Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Any mmorpg actually require skill?

VanReeseVanReese Member Posts: 7

Used to play enchanter in EQ1 -- do any mmorpg nowadays have a class with challenging play style that is powerful / rare ?

I was thinking of trying out guildwars because of all the options but it seems a bit poor that anyone can rock up and have a max level character in PVP (i.e. didn't earn their levels etc)

i've played so far also Eve (good but slow paced and takes about a year to do anything) and Vanguard SoH just after release, and Wow (but please don't mention Wow which should have been renamed "super easy for kids")...

so... any worthwhile challenges out there?

van..

Comments

  • lazyredheadlazyredhead Member Posts: 66

    let me pull up a few

    http://gunz.ijji.com/

    http://sfront.ijji.com/

    now those are really online FPS. if you want a mmorpg that requires skills you best choice would  be http://mabinogi.nexon.net/

    unlike most mmorpg's you dont click once and watch you guy kill something. also you you want it to be a challenge play as the yongest age the yonger  you are the harder it is

  • traumadawgtraumadawg Member Posts: 4

    IMO try lineage II, just watch out for the scammers;) could also try LOTRO, not terribly easy but interesting enough ( i like the bards, very versatile) or just wait until AoC opens:)

  • HairysunHairysun Member UncommonPosts: 1,059

      I like the title of this post........a valid question.  Is skill the correct word to identify someones ability to play a game.  It's not like you could put it down on a job application.  Any mmorpg actually require skill?  Hmm......

     

     

    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source - Share This

    skill1      /sk?l/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[skil] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
    –noun
    1. the ability, coming from one's knowledge, practice, aptitude, etc., to do something well: Carpentry was one of his many skills.
    2. competent excellence in performance; expertness; dexterity: The dancers performed with skill.
    3. a craft, trade, or job requiring manual dexterity or special training in which a person has competence and experience: the skill of cabinetmaking.
    4. Obsolete. understanding; discernment.
    5. Obsolete. reason; cause.



    [Origin: 1125–75; ME < ON skil distinction, difference; c. D geschil difference, quarrel. See skill2]



    —Synonyms 1. proficiency, facility. 2. deftness, cleverness.

    —Antonyms 1. inability.


    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1)

    Based on the Random House Unabridged Dictionary, © Random House, Inc. 2006.
    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source - Share This
    skill2      /sk?l/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[skil] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
    –verb (used without object) Archaic.
    1. to matter.
    2. to help; avail.



    [Origin: 1150–1200; ME skilien < ON skilja to distinguish, divide, akin to skil (see skill1), OE scylian to separate, Goth skilja butcher, Lith skélti to split]


    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1)

    Based on the Random House Unabridged Dictionary, © Random House, Inc. 2006.
    American Heritage Dictionary - Cite This Source - Share This
    skill       (sk?l)  Pronunciation Key 

    n.  
    1. Proficiency, facility, or dexterity that is acquired or developed through training or experience. See Synonyms at ability.
      1. An art, trade, or technique, particularly one requiring use of the hands or body.
      2. A developed talent or ability: writing skills.
    2. Obsolete A reason; a cause.




    [Middle English skil, from Old Norse, discernment; see skel-1 in Indo-European roots.]

    (Download Now or Buy the Book)
    The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition

    Copyright © 2006 by Houghton Mifflin Company.

    Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.
    Online Etymology Dictionary - Cite This Source - Share This

    skill 

    c.1175, "power of discernment," from O.N. skil "distinction, discernment," related to skilja (v.) "distinguish, separate," from P.Gmc. *skaljo- "divide, separate" (cf. M.L.G. schillen "to differ;" M.L.G., M.Du. schele "difference;" see shell). Sense of "ability, cleverness" first recorded c.1300.


    Online Etymology Dictionary, © 2001 Douglas Harper
    WordNet - Cite This Source - Share This
    skill


    noun
    1.  an ability that has been acquired by training 
    2.  ability to produce solutions in some problem domain; "the skill of a well-trained boxer"; "the sweet science of pugilism" 
    WordNet® 3.0, © 2006 by Princeton University.
    Kernerman English Multilingual Dictionary (Beta Version) - Cite This Source - Share This

    skill1 [skil] noun

    cleverness at doing something, resulting either from practice or from natural ability

    Example: This job requires a lot of skill.
    Arabic: ???????? ?????
    Chinese (Simplified): ??
    Chinese (Traditional): ??
    Czech: obratnost
    Danish: færdighed; dygtighed
    Dutch: bedrevenheid
    Estonian: oskused, vilumus
    Finnish: taito
    French: adresse, habileté
    German: das Geschick
    Greek: επιδεξι?τητα
    Hungarian: ügyesség, jártasság, szaktudás
    Icelandic: kunnátta, hæfni
    Indonesian: keahlian
    Italian: abilità, bravura
    Japanese: ??
    Korean: ??, ??
    Latvian: m?ka; izveic?ba
    Lithuanian: ?gudimas
    Norwegian: dyktighet, ferdighet
    Polish: umiej?tno??, wprawa
    Portuguese (Brazil): habilidade
    Portuguese (Portugal): perícia
    Romanian: înde­mâ­nare, abilitate
    Russian: ??????????; ?????????
    Slovak: obratnos?
    Slovenian: spretnost
    Spanish: destreza, habilidad
    Swedish: skicklighet
    Turkish: ustal?k, beceri
     

    skill2 [skil] noun

    a job or activity that requires training and practice; an art or craft

    Example: the basic skills of reading and writing
    Arabic: ???????
    Chinese (Simplified): ??
    Chinese (Traditional): ??
    Czech: dovednost
    Danish: færdighed
    Dutch: vaardigheid
    Estonian: oskus, kunst
    Finnish: taito
    French: technique, capacité
    German: die Kenntnis
    Greek: ικαν?τητα
    Hungarian: szakképzettség
    Icelandic: fag, iðn; tækni, fagkunnátta
    Indonesian: ketrampilan
    Italian: mestiere, professione
    Japanese: ??
    Korean: ??, ??
    Latvian: prasme; iema?a
    Lithuanian: ?g?dis
    Norwegian: ferdighet
    Polish: umiej?tno??, sztuka
    Portuguese (Brazil): prática, arte
    Portuguese (Portugal): competência
    Romanian: tehnic?, capacitate
    Russian: ????????; ??????
    Slovak: zru?nos?
    Slovenian: veš?ina
    Spanish: técnica, arte
    Swedish: färdighet
    Turkish: beceri
     

    See also: skilful, skilled

    Kernerman English Multilingual Dictionary (Beta Version), © 2000-2006 K Dictionaries Ltd.
    Free On-line Dictionary of Computing - Cite This Source - Share This

    Skill

    A somewhat peculiar blend between Franz-Lisp and C, with a large set of various CAD primitives. It is owned by Cadence Design Systems and has been used in their CAD frameworks since 1985. It's an extension language to the CAD framework (in the same way that Emacs-Lisp extends GNU Emacs), enabling you to automate virtually everything that you can do manually in for example the graphic editor. Skill accepts C-syntax, fun(a b), as well as Lisp syntax, (fun a b), but most users (including Cadence themselves) use the C-style.

    [Jonas Jarnestrom

    The Free On-line Dictionary of Computing, © 1993-2007 Denis Howe
    On-line Medical Dictionary - Cite This Source - Share This

    skill

    skill: in CancerWEB's On-line Medical Dictionary

    On-line Medical Dictionary, © 1997-98 Academic Medical Publishing & CancerWEB

     

      OK, I suppose it applies.  In regards to your question.....no......there arn't any worthwhile challenges out there.  It's all bubble gum for the brain.

    ~Hairysun~

  • VualVual Member Posts: 13

     

    Originally posted by VanReese


    Used to play enchanter in EQ1 -- do any mmorpg nowadays have a class with challenging play style that is powerful / rare ?
    I was thinking of trying out guildwars because of all the options but it seems a bit poor that anyone can rock up and have a max level character in PVP (i.e. didn't earn their levels etc)
    i've played so far also Eve (good but slow paced and takes about a year to do anything) and Vanguard SoH just after release, and Wow (but please don't mention Wow which should have been renamed "super easy for kids")...
    so... any worthwhile challenges out there?
    van..

     

    I think Lineage II may be what you need. I know it is full of botters/cheaters/hackers whatever, but the game is actually fun. The castle sieges, well, look for yourself on youtube, they look awsome. The community is good on most servers mainly because the game doesn't appeal to kids, which is excellent.

    I'd also recommend EQ2. I've never actually raided properly myself but from what i've read and what friends who do raid have told me, it sounds as if a certain amount of "skill" is needed to be effective. However, this is all second hand information, so i can't say this is completely true.

     

  • traumadawgtraumadawg Member Posts: 4

    first off i love gaming, i currently play 3 mmo's. now, with that being said heres the strraightdope, some games take skills,  some peeps havem some dont. also, no game is really worth while. you really only get fun out of it and sometimes not even that. it's all virtual unless your a farmer and make money that way, but then that cant be to fun now could it. point is if you want to challenge yourself try an outdoor sport or something. video games are for the fun of it :)

  • MiexonMiexon Vendetta Online CorrespondentMember Posts: 181

    Vendetta Online is quite the challenge PVP wise. Its a twitch combat system and allows multiple ways to fight joysticks, mouse, and many other options.  Big missions allow major combat between large fighter class ships, other players, and large frigates etc. Quite an intense combat system.

    You up for the challenge?

    Member of the Phoenix Alliance Guild
    in Vendetta Online
    www.vendetta-online.com

  • traumadawgtraumadawg Member Posts: 4

    Originally posted by Vual


     
    Originally posted by VanReese


    Used to play enchanter in EQ1 -- do any mmorpg nowadays have a class with challenging play style that is powerful / rare ?
    I was thinking of trying out guildwars because of all the options but it seems a bit poor that anyone can rock up and have a max level character in PVP (i.e. didn't earn their levels etc)
    i've played so far also Eve (good but slow paced and takes about a year to do anything) and Vanguard SoH just after release, and Wow (but please don't mention Wow which should have been renamed "super easy for kids")...
    so... any worthwhile challenges out there?
    van..

     

    I think Lineage II may be what you need. I know it is full of botters/cheaters/hackers whatever, but the game is actually fun. The castle sieges, well, look for yourself on youtube, they look awsome. The community is good on most servers mainly because the game doesn't appeal to kids, which is excellent.

    I'd also recommend EQ2. I've never actually raided properly myself but from what i've read and what friends who do raid have told me, it sounds as if a certain amount of "skill" is needed to be effective. However, this is all second hand information, so i can't say this is completely true.

     

    well, from 1st hand knowledge of 4 + yrs playing EQ2 and 2 yrs playing L2 on and off i'd say you are correct sir:) raiding in EQ2 does require good leadership and skill to be effective. you can tell the skilled from the unskilled very quick if your raiding with em. and L2 is just awsome, hardcore but awsome and yes , geared more toward adults which lends to the real world  hardness of it

     

  • samuraislyrsamuraislyr Member Posts: 122

    I will just mention this about Guild wars.... It does require quite a bit of skill. Leveling is nothing. Plus the ability to make a pvp character that is 20 is very limited. You start out with only the basic skills and have to pvp a lot to get elite and better skills in order to come up with more builds.

    Guild wars has a dual-class system which makes things very interesting. I'm just making these numbers up as an estimate but each class has about 200 or so skills so with two classes you can mix and match over 400 skills on a bar of 8. Choosing good combos that work and such can be challenging.

    Guild Wars pvp is probably in my opinion the best of the bunch. Guild Wars PvE is lacking sadly. It's not horrible but it could be better. I would definitly see about a trial key or heck even just buy prophecies, the first campaing which I think is 20 bucks now and see if you enjoy it, then get the other ones for more classes and fun.

    Nightfall is actually probably the best one to buy first since you get more bang for your buck but it's up to you if you even want to try it.

  • BankotsuLiBankotsuLi Member Posts: 3

    You clearly like the fantasy-style games, which is great - but if you're willing to try something new, I'd recommend EVE Online (www.eve-online.com). It's a sci-fi MMO. There are some RPG aspects to it, but it's very PVP-oriented. Nearly everything about the game is player-driven. CCP (EVE's developers) has great forums full of knowledge if you want to check out more about the game, but they regularly take player input and incorporate what they can into the game. The learning curve when first starting the game is like hitting a brick-wall, but there's good corporations (same as 'guilds') that will happily help you out. PVP and PVE can range from 1v1 all the way up to enormous fleet engagements with 100's of pilots involved.

    As you were previously an Enchanter, there's not too much of an equivelent role within EVE, but there are ships and skills that would allow you to perform logistics and command roles (giving buffs, etc.), and electronic warfare (crowd control).

  • oakaeoakae Member UncommonPosts: 344

    The Chronicles of Spellborn when it comes out and Darkfall if it ever comes out.

  • RazankaRazanka Member UncommonPosts: 67
    Originally posted by BankotsuLi


    You clearly like the fantasy-style games, which is great - but if you're willing to try something new, I'd recommend EVE Online (www.eve-online.com). It's a sci-fi MMO. There are some RPG aspects to it, but it's very PVP-oriented. Nearly everything about the game is player-driven. CCP (EVE's developers) has great forums full of knowledge if you want to check out more about the game, but they regularly take player input and incorporate what they can into the game. The learning curve when first starting the game is like hitting a brick-wall, but there's good corporations (same as 'guilds') that will happily help you out. PVP and PVE can range from 1v1 all the way up to enormous fleet engagements with 100's of pilots involved.
    As you were previously an Enchanter, there's not too much of an equivelent role within EVE, but there are ships and skills that would allow you to perform logistics and command roles (giving buffs, etc.), and electronic warfare (crowd control).

    ^What he said. EvE is the only mmorpg out there that requires the player to have skill.

  • SpeedMannSpeedMann Member UncommonPosts: 333
    Originally posted by BankotsuLi


    You clearly like the fantasy-style games, which is great - but if you're willing to try something new, I'd recommend EVE Online (www.eve-online.com). It's a sci-fi MMO. There are some RPG aspects to it, but it's very PVP-oriented. Nearly everything about the game is player-driven. CCP (EVE's developers) has great forums full of knowledge if you want to check out more about the game, but they regularly take player input and incorporate what they can into the game. The learning curve when first starting the game is like hitting a brick-wall, but there's good corporations (same as 'guilds') that will happily help you out. PVP and PVE can range from 1v1 all the way up to enormous fleet engagements with 100's of pilots involved.
    As you were previously an Enchanter, there's not too much of an equivelent role within EVE, but there are ships and skills that would allow you to perform logistics and command roles (giving buffs, etc.), and electronic warfare (crowd control).



    Clearly you haven't even read this thread and just trying to sell EVE to anyone looking for a MMO to play.

    ==================================================
    Happy! Happy! Joy! Joy!

Sign In or Register to comment.