If we combined a whole bunch of MMORPGs together what would it look like?

chaokhan

I have played alot of MMO's and can honestly say that there are parts to all of them that I like and dislike.  So what parts were really good from other games that were/are worth saving?

CleffyII

A Tale in the Desert - Crafting System

Granado Espada - MCC System, Character Designs

Lord of the Rings Online - Quests

Lineage 2 - Siege Battles

(Aion) - Character Progression System

NavyFIELD - Naval Combat Mini-game

Albatross 18 - Golf Mini-game

D&D Online - Twitch Controls

Cabe2323

It would look like World of warcraft of course.  

 

but seriously. 

 

I would say Dark Age of Camelot's end game system.  Combined with World of Warcraft leveling.  Combined with Everquest 2 crafting.  Throw in a bit of ASheron's Call 1's live team and monthly update team and I would have my perfect game.  Oh character and race selection similar to Dark Age of Camelot.  But using World of Warcrafts UI system and having character animations similar to WoW. 

Naryysys

Originally posted by CleffyII


A Tale in the Desert - Crafting System
Granado Espada - MCC System, Character Designs
Lord of the Rings Online - Quests
Lineage 2 - Siege Battles
(Aion) - Character Progression System
NavyFIELD - Naval Combat Mini-game
Albatross 18 - Golf Mini-game
D&D Online - Twitch Controls

You forgot:

DAoC: Frontiers and RvR system. 

valun

AO - Character Progression System,PvP ranks system;
DAOC - RVR system;
WoW - Quests;
VG - Crafting system,air battles (under effect of levitate),classes;
L2 - Death penalty.

Cabe2323

I actually loved all of DAoC's endgame better then any other game I have played.  The raids were fun to go on just for going on.  There wasn't any of this crappy gear centric raiding that WoW has currently.  there was no need for DKP or any of htat crap.  Instead you would go just for the enjoyment of going and if you didn't get an item you wanted (which more often then not was for visual looks and not because it was vastly better) you could just find one to buy off someone's Consignment Merchant.  Even the Artifacts were neat to do.  About the only part I didn't like was the Master level raids.  They were so boring to do that people didn't want to do them over once they had done them the first time.  That is why it was so hard to go back and finish Master Levels later on in the life of the game.  

Lucifrank

Originally posted by chaokhan


I have played alot of MMO's and can honestly say that there are parts to all of them that I like and dislike.  So what parts were really good from other games that were/are worth saving?

It would look like WoW.

METALDRAG0N

Originally posted by chaokhan


I have played alot of MMO's and can honestly say that there are parts to all of them that I like and dislike.  So what parts were really good from other games that were/are worth saving?

This was already done by Blizzard.

Naryysys

Originally posted by Cabe2323


I actually loved all of DAoC's endgame better then any other game I have played.  The raids were fun to go on just for going on.  There wasn't any of this crappy gear centric raiding that WoW has currently.  there was no need for DKP or any of htat crap.  Instead you would go just for the enjoyment of going and if you didn't get an item you wanted (which more often then not was for visual looks and not because it was vastly better) you could just find one to buy off someone's Consignment Merchant.  Even the Artifacts were neat to do.  About the only part I didn't like was the Master level raids.  They were so boring to do that people didn't want to do them over once they had done them the first time.  That is why it was so hard to go back and finish Master Levels later on in the life of the game.  

Thank god for the classic cluster, eh?

Tolwynn

the best-est-est part

 

 

 

 

is Cabe's icon !

 

Something along the lines of:

*Eq1(pre-PoP) and Pre-ToA DaoC...mixed together....i would enjoy alot.

EQ- size of world and quests,raids

Daoc-RvR(not pvp)

 

*EvE+CoH(when your land based)..avatar fighting;)

Eve (too much to list)

CoH(really any mmorpg would fit here in the sci-fi genre...i just picked CoH for the added Avatar fighting that could be in EvE...but any Sci-Fi would work.

*WaR+PoTbS would be interesting.

War- no explanation needed

PoTbS-"See above"

 

other than that, as other posters have stated in a multitude of threads, I am also kind of burnt out on the whole fantasy genre in regards to online mmorpg's.

 

Sci-Fi and Pirates(historical based stuff).....I would LOVE to see.