any game like this exist?

badermal

 medieval sandbox  game with these features
 open world pvp
player created economy
 player formed guilds
 claim land in wilderness
 building our houses/towns in claimed land
siege/raid the enemy houses
 Active community
except life is feudal already tried that out

Myrdynn

Gloria Victis, everything you list, except people playing it

[Deleted User]

The user and all related content has been deleted.

Ungood

I think Mortal Online and Wurm Online both have what you are looking for.

Myrdynn

Ungood said:

I think Mortal Online and Wurm Online both have what you are looking for.

Wurm has combat?

MightyUnclean

What didn't you like about Life is Feudal?  I found it to be incredibly tedious.

Kyleran

Mars_Orbital said:

Black Death / Gloria Victus / Life is Feudal .

LOL, he knows the answer, its the 15th variant of this same thread he's created, 14 of them since Oct 2017.

Either pulling everyone's chain or.....?

cheyane

Kyleran said:

Mars_Orbital said:

Black Death / Gloria Victus / Life is Feudal .

LOL, he knows the answer, its the 15th variant of this same thread he's created, 14 of them since Oct 2017.

Either pulling everyone's chain or.....?

I checked you're right. May be it is a 50 First Dates thing.

Scot

cheyane said:

Kyleran said:

Mars_Orbital said:

Black Death / Gloria Victus / Life is Feudal .

LOL, he knows the answer, its the 15th variant of this same thread he's created, 14 of them since Oct 2017.

Either pulling everyone's chain or.....?

I checked you're right. May be it is a 50 First Dates thing.

No, it must be the Australian version of Groundhog Day except with a koala. Here we go again....

badermal

Kyleran so you beeen trolling on all the 15 thread so atleast let the people help who wants to answer and in gloria victis it sounds good but the game got preset faction instead of player created one  and wurm already tried not even a real pvp game and life is feudal become shit lots of restrictions and limitation in pvp and i dont know why its even called a pvp game

Kyleran

badermal said:

Kyleran so you beeen trolling on all the 15 thread so atleast let the people help who wants to answer and in gloria victis it sounds good but the game got preset faction instead of player created one  and wurm already tried not even a real pvp game and life is feudal become shit lots of restrictions and limitation in pvp and i dont know why its even called a pvp game

As "trolling" is not something I'm often accused of, I had to go back and check.

Looks as if I replied in only 5 of your 15 threads and while I often include some humor in them (sort of a trademark of mine) I actually gave you sound suggestions twice for EVE and LIF.

I also pointed out in one of your latest threads there was nothing on the horizon coming out that matched your very specific requirements. 

Your reply which I missed explained so much, though you never use it in your OPs and rarely bring it up, you brought up Shadowbane asking if I'd  heard of it.

Yes, I have, played it at launch, fun game but unstable and had some designs I didn't care for.

But I'll help you out again, same advice,  no, there are no games being made which will mirror SB.  There are some former SB Devs behind some indie efforts (Crowfall maybe?) but as far as I know no one is trying to recreate anything like it.

Darkfall New Dawn just relaunched,  the suggestion has been given before, you even created a thread about it, so now that it is out are you playing? 

Or will you continue to average two new threads a month where people respond with the same suggestions for games you keep dismissing? (Are you sure you understand the meaning of the term "trolling?")

Here's another one you can dismiss, Legends of Aria, people are having some fun with its early access, one private shard claims to be a faithful recreation of original UO pre Trammel.

But "you" will have to let go of some of your limitations and provisos, and support what is currently available. 

Or make another thread like this in two weeks, where I promise to respond, you've drawn my interest now.

After all, I am a self proclaimed "Harbinger of Failure", and it isnt always about specific games.

 

ConstantineMerus

Kyleran said:

badermal said:

Kyleran so you beeen trolling on all the 15 thread so atleast let the people help who wants to answer and in gloria victis it sounds good but the game got preset faction instead of player created one  and wurm already tried not even a real pvp game and life is feudal become shit lots of restrictions and limitation in pvp and i dont know why its even called a pvp game

As "trolling" is not something I'm often accused of, I had to go back and check.

Looks as if I replied in only 5 of your 15 threads and while I often include some humor in them (sort of a trademark of mine) I actually gave you sound suggestions twice for EVE and LIF.

I also pointed out in one of your latest threads there was nothing on the horizon coming out that matched your very specific requirements. 

Your reply which I missed explained so much, though you never use it in your OPs and rarely bring it up, you brought up Shadowbane asking if I'd  heard of it.

Yes, I have, played it at launch, fun game but unstable and had some designs I didn't care for.

But I'll help you out again, same advice,  no, there are no games being made which will mirror SB.  There are some former SB Devs behind some indie efforts (Crowfall maybe?) but as far as I know no one is trying to recreate anything like it.

Darkfall New Dawn just relaunched,  the suggestion has been given before, you even created a thread about it, so now that it is out are you playing? 

Or will you continue to average two new threads a month where people respond with the same suggestions for games you keep dismissing? (Are you sure you understand the meaning of the term "trolling?")

Here's another one you can dismiss, Legends of Aria, people are having some fun with its early access, one private shard claims to be a faithful recreation of original UO pre Trammel.

But "you" will have to let go of some of your limitations and provisos, and support what is currently available. 

Or make another thread like this in two weeks, where I promise to respond, you've drawn my interest now.

After all, I am a self proclaimed "Harbinger of Failure", and it isnt always about specific games.

 

Provisos.. You don't hear that word as often as you'd like to.

Ungood

Myrdynn said:

Ungood said:

I think Mortal Online and Wurm Online both have what you are looking for.

Wurm has combat?

This is why I link things.

Combat | Take the fight to a variety of legendary creatures and monsters or battle with other players and kingdoms.
Read more at https://www.mmorpg.com/wurm-online#tz8cUwGhL6K3EaX6.99

 From the MMORPG link I provided, it says it has both PvE and PvP combat.

Theocritus

Wurm Online looks like it was made in the 1990s......It was different but not much fun and extremely dated.

Scot

Maybe the OP can just tell us a couple of MMOs he thinks fits the bill?

Octagon7711

Maybe OP wants to be sure he doesn't miss anything new?

Ungood

Theocritus said:

Wurm Online looks like it was made in the 1990s......It was different but not much fun and extremely dated.

It was made in 2006, the same year WoW was released.

badermal

ikcin yes its really hard to find that kind of game  and kyleran it is good to make new threads after few months as there many games releasing everyday we will find lots of new games releasing everyday so you will get different replies too and even there is new game coming called conquer blade and legend of aria do not have siege it does?

Kyleran

badermal said:

ikcin yes its really hard to find that kind of game  and kyleran it is good to make new threads after few months as there many games releasing everyday we will find lots of new games releasing everyday so you will get different replies too and even there is new game coming called conquer blade and legend of aria do not have siege it does?

Speaking of games recently releasing, new zombie, survival PVP centric game just launched, Dead Maze I believe, this site is even having a promotion giving players a free nail studded bat.

I believe the game has full or partial  looting even, right up your alley.

But its not a medieval setting.....

Give it a try,  its F2P even.



BTW while the  game did actually spring from no where, the game you are looking for won't. 

Every 2 months would be great to revisit, you've created 14 similar posts since Oct 2017, 5 months ago. 

You are averaging over 2 a month, the market doesn't change that much. 

Besides, you could do some research you know,  read some of the articles here and at other sites.

Then maybe you'll be able to come here and tell everyone about something new on the horizon, instead of asking.

Ungood

badermal said:

ikcin yes its really hard to find that kind of game  and kyleran it is good to make new threads after few months as there many games releasing everyday we will find lots of new games releasing everyday so you will get different replies too and even there is new game coming called conquer blade and legend of aria do not have siege it does?

It's hard.. because as we have seen from the games with such features.. nowhere near enough people will play it.

Most of the people that want to play a game like that, don't want to play with the kind of people that want to play a game like that.

kitarad

Ungood said:

badermal said:

ikcin yes its really hard to find that kind of game  and kyleran it is good to make new threads after few months as there many games releasing everyday we will find lots of new games releasing everyday so you will get different replies too and even there is new game coming called conquer blade and legend of aria do not have siege it does?

It's hard.. because as we have seen from the games with such features.. nowhere near enough people will play it.

Most of the people that want to play a game like that, don't want to play with the kind of people that want to play a game like that.

That is so true the bit where you say that 'they don't want to play with the kind of people that want to play a game like that' really struck a chord with me. So many times I go to a game and then I read what the community posts and it totally turns me off or when I log in and read what the chat is like or what they are doing in the game I just log off and don't come back.... am I typical of the average player one might ask ...no idea but it is food for thought.

anemo

Screeps on all accounts.  

RTS at MMO scale with RPG elements to stop unlimited growth and experienced through AI programming.   (3 servers with 300 to 1000 players that you can freely travel between running 24/7)

If you cross that skill gap it's one of the most rewarding MMOs out there.  That also supports an amazing community that is absurdly helpful, and friendly considering its PVP is brutally hardcore. 

EDIT: a major win here is that everyone does the interesting building and planning parts.  Rather than there needing to 30 F1 donkeys to one 'decider'.

Cryomatrix

anemo said:

Screeps on all accounts.  

RTS at MMO scale with RPG elements to stop unlimited growth and experienced through AI programming.   (3 servers with 300 to 1000 players that you can freely travel between running 24/7)

If you cross that skill gap it's one of the most rewarding MMOs out there.  That also supports an amazing community that is absurdly helpful, and friendly considering its PVP is brutally hardcore. 

EDIT: a major win here is that everyone does the interesting building and planning parts.  Rather than there needing to 30 F1 donkeys to one 'decider'.

But you need to know how to program right?

anemo

Cryomatrix said:

anemo said:

Screeps on all accounts.  

RTS at MMO scale with RPG elements to stop unlimited growth and experienced through AI programming.   (3 servers with 300 to 1000 players that you can freely travel between running 24/7)

If you cross that skill gap it's one of the most rewarding MMOs out there.  That also supports an amazing community that is absurdly helpful, and friendly considering its PVP is brutally hardcore. 

EDIT: a major win here is that everyone does the interesting building and planning parts.  Rather than there needing to 30 F1 donkeys to one 'decider'.

But you need to know how to program right?

Pretty much.   The devs don't recommend going in blind.

There have been a small handful that can talk about having done so.   But they're an exception (that normally have done something programming like, like using contactor logic/ladder logic on their day job).   

Personally I think someone who has put 10 to 20 hours in learning the formal logic behind programming or 20 to 40 something just goofing around with it (even if it's using plain markup to make web pages look right)...   Will be able to have tons of fun with logic that isn't perfect, use hard coded values too often, and similar (I know I've done similarly and have done well).

EDIT:  You can look at the simulator and tutorial without needing to log in,  there won't even be registration nags to do so. 

Deadflag

This is EXACTLY  like Mystera Legacy. 

Http://www.mysteralegacy.com

Can also play on the go with android.  Or on PC.

Sid_Vicious

Darkfall New Dawn just came out last month and I have been having lots of fun with it... they made quite a few changes. Should be active for at least another year but now is the time to start playing since its a PVP game.