Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

ATI vs Nvidia 2010

124

Comments

  • solarinesolarine Member Posts: 1,203
    Originally posted by AmazingAvery

    Originally posted by Mellow44


    nVidias not yet released chip is too big and expensive to produce i.e. their next cards will cost $499-$599 and that means that they will not sell many of them.
    I mean 500 to 600 buckaroos for a graphics card?
    Give me a break!



     

    Here in Canada a 5870 is $460 ish and when short supply up to just under $500. The 5970 can reach $700 Canadian.

     



     

    Still not so bad. Those two go for $700 and $900 where I live. :)

     

  • LurvLurv Member UncommonPosts: 409

    Damn. Y'all must be doing some heavy gaming. I just wanna play my MMO's. I think one 5770 and one later crossfired will be just fine for me. Maybe a nice FPS too. Spend about $170 and another later. Otherwise I spend $300-$400 now and then I'll be tempted to spend another $300-$400 later and my wife will kill me. Wives and hardware don't mix.

    Getting too old for this $&17!

  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394
    Originally posted by r3zs1ckn3ss


    Damn. Y'all must be doing some heavy gaming. I just wanna play my MMO's. I think one 5770 and one later crossfired will be just fine for me. Maybe a nice FPS too. Spend about $170 and another later. Otherwise I spend $300-$400 now and then I'll be tempted to spend another $300-$400 later and my wife will kill me. Wives and hardware don't mix.

     

    Chassis: NZXT LEXA BlackLine - ATX Mid Tower

    Chassis Cooling Device: 2x Rosewill RFA80L-R 80mm Red LED Case Fan, 3x Rosewill RFA120L-R 120mm Red LED Case Fan

    Power Supply: COOLER MASTER Real Power Pro RS-750 - ATX12V 750 Watt

    Thermal Compound: Arctic Silver 5 Thermal Compound

    Mainboard : ASUS P5E3 WS PRO- X38 LGA 775 ATX

    Memory: 4 GB Patriot Extreme Performance PC3-10666 DDR3-1333- Quad Channel in Crossfire

    Memory Cooling Device: EVERCOOL MNC-E

    Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 Wolfdale - 3.0GHz 6MB L2 Cache LGA 775

    Processor Cooling Device: ARCTIC COOLING Freezer 7 Pro 92mm CPU Cooler

    Video Card: 2x ASUS EAH3870 TOP(ATi 3870) - 851 Mhz Core clock each, 2280 MHz Memory clock each, 512MB GDDR4 each(1 GB Total) Ran in Crossfire.

    Video Card Cooling Device: 2x VANTEC Iceberq 6 VGA Cooler

    Network Interface Card: Bigfoot Networks Killer NIC M1 - 10/100/1000Mbps PCI 400 MHz Network Processing Unit (NPU) 64MB RAM

    Sound Card: AuzenTech Auzen X-Fi Prelude 7.1 - 7.1 Channels 24-bit 192KHz 64MB X-RAM

    Hard Drives: 2x Western Digital Caviar WD5000AAKS - 500GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s (1 TB Total Space)

    Media Devices: LG GSA-H55NK - 20X DVD±R 2MB Cache ATAPI / E-IDE Super Multi DVD Burner

    Keyboard: Logitech G15 V2.0

    Mouse: Logitech MX518 Gaming Optical Mouse

    Monitor: ASUS VK222U - 22" Widescreen, 2ms Response time, 5000:1 Contrast ratio, 1.3MP Built in Webcam/Speakers

    Speakers: 5.1 Surround sound

    Power Protection: BELKIN BE112234 - 4120 joule Surge Suppressor with Phone/Modem, RJ45 and Coax Protection

    Operating System: Windows 7 Ultimate Signature Edition x64

     

    Those are my specs ;)

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • LurvLurv Member UncommonPosts: 409
    Originally posted by spyder2k5

    Originally posted by r3zs1ckn3ss


    Damn. Y'all must be doing some heavy gaming. I just wanna play my MMO's. I think one 5770 and one later crossfired will be just fine for me. Maybe a nice FPS too. Spend about $170 and another later. Otherwise I spend $300-$400 now and then I'll be tempted to spend another $300-$400 later and my wife will kill me. Wives and hardware don't mix.

     

    Chassis: NZXT LEXA BlackLine - ATX Mid Tower

    Chassis Cooling Device: 2x Rosewill RFA80L-R 80mm Red LED Case Fan, 3x Rosewill RFA120L-R 120mm Red LED Case Fan

    Power Supply: COOLER MASTER Real Power Pro RS-750 - ATX12V 750 Watt

    Thermal Compound: Arctic Silver 5 Thermal Compound

    Mainboard : ASUS P5E3 WS PRO- X38 LGA 775 ATX

    Memory: 4 GB Patriot Extreme Performance PC3-10666 DDR3-1333- Quad Channel in Crossfire

    Memory Cooling Device: EVERCOOL MNC-E

    Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 Wolfdale - 3.0GHz 6MB L2 Cache LGA 775

    Processor Cooling Device: ARCTIC COOLING Freezer 7 Pro 92mm CPU Cooler

    Video Card: 2x ASUS EAH3870 TOP(ATi 3870) - 851 Mhz Core clock each, 2280 MHz Memory clock each, 512MB GDDR4 each(1 GB Total) Ran in Crossfire.

    Video Card Cooling Device: 2x VANTEC Iceberq 6 VGA Cooler

    Network Interface Card: Bigfoot Networks Killer NIC M1 - 10/100/1000Mbps PCI 400 MHz Network Processing Unit (NPU) 64MB RAM

    Sound Card: AuzenTech Auzen X-Fi Prelude 7.1 - 7.1 Channels 24-bit 192KHz 64MB X-RAM

    Hard Drives: 2x Western Digital Caviar WD5000AAKS - 500GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s (1 TB Total Space)

    Media Devices: LG GSA-H55NK - 20X DVD±R 2MB Cache ATAPI / E-IDE Super Multi DVD Burner

    Keyboard: Logitech G15 V2.0

    Mouse: Logitech MX518 Gaming Optical Mouse

    Monitor: ASUS VK222U - 22" Widescreen, 2ms Response time, 5000:1 Contrast ratio, 1.3MP Built in Webcam/Speakers

    Speakers: 5.1 Surround sound

    Power Protection: BELKIN BE112234 - 4120 joule Surge Suppressor with Phone/Modem, RJ45 and Coax Protection

    Operating System: Windows 7 Ultimate Signature Edition x64

     

    Those are my specs ;)

    Haha. You included your surge protector. At least your specs kill my ancient machine.

    Pentium D Smithfield 820 2.80 GHz Dual Core

    Gigabyte P35-DS3L MOBO

    WD Raptor 10k RPM 36g HD (OS)

    WD Green 7200 RPM 320g HD (Program Drive)

    2g RAM DDR@ 800 GSkill RAM

    HIS RadeonHD 2600XT ICEQ  Turbo (Automatically Clocked Memory to 2200MHz so no head room.)

    Raidmax Dirktooth Mid Tower Gaming Case (4) Fan

    Thermaltake CPU Fan/Heatsink

    DVDCD +-RW Dual Layer                                                                                                                                                                                         Vizio 32" LCD 1080p

    Yeah. My hardware is screaming for an overdue upgrade. Anyone wanna give me some $. (^_^)

     

    I'm building my next system and have the boxes just sitting there. Gonna take me a while to save for the rest. But so far I have the:

    Intel Core i7-860 Lynnfield 2.8GHz LGA 1156 95W Quad-Core

    Foxconn Inferno Katana GTI LGA 1156 Intel P55

    Intel X25-V SSDSA2MP040G2R5 2.5" 40GB SATA II MLC Internal Solid State Drive (OS)

    Western Digital VelociRaptor WD1500HLFS 150GB 10000 RPM SATA HDD (Games and Apps)

    Now I'm broke. :`(   

    But hey. It's a start right?

     

    Getting too old for this $&17!

  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394


    Originally posted by r3zs1ckn3ss

    I'm building my next system and have the boxes just sitting there. Gonna take me a while to save for the rest. But so far I have the:
    Intel Core i7-860 Lynnfield 2.8GHz LGA 1156 95W Quad-Core
    Foxconn Inferno Katana GTI LGA 1156 Intel P55
    Intel X25-V SSDSA2MP040G2R5 2.5" 40GB SATA II MLC Internal Solid State Drive (OS)
    Western Digital VelociRaptor WD1500HLFS 150GB 10000 RPM SATA HDD (Games and Apps)
    Now I'm broke. :`(   

    But hey. It's a start right?
     


     
    I wouldn't have spent the money on the drives, normal drives work fine. Waste of money. All that will help with is load times of games and the OS, and not really by much. Does not help performance. I would have gotten the CPU, Mobo, RAM, and Video card(s) first and had a usable system first recycling my old drives.

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • LurvLurv Member UncommonPosts: 409
    Originally posted by spyder2k5




     

    I wouldn't have spent the money on the drives, normal drives work fine. Waste of money. All that will help with is load times of games and the OS, and not really by much. Does not help performance. I would have gotten the CPU, Mobo, RAM, and Video card(s) first and had a usable system first recycling my old drives.

     

     

    True. But I had money in my hands and got too excited and saw some good deals on NewEgg. In any case, it's not like I would be using the system anytime soon. But at least I get to take the boxes out and look at them.

    Getting too old for this $&17!

  • VarnyVarny Member Posts: 765

     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394
    Originally posted by Varny


     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • drazzahdrazzah Member UncommonPosts: 437

     nVidia Cards are so much better then ATI. If you are going to run single card and not SLI/Crossfire, nVidia blows ATI out of the water. Price wise, speed wise, and useability wise. Games that have problem with graphic cards, all of the time it has to do with the ATI cards. 

    image

  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394


    Originally posted by drazzah

     nVidia Cards are so much better then ATI. If you are going to run single card and not SLI/Crossfire, nVidia blows ATI out of the water. Price wise, speed wise, and useability wise. Games that have problem with graphic cards, all of the time it has to do with the ATI cards. 


     
    Straight from the mouth of a fanboi.
     
    Not only does ATi beat nVidia price wise, hardware wise the 5870, and even the 5890 both blow nVidias offerings out of the water. Usability? What? Seriously drivers install and run just fine, what do you mean usability?

    ROFL I know tons of games that have issues with nVidia, with ATi, or both. Don't even.

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • drazzahdrazzah Member UncommonPosts: 437
    Originally posted by spyder2k5

    Originally posted by Varny


     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.

     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 

    image

  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394
    Originally posted by drazzah

    Originally posted by spyder2k5

    Originally posted by Varny


     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.

     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 

    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • AmazingAveryAmazingAvery Age of Conan AdvocateMember UncommonPosts: 7,188
    Originally posted by r3zs1ckn3ss


    Damn. Y'all must be doing some heavy gaming. I just wanna play my MMO's. I think one 5770 and one later crossfired will be just fine for me. Maybe a nice FPS too. Spend about $170 and another later. Otherwise I spend $300-$400 now and then I'll be tempted to spend another $300-$400 later and my wife will kill me. Wives and hardware don't mix.



     

    My wifes a gamer too, just as much money goes on upgrades as her shopping habit!

    She is neither for either GPU maker, had them in different machines over the years. She is Canadian though so she likes ATI.



  • AmazingAveryAmazingAvery Age of Conan AdvocateMember UncommonPosts: 7,188
    Originally posted by spyder2k5

    Originally posted by drazzah

    Originally posted by spyder2k5

    Originally posted by Varny


     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.

     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 

    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.



     

    Spyder c'mon mate, I want some of what your drinking.

    Your 3870 beats a GTX 285? lol.

    Now that's foot and mouth disease.



  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394

     



    Originally posted by AmazingAvery


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by drazzah


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by Varny

     

     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.



     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.



     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 



    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.



     

     

    Spyder c'mon mate, I want some of what your drinking.

    Your 3870 beats a GTX 285? lol.

    Now that's foot and mouth disease.





     

    GTX 285:

    Core Clock: 648MHz

    Stream Processors: 240 Processor Cores

    Effective Memory Clock: 2484MHz(effective)

    Memory Type: GDDR3

     



    My 3870(just one I have 2):

    Core Clock: 851MHz

    Stream Processors: 320 Stream Processing Units

    Effective Memory Clock: 2280MHz

    Memory Type: GDDR4

    Please for the love of god, stop sucking up to nVidia and using opinions in place of facts, it will only hurt you.

    See more at:

    GTX 285:

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?item=N82E16814130442

    My 3870:

    http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16814121233

     

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • AmazingAveryAmazingAvery Age of Conan AdvocateMember UncommonPosts: 7,188
    Originally posted by spyder2k5


     

    Originally posted by AmazingAvery


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by drazzah


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by Varny
     
     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.





     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 





    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.


     

     

    Spyder c'mon mate, I want some of what your drinking.

    Your 3870 beats a GTX 285? lol.

    Now that's foot and mouth disease.




     

    GTX 285:

    Core Clock: 648MHz

    Stream Processors: 240 Processor Cores

    Effective Memory Clock: 2484MHz(effective)

    Memory Type: GDDR3

     



    My 3870(just one I have 2):

    Core Clock: 851MHz

    Stream Processors: 320 Stream Processing Units

    Effective Memory Clock: 2280MHz

    Memory Type: GDDR4

    Please for the love of god, stop sucking up to nVidia and using opinions in place of facts, it will only hurt you.

    See more at:

    GTX 285:

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?item=N82E16814130442

    My 3870:

    http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16814121233

     



     

    Are you trying to educate people that SPU's and architecture is the same? FYI what ATI calls a Stream processor is different to Nvidia's. Are you seriously under the impression that  because your 3870 is clocked higher it performs better?

    Not to mention you failed to mention memory interface. 512 > 256.

    What about the states that count?

    3870

    Memory Bandwidth: 72 GB/sec

    FLOPS: 496 GFLOPS

    Pixel Fill Rate: 12400 MPixels/sec

    Texture Fill Rate: 12400 MTexels/sec

    Texture Units: 16

    Raster Operators 16

    Shader Clock: 775 MHz

    GTX 285

    Memory Bandwidth: 158.976 GB/sec

    FLOPS: 1062.72 GFLOPS

    Pixel Fill Rate: 20736 MPixels/sec

    Texture Fill Rate: 51840 MTexels/sec

    Texture Units: 80

    Raster Operators 32

    Shader Clock: 1476 MHz

    Someone please explain to him.

    We will see the same this year, a higher memory interface and lower clocks from nvidia out performing at the top end on single GPU.



  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394

     



    Originally posted by AmazingAvery


    Originally posted by spyder2k5
     
     

    Originally posted by AmazingAvery


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by drazzah


    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Originally posted by Varny
     
     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.
     
     


     
    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.
     
     


     
    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 
     
     


    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.
     
     


     
     
    Spyder c'mon mate, I want some of what your drinking.
    Your 3870 beats a GTX 285? lol.
    Now that's foot and mouth disease.
     
     


     
     
    GTX 285:
    Core Clock: 648MHz
    Stream Processors: 240 Processor Cores
    Effective Memory Clock: 2484MHz(effective)
    Memory Type: GDDR3
     
    My 3870(just one I have 2):
    Core Clock: 851MHz
    Stream Processors: 320 Stream Processing Units
    Effective Memory Clock: 2280MHz
    Memory Type: GDDR4
    Please for the love of god, stop sucking up to nVidia and using opinions in place of facts, it will only hurt you.
    See more at:
    GTX 285:
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?item=N82E16814130442
    My 3870:
    http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16814121233
     


     
     
    Are you trying to educate people that SPU's and architecture is the same? FYI what ATI calls a Stream processor is different to Nvidia's. Are you seriously under the impression that  because your 3870 is clocked higher it performs better?
    Not to mention you failed to mention memory interface. 512 > 256.
    What about the states that count?
    3870
    Memory Bandwidth: 72 GB/sec
    FLOPS: 496 GFLOPS
    Pixel Fill Rate: 12400 MPixels/sec
    Texture Fill Rate: 12400 MTexels/sec
    Texture Units: 16
    Raster Operators 16
    Shader Clock: 775 MHz
    GTX 285
    Memory Bandwidth: 158.976 GB/sec
    FLOPS: 1062.72 GFLOPS
    Pixel Fill Rate: 20736 MPixels/sec
    Texture Fill Rate: 51840 MTexels/sec
    Texture Units: 80
    Raster Operators 32
    Shader Clock: 1476 MHz
    Someone please explain to him.
    We will see the same this year, a higher memory interface and lower clocks from nvidia out performing at the top end on single GPU.


    ROFL, I see now you know very little about computer, or the hardware involved. Those specs mean jack s*** on the nVidia, the whole thing bottlenecks itself. The card can only run as fast as its slowest component. You also fail to realize mine as well as the one quoted is the higher end versions of the spectrum, my 3870s are not stock. It would easily beat the 285. Sorry to burst your false knowledge party.
     
    Oh and that site? It posts theoretical figures that are just that theoretical, they are not numbers you can do anything else with. They don't mean anything next to real numbers and based facts which I have shown.
     
    This topic has gone into retardation with all the supposed people that claim they know stuff they obviously do not. I am tired of fighting idiots all day. Argue with yourself.
     

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • AmazingAveryAmazingAvery Age of Conan AdvocateMember UncommonPosts: 7,188
    Originally posted by spyder2k5


     

     



    Originally posted by AmazingAvery




    Originally posted by spyder2k5

     

     


     
    Originally posted by AmazingAvery

     

     
    Originally posted by spyder2k5

     

     
    Originally posted by drazzah

     

     
    Originally posted by spyder2k5

     

     
    Originally posted by Varny

     

     Well ATI until Sept when Nvidia launches their next round of cards which will probably be better. Then ATI will release theirs which will be better and it goes back and forth like this until one gets bought by the other.

     

     


     

    That was how it was YEARS ago. Now it is one or the other. And sad to say even with the newer nVida cards they will still lack the power of the newer ATi ones. My 3870s beat nVidias latest, hell the old 8800 nVidia cards out power their new ones.

     

     

     






     

    And spyder, you should do your research because ATI cards have more problems with bottlenecking than nVidia, 

     

     

     






    ROFL! Hardware specs say otherwise, the ram and the speed of the GPU run without bottlenecking. Sorry nice try. Learn what bottlenecking is, and how it happens, and most of all please stop sticking your foot in your mouth.

     

     

     






     

     

    Spyder c'mon mate, I want some of what your drinking.

    Your 3870 beats a GTX 285? lol.

    Now that's foot and mouth disease.

     

     

     






     

     

    GTX 285:

    Core Clock: 648MHz

    Stream Processors: 240 Processor Cores

    Effective Memory Clock: 2484MHz(effective)

    Memory Type: GDDR3

     

    My 3870(just one I have 2):

    Core Clock: 851MHz

    Stream Processors: 320 Stream Processing Units

    Effective Memory Clock: 2280MHz

    Memory Type: GDDR4

    Please for the love of god, stop sucking up to nVidia and using opinions in place of facts, it will only hurt you.

    See more at:

    GTX 285:

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?item=N82E16814130442

    My 3870:

    http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16814121233

     

     






     

     

    Are you trying to educate people that SPU's and architecture is the same? FYI what ATI calls a Stream processor is different to Nvidia's. Are you seriously under the impression that  because your 3870 is clocked higher it performs better?

    Not to mention you failed to mention memory interface. 512 > 256.

    What about the states that count?

    3870

    Memory Bandwidth: 72 GB/sec

    FLOPS: 496 GFLOPS

    Pixel Fill Rate: 12400 MPixels/sec

    Texture Fill Rate: 12400 MTexels/sec

    Texture Units: 16

    Raster Operators 16

    Shader Clock: 775 MHz

    GTX 285

    Memory Bandwidth: 158.976 GB/sec

    FLOPS: 1062.72 GFLOPS

    Pixel Fill Rate: 20736 MPixels/sec

    Texture Fill Rate: 51840 MTexels/sec

    Texture Units: 80

    Raster Operators 32

    Shader Clock: 1476 MHz

    Someone please explain to him.

    We will see the same this year, a higher memory interface and lower clocks from nvidia out performing at the top end on single GPU.

     



     

    ROFL, I see now you know very little about computer, or the hardware involved. Those specs mean jack s*** on the nVidia, the whole thing bottlenecks itself. The card can only run as fast as its slowest component. You also fail to realize mine as well as the one quoted is the higher end versions of the spectrum, my 3870s are not stock. It would easily beat the 285. Sorry to burst your false knowledge party.

     

    Oh and that site? It posts theoretical figures that are just that theoretical, they are not numbers you can do anything else with. They don't mean anything next to real numbers and based facts which I have shown.

     

    This topic has gone into retardation with all the supposed people that claim they know stuff they obviously do not. I am tired of fighting idiots all day. Argue with yourself.

     



     

    Link me reputable game benchmarks to prove what you are saying. If you noticed you can move the OC slider on linked site to OC your card to the high end and watch the numbers go up.

    If you want to live in dreamland that is your choice I am just trying to help you out as it is clear you have an issue.

    Self denial.

    I owned a 3870 and 3870x2, have the boxes with the stats in front of me. Went 8800 never looked back. Then went GTX doubled the fun..



  • CleffyCleffy Member RarePosts: 6,414

    No upper end GPU is going to bottleneck performance.  That said the HD3870 and GTX285 have different strengths.

    The HD3870 is a poly rendering/calculation card to the extreme.  It can do things the GTX285 simply can't.  I think AMD had the right idea with the HD2900 and subsequent HD3870, the future of games will be in calculations and increased amount of polies.  Instead of making a card based on DX9.0 development they made a card that can render millions of polies and can real-time ray trace.  This path actually makes more sense then continuing with larger texture and rasterization, since that path will be victim to hard drive load, limited memory limits of 32-bit software, and larger transistor counts for limited effect.  However, the game industry did not seem to agree on this and decided not to use Real-time Raytracing and Instanced Based Tesselation.

    The GTX285 uses an architecture that nVidia themselves will kill with Fermi.  If you get a recent nVidia card you made a bad investment.  Although it can rasterize really quickly and load extremely large textures, this isn't the future of game development and will be obsolete soon enough.  The benefit of the GTX285 is it has a superior amount of transistors.  The downside is those transistors are badly utilized and no game will ever make use of them all.

  • mudstuckmudstuck Member Posts: 203

    I am no PC tech, just a casual observer. Yet, I've decided that ATI would be my choice, for one reason. I've been seeing alot of threads here, and elsewhere, about 8 series Nvidia's going poof. And as I look more, I see much more about Nvidia's, going poof, in general. Could be other reasons, why I dont see much about ATI's going poof, but it's enough for me.

  • LurvLurv Member UncommonPosts: 409

    Well as you may have noticed in a lot of reviews and forums, the majority pretty much rules in favor of ATI owning 2010 and possibly 2011 if they keep chugging along at this route. At one point Nvdia was a couple steps ahead but now this time it's the complete opposite. And let's not forgot Intel's plans to jump into the market therefore creating another competitor for them.

    Getting too old for this $&17!

  • AmazingAveryAmazingAvery Age of Conan AdvocateMember UncommonPosts: 7,188
    Originally posted by mudstuck


    I am no PC tech, just a casual observer. Yet, I've decided that ATI would be my choice, for one reason. I've been seeing alot of threads here, and elsewhere, about 8 series Nvidia's going poof. And as I look more, I see much more about Nvidia's, going poof, in general. Could be other reasons, why I dont see much about ATI's going poof, but it's enough for me.



     

    www.tomshardware.com/news/ATI-Radeon-Gray-Screen-Crash,9529.html



  • MorningStarGGMorningStarGG Member UncommonPosts: 394

    Owner/Admin of GodlessGamer.com - Gaming news and reviews for the godless.

  • drbaltazardrbaltazar Member UncommonPosts: 7,856

    if you leave card or processor at default value there are no problem .but when you touch any oc macanism frm ati

    then you get ton of issue ,those softwere are faulty (the auto detect.

    rule of tumb ,any time ati ir amd warn you or ask you for a permission STOP.DONT SET THOSE TUNING!

  • LurvLurv Member UncommonPosts: 409
    Originally posted by spyder2k5


    Don't forget:
    http://www.reghardware.co.uk/2008/03/28/nvidia_vista_drivers/
    or
    http://www.engadget.com/2008/03/27/nvidia-drivers-responsible-for-nearly-30-of-vista-crashes-in-20/
     
    But of course Tom's Hardware never reported on that....

     

    Tom's Hardware never does.

    Getting too old for this $&17!

Sign In or Register to comment.