Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Huxley compared to Planetside?

PhosPhos Member Posts: 455

Did anyone out there play Planetside?

I did not.  I've been reading about it, and it looks like it was pretty cool.  I wish I got in on it while it was hot.

That being said, do you think it's fair to compare Huxley to Planetside (although Huxley appears to be much better graphics, persistent world, etc)?  It so, I guess I'll stop hoping for a Planetside 2, and just play Huxley instead!!!

 - Phos

imageAAH! A troll fire! Quick, pour some Kool-Aid on it!!!

Comments

  • Berserker202Berserker202 Member Posts: 44


    given teh strong FPS base of both games and the large battlefields being promised i think it is perfectly fair to compare the two. Planetside was straight up jsut like any other FPS except for the alrge enviroments. The game had alrge bases which acted as capture points that they "attempted" to make each one useful although only a few meant anything and even then it wasn't anything worth noting. Also leveling in that game was more about being around during a base capture then kills. Kill exp was worth practically nothing if you could even get a kill, it always went to someone else it seemed. The game was also veyr laggy in its early days, however they kind of helped that. The battlefields themselves were really bad but theyw ere all the same. EAch one was simply the same as the last with a new coat of paint and the occasional different floorplan (there were like 4). Levels also counted for certification points and nothing else, there was no loot or monetary system. An finally  ther was nothing other then PVP.



    Huxley promises differing enviroments (or at the very least they seem much more interesting). Also cap points are supposed to mean something as well as being more then just "heres another large base to siege for a grueling 30 minutes only to wait for a 10 min cap to get your exp), it will all move much faster. How easy it will be to make sure you consistently nail the killing blow is questionable and im not sure if it will differe much but oh well. People sound liek they will also be more specialized in their jobs. Also Huxley has quests, thats a big deal to alot of people.



    Huxley jsut seems to be offering a more fulfilling experience with much much mroe content.



    Planetside was a good experiment and a sequel would be cool but untill then im definently looking forward to huxley
  • NastyNitroNastyNitro Member Posts: 75
    Ooooo i luved the crap outa planetside, guess ill start reading up on this game!

    image

  • Erazor01Erazor01 Member Posts: 109

    What's all this rubbish about "Planetside WAS this..." and "Planetside WAS that.."?

    Planetside IS alive and kicking with 133 vs 133 vs 133 persistent battles every night.  It's just celebrating it's 4th anniversary with 5 new weapons including a fragmentation grendate launcher and a flamethrower.

    Huxley, on the other hand IS NOT.  It will be sometime, possibly 4 months from now, possibly later. 

    If you're into self-denial, do without and wait at least 4 months for Huxley.  If you want a lot of fun NOW, play Planetside.

  • grimbojgrimboj Member Posts: 2,102
    yah I keep resubbing planetside every few months - the game doesnt have a lot of longevity but its so packed at weekend its a blast.

    --
    Note: PlayNC will refuse to allow you access to your account if you forget your password and can't provide a scanned image of the product key for the first product you purchased..... LOL

  • GhosthaukGhosthauk Member Posts: 122
    Hm, been itching to play some fps lately, maybe I'll resub to Planetside for a month and see what's changed, haven't played in more than a year now. Planetside is a great game, it's just too bad it that SOE left it to rot for so long after release. By now there should have been new base designs, personal outfit bases etc. Most of the good battles happen at the bases, it's a lot of fun trying different tactics to defend or capture a base. As for the experience, yeah it can be a little hard to get if you're solo and not using a mass killing setup, but it's just fine in a group as experience for kills is shared, so even dedicated medics get something :)



    Been waiting on Huxley, don't think it'll be as open as Planetside, more like a collective of battlegrounds with different goals, but hopefully they will have some huge epic fights to offer.



    P.S I was really hoping the next Starcraft would have been a mmofps, much like Planetside with the blizzard touch /drool oh well.
  • logicbomb82logicbomb82 Member UncommonPosts: 228
    hux is out?
    I run the Mature Minded Gamers. We do video and board gaming videos and reviews. We also have a big Dungeons and Dragons community with multiple games active each week.
    Join us at: https://www.maturemindedgamers.com

  • GhosthaukGhosthauk Member Posts: 122
    Originally posted by logicbomb82

    hux is out?
    err no.
  • Hoobley_deletedHoobley_deleted Member Posts: 677
    Originally posted by logicbomb82

    hux is out?
    no, not yet.
  • keygankeygan Member Posts: 237
    Planetside is still a ton of fun.  still massive and still packed fights.  If your thinking about it just download it and play for a month, i think you'll like it, if you like mmofps'.
  • StyijStyij Member Posts: 186

    I wonder if it will CTD every ten minutes like Planetside use to? I liked Planetside but I could never fix the CTD issue so I had to just walk away.

  • GeolasGeolas Member Posts: 21

    planetside changed since it release. When it first came out, i sub for 3 months. Took a month to reach rank 20 (max at that time) and 2 month of leading looong battles to get CR4.

    Within those 3 months they made alot of changes. the 2nd month of updates they added the lattice system, to create front lines and to prevent back hacking. It was looking great. Then by the 3rd month, the number of players wasnt enough for SoE to keep all their servers, so they drop half their servers and merge them. It created more lag for me. So i just stop playing.

    Huxley i believe will have some PvE instead of just PvP. but i guess we will all have to wait for beta or release before we can really compare the 2 games.

  • ChiseChise Member Posts: 17
    By the looks of it, Planet Side was basically a game with one main objective.  To blow the crap out of the other guy and take the base.  Sub objective, many different ways to blow the crap out of the other guy and take the base.  Or to play as support so as to help people blow the crap out of the other guy, and of course take the other base.



    I'm not saying it's bad by any means.  In fact I do resubscribe every so often when I have the time and do quite enjoy playing it :)  But what I'm saying is that this game focuses completely on combat.



    While Huxley does have combat, from what I've read and gathered.  It focuses more on establishing a world of sorts.  While combat is a big part of it, you also have cities (or so I think this was indicated), quests, and an economy to play around with.  Not to mention, as stated in the post above.  There will most likely be quite a bit of PvE combat as opposed to only PvP, as experienced in Planet Side.

    _______________________________
    One of my friend's just received an xbox 360 elite through this method. So I thought I'd try it. Your help would be appreciated :)
    image

  • XLCSXLCS Member Posts: 7
    I have yet to find good information on what exactly Huxley will offer as an MMOFPS... there are a lot of websites out there that are hyping different information.  I don't think they really know what Huxley will look like at release and are reporting wild a$$ guesses as reality.  Even well-known websites like Gamespot are hyping it as a MMO... but is it really?



    It sort of looks like a team match FPS shrouded in a MMO veneer, ala Shadowrun.  Since Hux is going to be crossplatform PC/XBOX on Live this would make sense.  Microsoft is maneuvering to make consumers accept that we must pay for traditionally free types of gameplay - developers who want to release titles for free are being made to charge on Live.  Shadowrun and Huxley certainly fit the mold of what was once free - team FPS gameplay - turning into something that we will have to pay for.



    So if that is the case, Planetside and Huxley are far different creatures.  Planetside, for it's shortcomings and aging code, is a real MMO with a persistent world and open form of strategic/tactical PvP.  I'm not sure what Huxley is or will be once it is entrenched on Live.



    The Team XBOX review stated this: "But, whether PlanetSide is a strategy-focused first-person shooter, Huxley offers a completely different shooting experience; playing very similar to Unreal Tournament games."  http://previews.teamxbox.com/xbox-360/1349/Huxley/p1/
  • Berserker202Berserker202 Member Posts: 44
    Originally posted by XLCS

    The Team XBOX review stated this: "But, whether PlanetSide is a strategy-focused first-person shooter, Huxley offers a completely different shooting experience; playing very similar to Unreal Tournament games."  http://previews.teamxbox.com/xbox-360/1349/Huxley/p1/
    I don't see what this quote has to do with it being an MMO or not. The world is persistant with massive scale battles and takes place all in an online world (for PC players) Clans are supposed to be able to own buildings within the cities as well as the cities themselves being littered with quest instances and small areas of conflict. It sounds more MMO then planetside was to me
  • MrbloodworthMrbloodworth Member Posts: 5,615
    Originally posted by Erazor01


    What's all this rubbish about "Planetside WAS this..." and "Planetside WAS that.."?
    Planetside IS alive and kicking with 133 vs 133 vs 133 persistent battles every night.  It's just celebrating it's 4th anniversary with 5 new weapons including a fragmentation grendate launcher and a flamethrower.
    Huxley, on the other hand IS NOT.  It will be sometime, possibly 4 months from now, possibly later. 
    If you're into self-denial, do without and wait at least 4 months for Huxley.  If you want a lot of fun NOW, play Planetside.
    QFT.

    ----------
    "Anyone posting on this forum is not an average user, and there for any opinions about the game are going to be overly critical compared to an average users opinions." - Me

    "No, your wrong.." - Random user #123

    "Hello person posting on a site specifically for MMO's in a thread on a sub forum specifically for a particular game talking about meta features and making comparisons to other titles in the genre, and their meta features.

    How are you?" -Me

  • DavynelordDavynelord Member Posts: 122
    Well, it's been nearly a year since I last checked up on huxley.   Back then it gave me the impression that it was gonna be a massive online version of unreal tournament/quake type of game.     I don't really like drooling over games while in production so I don't follow the hype around them.   I wait for them to come out and play them, then that dictates my hype, not some guy writing an article about a game being this or that because 9 times out of 10, articles over hype "ALL" games ever made.   Things sound good on paper, but in when it comes time to play the game, that is the true measure by which I rate games.





    That being said, I played planetside for about a year or so and it was non-stop fun (when you play at the right hours of the day).   The server population is not huge by any means and the large scales battles are limited because continents get population locked and you can't enter the battles.   The cap per continent is very low as well where I heard huxley will have 5000 man servers and large population caps (probably outdated information).    so if your locked out of the big battle, your stuck playing little small man skirmishes or backdoor hacking planets to try and draw some of the people off the pop locked continent and hopefully sneak in on the big battle when they come to reclaim the bases you've hacked. 



    A lot of the times I'd slap on my stealth suit and just hit base after base on a continent having the enemy trying to figure out which base i was gonna hit next.  Pure cat and mouse games I played when there wasn't a non-pop locked fight to join.    Being on a free account in the beggining though made things tougher because paid players got first dibs on pop locked planets and reserves (what they call free accounts) had to wait in long 20+ man waiting lines to get into battles.    Sometimes I'd be waiting for an hour just to get in on a real good battle....that's went ahead and got a station pass account to play since I was already playing SWG.   However, when I said goodbye to SWG, planetside wasn't good enough to keep paying for only that game.   The game was real fun at the right times but too often I found myself not able to get into the big fights.



    Anyway, if you love FPS's then planetside is a awesome game and I imagine huxley will be even better when it finally comes out.   Just the technology available today will make huxley better than planetside.   You'll have options in huxley that planetside just won't have since I doubt SOE will ever give it a major upgrade seeing as how low the accounts are for it.    Anyone who says that the servers are packed are fooling themselves.    The reason SOE started the reserves is to populate the servers because the game was dying.   So no it's not dead yet, but it is on it last breathe and could get the flatline any day now.   The day a good FPS comes out will probably be the day planetside will die.  it's only lasted this long because it doesn't have much competition in the MMOFPS market.    If Huxley will be that competition?  who knows!  I'll try it out and see myself though.    right now, I'm not interested in paying to  play planetside though, I'd much rather play america's army (a truely awesome FPS/tactical game by the way) which has the same goals as planetside but many many better designs and ways of doing things....besides what's not to like about a military style game (army calls it a simulation).  I was in the military and I have to say, AA is everything like I remembered it when I served, much more fun in a game though, lol
  • XLCSXLCS Member Posts: 7
    Originally posted by Berserker202

    Originally posted by XLCS

    The Team XBOX review stated this: "But, whether PlanetSide is a strategy-focused first-person shooter, Huxley offers a completely different shooting experience; playing very similar to Unreal Tournament games."  http://previews.teamxbox.com/xbox-360/1349/Huxley/p1/
    I don't see what this quote has to do with it being an MMO or not. The world is persistant with massive scale battles and takes place all in an online world (for PC players) Clans are supposed to be able to own buildings within the cities as well as the cities themselves being littered with quest instances and small areas of conflict. It sounds more MMO then planetside was to me

    Allow me to explain that sentence then: Planetside = strategy; Huxley = typical FPS objectives.



    Doesn't sound like an MMO to me, more like glorified match FPS that up to now has been free to play online.



    So far the real information is that it handles 16 v 16 matches like any other FPS - everything else seems to be conjecture and wishful thinking.
Sign In or Register to comment.