggling system, it's guaranteed to bring in ex-smugglers to check it out.  Whether they like it is a different topic.  Chapter 4 is going to be another high-profile thing with the Crafter revamp and a supposed new high end content area.

    I saw a surge of new people on Bloodfin (which has always been a larger server than yours, btw) when Restuss came out, then a smaller one when this publish came out.  But the active population is quickly sinking back to what it was before both.  I'm even playing less, and I'm right now deciding which accounts to get rid of, I can't justify all of them anymore, especially since only my Jedi and BH are worth even bringing to a fight now, and they are both on one account.

    Right now you can't find populations anywhere except Eisley.  You might run into some people at a battlefield, and that's about it.  Restuss is dead, overrun by NPC's.




    What I've been seeing on the forums contradicts that.  I've seen more "I'm back from XX months" posts this month then I have before.  I've been seeing this in game too with old friends on my friendslist popping online.  Not only that, but I'm seeing more new people at the Legacy hotspots

    image

    image

  • KzinKillerKzinKiller Member Posts: 625
    Classic servers mean new investment, training coders to work on code they've never worked on (since all the pre-CU designers are history).  I don't see it, they'll shut down the whole thing and open SWG-2 before they do classic servers.

    Which I also wouldn't buy from SOE.


    image

  • zoey121zoey121 Member Posts: 926
    there is the whole coding issue and the layers of crud upon layers reguardless of the issue of just dumping data from a set publish date go from there there most likely would be little maintence on it and it would get pretty ugly.

     


  • scaramooshscaramoosh Member Posts: 3,424

    All depends what server your on.The populations are low compared to pre cu.

    I'd reckon about 50k peopel would sub to play pre cu

    ---------------------------------------------
    image
    Don't click here...no2

  • AntariousAntarious Member UncommonPosts: 2,846

    "What I've been seeing on the forums contradicts that.  I've seen more "I'm back from XX months" posts this month then I have before.  I've been seeing this in game too with old friends on my friendslist popping online.  Not only that, but I'm seeing more new people at the Legacy hotspots"

    I can agree with your first response in this thread.  However, in no way can I agree with this comment about the forums.

    There has in the last few days been vets asking question.  This however, has still been far outweighed by the post on:

    Empty Servers

    Finally Quit

    etc etc

    There has been and will be many people that will resub.  Most of them quickly scurry away.  I think anyone that really loved this game is going to come back now and then.  They hope that the game is somehow back with what they loved.

    The problem with that is SOE most likely doesn't see it that way.  They just keep seeing that $15 the person paid for the month.  As long as they keep seeing that there is no reason to really change things.

    Which is why I personally won't resub to even check it out.

    Obviously on the server you play on Obraik you see the population you see there.  The server I played on (starsider) is just not what it was or even close.  The total population you'd find on the server isn't even as high as you would have found in Theed Cantina the day before CU went live.

    That's not even the entire city of Theed or even Coronet.  That's just the cantina and yes it had more people than I can find on the entire server now (well before my accounts cancelled out).

    Driving through player city after player city just to see empty.  Yes I see plenty of building but no players.  I'm sure SOE was losing subscriptions...

    However, what I know is what the game looked like the day before CU and what MY server has looked like since.  CU didn't hurt Starsiders population as bad as the NGE.  It did drop substantially but not like it did with the NGE.

    I can't comment on other servers.  I'm sure someone would like to say how most people in the Cantina were afk entertainers.  Well afk entertainers were still another account paying a monthly which they don't have now.

    Plain and simple...

    They should have just fixed the game they had. 

    The main reason I just can't see myself ever going back.. Is that they removed from the game every part of it that even interested me.  Of course that's just me...  I'm not going to claim it affects your enjoyment or anyone elses.

    I just don't see how anyone can honestly claim or even believe that CU and/or the NGE doesn't have less players subscribed than pre-cu.  Or that the entire game population is on an upswing...

    ((I guess if you play on some server I've never seen that seems to have population you may be able to believe it.  I just also would say based on servers that used to be overly populated and are now basicly empty.. its very hard to believe))

  • RekrulRekrul Member Posts: 2,961


    Originally posted by Obraik





    What I've been seeing on the forums contradicts that.  I've seen more "I'm back from XX months" posts this month then I have before.  I've been seeing this in game too with old friends on my friendslist popping online.  Not only that, but I'm seeing more new people at the Legacy hotspots


    Yes, plenty of that. Read any forum, "Hi, I'm back, so what's ..."

    During the JTL trial around end of 2004, servers were so full, full groups of 20 were going out from Mos Espa. Because all other cities were so full, people lagged out. Bestine was a no-no, Eisley was packed, you had hard time getting anywhere and not running into a bunch of people.

    Yes, people come back, take a look.

    Where are the hordes of newbies, first timers, players enthusiastic about the game, that can't stop playing. Where are the newbie guilds, newbie cities, newbies inviting random people to come see their house? Where are newbies excited about killing a bantha? Killing borvo's elite guard? Where are the newbies setting down a camp, inviting any random passer by, ammasing dozens of people? Where is the Jedi, assembling a group of new players, and taking them out for a hunt to help them gain a few skills? Crafters making stuff for new players? Where are the newbies running around excited telling everyone that Han Solo is cantina? A group of newbies setting up an expedition to Fort Tusken? A group of underequiped players struggling on their way to Sarlacc pit? A newbie completing the Jabba's palace quest, and spending 30 minutes trying to get Bobba to group with him? The horrible disaster that happened when you first ventured out on Dantooine? Or even worse, Endor. Learning about brandy. Getting first armor. First decent weapon. First pet. AT-ST.

    That is what the experience was. The technical quality was always crap. The bugs were always there. But ask anyone to tell you of their experience now. Will they be excited? Will they have anything noteworthy to say? Do they have a story?

    That was the game I played.

    This game is dead.
  • ObraikObraik Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,261


    Originally posted by Antarious

    "What I've been seeing on the forums contradicts that.  I've seen more "I'm back from XX months" posts this month then I have before.  I've been seeing this in game too with old friends on my friendslist popping online.  Not only that, but I'm seeing more new people at the Legacy hotspots"
    I can agree with your first response in this thread.  However, in no way can I agree with this comment about the forums.
    There has in the last few days been vets asking question.  This however, has still been far outweighed by the post on:
    Empty Servers
    Finally Quit
    etc etc
    There has been and will be many people that will resub.  Most of them quickly scurry away.  I think anyone that really loved this game is going to come back now and then.  They hope that the game is somehow back with what they loved.
    The problem with that is SOE most likely doesn't see it that way.  They just keep seeing that $15 the person paid for the month.  As long as they keep seeing that there is no reason to really change things.
    This is what I said :)  It doesn't matter that they only re-subbed for a month, they still put forward money and they still count towards the population until their account runs out.
    Which is why I personally won't resub to even check it out.
    Obviously on the server you play on Obraik you see the population you see there.  The server I played on (starsider) is just not what it was or even close.  The total population you'd find on the server isn't even as high as you would have found in Theed Cantina the day before CU went live.
    That's not even the entire city of Theed or even Coronet.  That's just the cantina and yes it had more people than I can find on the entire server now (well before my accounts cancelled out).
    You can't compare the population you saw on a "special event" such as the day before the CU to a random day today.  Of course there's going to be more people on at one time in one spot then normal due to the fact that it was a special event :)  
    Driving through player city after player city just to see empty.  Yes I see plenty of building but no players.  I'm sure SOE was losing subscriptions...
    They're empty because there's really no reason to be in them other then to pick up stuff off a vendor.
    However, what I know is what the game looked like the day before CU and what MY server has looked like since.  CU didn't hurt Starsiders population as bad as the NGE.  It did drop substantially but not like it did with the NGE.
    I can't really comment on Starsiders population as I don't play on it. I do know they had an event this weekend past that crashed the server.  That and it has a pretty big pilot community.
    I can't comment on other servers.  I'm sure someone would like to say how most people in the Cantina were afk entertainers.  Well afk entertainers were still another account paying a monthly which they don't have now.
    Plain and simple...
    They should have just fixed the game they had. 
    The main reason I just can't see myself ever going back.. Is that they removed from the game every part of it that even interested me.  Of course that's just me...  I'm not going to claim it affects your enjoyment or anyone elses.
    I just don't see how anyone can honestly claim or even believe that CU and/or the NGE doesn't have less players subscribed than pre-cu.  Or that the entire game population is on an upswing...
    I'm NOT saying that there aren't less players then there was back in the early days of the game.  What I am saying though is that I'm not seeing the dying part.
    ((I guess if you play on some server I've never seen that seems to have population you may be able to believe it.  I just also would say based on servers that used to be overly populated and are now basicly empty.. its very hard to believe))


    image

    image

  • Concord7Concord7 Member Posts: 125

    By my gage - Just now at 10:48 AM Eastern US Time the first post on the General Forum has a time of 7:45 AM Pacific and the last post 6:34 AM. This is over a hour for a new post to scroll off the 1st page of 20 posts.

    Pre-CU this would have been under 1 minute.

    FYI -Scanning the Chilly Forums 1st 4 pages shows 3 goodbyes and 0 Im back

  • maxantomaxanto Member Posts: 778
    Though I am sure they will never return to pre-cu servers I do think they are gonna mix the best of what was in the pre-cu game with the NGE. You can see it happen every day.

  • ObraikObraik Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,261


    Originally posted by maxanto
    Though I am sure they will never return to pre-cu servers I do think they are gonna mix the best of what was in the pre-cu game with the NGE. You can see it happen every day.

    Yes that I can see/am seeing happening.  Personally, I think there's a best of both worlds ;)

    image

    image

  • tjvoodootjvoodoo Member Posts: 293


    Originally posted by Obraik

    Originally posted by maxanto
    Though I am sure they will never return to pre-cu servers I do think they are gonna mix the best of what was in the pre-cu game with the NGE. You can see it happen every day.
    Yes that I can see/am seeing happening.  Personally, I think there's a best of both worlds ;)

    Would you be as kind as to PM me when the "best of both is finished" so i can try it rather than pay for its development & testing (combat system,xp,loot tables,AI,proffesion balance) are worked out in beta, not in a live game.

    I bought a car - the sales man tells me the wheels will be put on soon so i bought it(what a deal).
  • RekrulRekrul Member Posts: 2,961


    Originally posted by Obraik

    Originally posted by maxanto
    Though I am sure they will never return to pre-cu servers I do think they are gonna mix the best of what was in the pre-cu game with the NGE. You can see it happen every day.
    Yes that I can see/am seeing happening.  Personally, I think there's a best of both worlds ;)

    The professions?
    Interdependancy?
    Sandbox?
    Community?
    Soul?
    Mistery?

    Oh, you mean an insignificant user interface issue, that affects how cursor moves. It wasn't the combat queue that made pre-cu.
  • TillerTiller Member LegendaryPosts: 11,489

    you know what, I don't want SOE to do classic servers. They can't even manage the mess they have now. WTH. I left 2 months ago and things have not changed since day one of the NGE from what I just read in a players post. All they can seem to do is add more stuff in to break.  I don't get.

     http://soe.lithium.com/swg/board/message?board.id=swggpdiscussion&message.id=1064121

    SWG Bloodfin vet
    Elder Jedi/Elder Bounty Hunter
     
  • KzinKillerKzinKiller Member Posts: 625
    As far as server populations go .... for starters, I don't know, I'm not playing and haven't for 5 months ...

    But it's summer, school vacation, this is as good as it's gonna get.  Free trials, kids experimenting out of curiosity.  When September comes around, numbers will dip again, how badly is anybody's guess.


    image

  • iskareotiskareot Member Posts: 2,143

    SOEs ego is just to strong for this failure.

    I would think a whole other game with them not invovled has a better chance to happen actually.

    SOE has really fucked this up and I cannot wait for the "I told ya so's" to fly around....it is coming, just not soon enough.

    ______________________________
    I usually picture the Career builder commercial with the room full of monkeys and upside down sales chart when thinking about the SOE/SWG decision making process.....
    SOE's John Blakely and Todd Fiala issued a warning: "Don't make our mistakes." Ref NGE
    Winner of the worst MMOS goes to.... the NGE and SWG..!!! http://www.mmorpg.com/showFeature.cfm?loadFeature=1034&bhcp=1

  • Concord7Concord7 Member Posts: 125
    The question I have is "What is the Revenue floor for LEC to pull the license?" 
  • Wildcat84Wildcat84 Member Posts: 2,304


    Originally posted by Concord7
    The question I have is "What is the Revenue floor for LEC to pull the license?" 

    My guess is that they are already well below that.  The plan for SWG was a million subs.  They never got to half that.  This is why they did the CUNGE, which achieved only the loss of most of the 250K loyal audience they were able to sustain.

  • zipitzipit Member Posts: 487


    Originally posted by Rekrul

    Originally posted by Obraik





    What I've been seeing on the forums contradicts that.  I've seen more "I'm back from XX months" posts this month then I have before.  I've been seeing this in game too with old friends on my friendslist popping online.  Not only that, but I'm seeing more new people at the Legacy hotspots


    Yes, plenty of that. Read any forum, "Hi, I'm back, so what's ..."

    During the JTL trial around end of 2004, servers were so full, full groups of 20 were going out from Mos Espa. Because all other cities were so full, people lagged out. Bestine was a no-no, Eisley was packed, you had hard time getting anywhere and not running into a bunch of people.

    Yes, people come back, take a look.

    Where are the hordes of newbies, first timers, players enthusiastic about the game, that can't stop playing. Where are the newbie guilds, newbie cities, newbies inviting random people to come see their house? Where are newbies excited about killing a bantha? Killing borvo's elite guard? Where are the newbies setting down a camp, inviting any random passer by, ammasing dozens of people? Where is the Jedi, assembling a group of new players, and taking them out for a hunt to help them gain a few skills? Crafters making stuff for new players? Where are the newbies running around excited telling everyone that Han Solo is cantina? A group of newbies setting up an expedition to Fort Tusken? A group of underequiped players struggling on their way to Sarlacc pit? A newbie completing the Jabba's palace quest, and spending 30 minutes trying to get Bobba to group with him? The horrible disaster that happened when you first ventured out on Dantooine? Or even worse, Endor. Learning about brandy. Getting first armor. First decent weapon. First pet. AT-ST.

    That is what the experience was. The technical quality was always crap. The bugs were always there. But ask anyone to tell you of their experience now. Will they be excited? Will they have anything noteworthy to say? Do they have a story?

    That was the game I played.

    This game is dead.


     /wipes away tears of memory

    Yes and thats really what has killed SWG. It's the spirit, the soul if you will,  that has vanished from this game. People make a MMO great, not coders ( although it sure helps to get bugs away and content filled in ).

Sign In or Register to comment.