Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

How would you prevent open world ghost towns and urban sprawl?

There is hard balance between having space for everyone to build, barren landscape, ghost town and urban sprawl in open world building. You don't want world too small or land will dry up fast.  If your world is too big it will be barren and sensitive to population loss.  Players will leave and even return to your game so you will have to deal with abandoned houses.  If you allow building to be too freelance and too numerous in one are you will have sprawling plots of houses with no organization.  

So what would be your solution to those issues?
«13

Comments

  • Morgenes83Morgenes83 Member UncommonPosts: 287
    Let mobs attack/destroy houses. Only if you build little towns and visit them frequently some guards spawn which defend against the mobs.

    Or you can only build a fence if you have a couple of houses standing next to each other. The fence can still be damaged but it repairs if the town is visited frequently and actions are participated in it

    Would fit more into a zombie setting but its just a first draft.














    AlBQuirky

    1997 Meridian 59 'til 2019 ESO 

    Waiting for Camelot Unchained & Pantheon

  • Octagon7711Octagon7711 Member LegendaryPosts: 9,004
    I like what SWG did.  If you didn't continue to pay a small amount of rent on the property it would eventually be condemned and destroyed.  If you were leaving for a long time you could pack up your house and put it in your inventory.  I liked housing that wasn't instanced and could be used as a store front.  ESO houses are good for instant travel locations and some storage.

    "We all do the best we can based on life experience, point of view, and our ability to believe in ourselves." - Naropa      "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are."  SR Covey

  • EldurianEldurian Member EpicPosts: 2,736
    edited June 2018
    So one system I want in the game I would eventually like to develop is "influence". The purpose of influence is settling leadership disputes in PvP-light areas. Essentially questing, crafting, harvesting etc. all generate influence for the character that does them. This influence can then be used to support various political parties to see players that you support take office.

    Influence generation is heavily weighted toward tasks you need to be online actively taking part in, in order to build it. If you can multi-box 20 characters doing the same task at the same time, that task will be a low influence generation task. If you need your full attention devoted to a single task to have any prayer of success, that task will be a high influence generation task.

    Such a system could also be used to control housing a bit. You need X influence with the controlling faction of the region in order to own a certain plot of property. Since influence is weighted toward active tasks this makes it difficult to just pay taxes on a certain piece of property forever without actively playing the game unless it's a very low influence requirement piece of property. It also makes it difficult to go the ArcheAge route and have 20 accounts that control 60+ pieces of property.

    This also would couple with ideas like there being a lot of benefits to having all your alts on one account that you would have to forgo in order to make a bunch of alts to game the property system.

    Essentially. Make the most efficient path to having great property options actively playing the crap out of a single account. That's how you get farms, manors, etc. Someone who has 40 accounts they play 5 minutes a month can have 40 single rooms at various inns (Which would not be highly beneficial to them so it's unlikely people would do this.)
    MadFrenchieGdemami
  • AmatheAmathe Member LegendaryPosts: 7,630
    As to player built structures:

    If a building is vacant for long enough it becomes haunted or becomes a hangout for villains - either way it transforms into a point of interest and something to fight lives there.

    if a building becomes vacant for even longer it eventually catches fire and burns down.
    Sovrath[Deleted User]CryomatrixUngoodOctagon7711AlBQuirkyGdemami

    EQ1, EQ2, SWG, SWTOR, GW, GW2 CoH, CoV, FFXI, WoW, CO, War,TSW and a slew of free trials and beta tests

  • EldurianEldurian Member EpicPosts: 2,736
    Amathe said:
    As to player built structures:

    If a building is vacant for long enough it becomes haunted or becomes a hangout for villains - either way it transforms into a point of interest and something to fight lives there.

    if a building becomes vacant for even longer it eventually catches fire and burns down.
    I feel like this is only a slight variation on currently existing systems. Like it could work as a part of another system but the real issue you get is that:

    1. People are able to claim too many properties too easily, but most systems that make it hard for land moguls to own half the map also make it hard for newbs to get property.

    2. A lot of people earn their property while playing actively, then go mostly inactive but maintain a piece of property they barely use for years afterwards. For instance the roadside inn (tradesman's manor) I built in ArcheAge stood for like a year. 6 months of which I was just having my fiancé log me in for 5 minutes a day to burn labor on tax certs while we were without a second operational gaming computer. That along with like 5-10 other pieces of property.

    Wurm Online, ArcheAge, LOTRO etc. They all have land ownership systems and they all have a way that land is lost if you straight up stop playing the game. But it is very easy for one barely active player to control many properties for years at a time, making most towns feel like ghost towns.

    That is why I suggest tying it to something like my proposed influence system. You would make it very easy for anyone to maintain a room at an inn or something so less active players can have a little space to throw some decorations and chests but if you want to own big pieces of property with resource production and crap attached to it, you need to be a very active player constantly re-earning your right to that plot of land. Or perhaps share it with a group who can generate the needed influence working together.
    Gdemami
  • FlyByKnightFlyByKnight Member EpicPosts: 3,967
    The housing situation in Archeage was fine, all they needed to do was limit the amount of land folks could own then slowly allow them to have more as the server ecosystem stabilized. They also should have locked people into a more comprehensive yet rigid grid system. In-game land tax/demolition worked fine, they just needed to tweak the timing to maybe once a month rather than weekly. They obviously did none of this because P2W.

    Instanced housing is absolute dumpster juice IMO.
    Octagon7711SteelhelmGdemami
    "As far as the forum code of conduct, I would think it's a bit outdated and in need of a refre *CLOSED*" 

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  • CryomatrixCryomatrix Member EpicPosts: 3,223
    I loved exploring in SWG and coming to random houses and going in them and seeing how well they were decorated. It was a lovely thing to see. 

    Cryomatrix
    mklinicOctagon7711AlBQuirky
    Catch me streaming at twitch.tv/cryomatrix
    You can see my sci-fi/WW2 book recommendations. 
  • QuizzicalQuizzical Member LegendaryPosts: 25,501
    Have more or less instanced housing, but with a large number of locations for players to choose from.  As a player approaches a structure, the game picks which other player's version of a house there it shows the approaching player.  A player always sees his own house, and it should prioritize guildmates or friends over strangers.  It should also prioritize active players over inactive.

    That way, if a player who owns a house goes idle, the house isn't unused.  The game just picks a different player whose house is at the same site as the one to be visible to other players and the game world seems as active as before.

    Also give players bonuses for logging off in their own house, and then if another player would see your house as he approaches, he sees your character, too, even though you're offline.  That way, the player housing areas don't seem like a ghost town.
    AlBQuirkyGdemami
  • Flyte27Flyte27 Member RarePosts: 4,574
    I think it is possible to do so.

    It is true that some people who have a lot of time would have a huge advantage.  I'm not sure why people get so upset about this.  There are tradeoffs in real life for spending a lot of time in a game.

    Houses shouldn't be permanent.  If you don't pay a fee every so often in the game eventually the house disappears.

    Houses can be attacked, damaged, destroyed, pillaged, stolen with a deed, etc..  If a house is damaged you have to pay money to repair it.

    I think the key factor is to make it difficult for people to have a permanent house.

    I am not a big fan of instanced houses.  I'm not the type of person who wants a house in a fantasy world.  Especially for cosmetic reasons.  It's just not my cup of tea.  I could do that in real life and it would be more useful to me.  I also like to go adventuring in a game as it's not something I get to do often in real life.  Sitting in a house or at work, a lot is what I mostly do anyway.
    Gdemami
  • MendelMendel Member LegendaryPosts: 5,609
    If land is finite, there will eventually be a problem with people who no longer play having in-game characters owning property.  The best solution is instanced neighborhoods.

    It might be possible if enough people want to build in a certain area, a neighborhood could 'spawn' at that location.  When a certain % of the properties are sold, a new instance could appear there.  That might make it simpler for some to accept the instanced housing concept without everyone having the 'magnificent view' and 'defensible location'.




    Logic, my dear, merely enables one to be wrong with great authority.

  • QuizzicalQuizzical Member LegendaryPosts: 25,501
    Nyctelios said:
    Quizzical said:
    Have more or less instanced housing, but with a large number of locations for players to choose from.  As a player approaches a structure, the game picks which other player's version of a house there it shows the approaching player.  A player always sees his own house, and it should prioritize guildmates or friends over strangers.  It should also prioritize active players over inactive.

    That way, if a player who owns a house goes idle, the house isn't unused.  The game just picks a different player whose house is at the same site as the one to be visible to other players and the game world seems as active as before.

    Also give players bonuses for logging off in their own house, and then if another player would see your house as he approaches, he sees your character, too, even though you're offline.  That way, the player housing areas don't seem like a ghost town.
    You are kinda describing BDO housing system.

    It is an instanced housing where the house is always there you just pick "which" house you'll enter.
    No, I'm describing something far more expansive.  The game picks which particular player's version of the house it will show you for you.  The door is open, and you can walk in and see how that particular player decorated his house.  Players could override the game's default choice of whose version to show you, but the person casually running by would see a bunch of houses belonging to active players with the players' characters standing there in many of them.
    Gdemami
  • CryomatrixCryomatrix Member EpicPosts: 3,223
    edited June 2018
    How about make certain areas to be dedicated to guild built towns. If a person wants to place a house in an uncharted area they can. It just however comes with a large cost. If you build out in the wilderness you will have the following:

    1) Larger maintenance cost x 10 for in-city costs
    2) Have to hire guards - each guard costs money, more money for higher level 
    3) Have to feed and maintain guards - higher level and more guards mean more money
    4) If you do not log on, your guards will notice that and steal from you. They will eventually steal items of increasing value. 
    5) Until one day, the guards ransack your place and leave. When that happens, you get an email and an on-line warning and in 7 days your place is burnt down and another person can build on it. 

    Four types of housing:
    Normal housing is instanced - pay a maintenance fee
    Set houses in-game - sell for real world cash (like in Entropia) and is tradeable. 
    Guild housing is in certain areas - Guild needs to hit certain milestones and have proper upkeep
    Wilderness housing is its own thing - available to every player but comes with huge costs and can be put anywhere, but not too close to an NPC city or a guild dedicated housing. 

    All items can be placed to decorate your house like in SWG. 

    The crux to reduce the urban sprawl is just to make the maintenance cost so high on wilderness housing that very few people can do it. Also, have it require crafters and others. You have to be uber to have it. If you don't have the time, then better have the credit card for set houses. If you don't have either, then you are out of luck. 

    SteelhelmGdemami
    Catch me streaming at twitch.tv/cryomatrix
    You can see my sci-fi/WW2 book recommendations. 
  • TillerTiller Member LegendaryPosts: 11,486
    SWG wasn't as bad as as some would have you think, at least not on all planets. It really was just a few like Dantooine and Corellia, and even then most people were just peeved because the spot they wanted was taken, or if you experienced  a bit of lag you might hit a building before it loaded causing you to get stuck which was more an issue with the game engine. 


    This could all be avoided with bigger maps with huge build zones. If a map had say several build zones 200sq miles off to the side away from the main content areas with specific roads through those areas, combined with phased housing in main cites, as well as max maintenance days for houses in the wild, I think it would alleviate some of the problems swg had. Honestly once they added house pack-up it made the problem of ghost towns less of one. If you hadn't logged in within a certain time period, your house was set to be demolished, eventually it just got auto packed.
    Gdemami
    SWG Bloodfin vet
    Elder Jedi/Elder Bounty Hunter
     
  • CryomatrixCryomatrix Member EpicPosts: 3,223
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    [Deleted User]TillerScotOctagon7711IsilithTehrothSteelhelm
    Catch me streaming at twitch.tv/cryomatrix
    You can see my sci-fi/WW2 book recommendations. 
  • Vermillion_RaventhalVermillion_Raventhal Member EpicPosts: 4,198
    I had a whole design for a game.  My idea was to have a large continents each being a server but connected. 

    NPC factions with large towns that were planned out.  So around the town you had lots plots that were taxed by the faction at cost depending on location and size.  As more players take up plots the town upgrades and more area becomes open to build on.  Player towns work the same way with guilds in control.

    One advantage to that is the city can have order.  Roads, walls and city decorations can have a place.  So you don't just have buildings plopped down.  You have a city layout for players to build on.  You can also zone for commercial districts.  

    Upkeep of taxes going to factions or guilds would help keep some of the ghost town from appearing.  Also have buildings degrade that must be repaired by a tradesman.  So even if you pay for your plot without repair you building decays. Having town guards as a fee for the city is also there because without guards the town is vulnerable for destruction.

    Players can also free build outside the range of a city but its lawless.  Players could hire mercs NPCs but they would be more expensive than guards.  
    [Deleted User]AlBQuirkySteelhelmGdemami
  • NorseGodNorseGod Member EpicPosts: 2,654
    Instances. Apartments within the cities like Anarchy Online.
    To talk about games without the censorship, check out https://www.reddit.com/r/MMORPG/
  • LokeroLokero Member RarePosts: 1,514
    1) - Taxes are, of course, the most logical solution.

    Taxes need to be relatively impactful though.  If a person is making thousands/millions of currency every month, and paying like 100 in tax, it won't mean much.  This is fine for a starter apartment or something, but taxes need to scale effectively.

    Ideally, taxation would be based on the amount of land and the location, etc., just as in the real world.
    This way if a person is wealthy, they can own more land but their taxes will be escalating as well.

    2) - The other important thing is to not allow people to "stock up" on their payments.  Like someone above mentioned, people just dump tons of currency into upkeep and the stuff will last forever.

    Ideally, force players to have to log in and manually pay their fees every so often. 
    You could even go deeper to help out the folks who have to quit playing for a while and allow their friends/guildies to cover the payments while they are away for a couple months or something.

    Interestingly, I could see a whole business popping up where people make sure your rent/taxes get paid(for a fee) while you are away.
    Gdemami
  • TillerTiller Member LegendaryPosts: 11,486
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    You just pointed out why I like open world housing in games like what SWG had. I used to spend hours just cruising all over planets looking inside people's homes to see what they had or how they decorated. Now to get design ideas for games like ESO I have to find a Youtube video, kinda defeats the purpose of designing your house to show off if few will ever see it.
     
    The first person I ever added to my friendlist I met when I happened to run into her house to get away from a bunch of Womprats lol. She was grinding out armorsmith and hooked me up with some gear to make it back to Mos Eisely.

    Then there was the time I logged into my house and there was a stupid patrol of Storm Troopers right outside the door, I was a weak novice marksman at the time, but also a dirty reb so I  had to burst run out the door and as far away as I could to get out my speeder bike before they scanned me overt lol.
    SWG Bloodfin vet
    Elder Jedi/Elder Bounty Hunter
     
  • delete5230delete5230 Member EpicPosts: 7,081
    I was expecting this to be about world/server population not housing.
  • cheyanecheyane Member LegendaryPosts: 9,405
    Tiller said:
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    You just pointed out why I like open world housing in games like what SWG had. I used to spend hours just cruising all over planets looking inside people's homes to see what they had or how they decorated. Now to get design ideas for games like ESO I have to find a Youtube video, kinda defeats the purpose of designing your house to show off if few will ever see it.
     
    The first person I ever added to my friendlist I met when I happened to run into her house to get away from a bunch of Womprats lol. She was grinding out armorsmith and hooked me up with some gear to make it back to Mos Eisely.

    Then there was the time I logged into my house and there was a stupid patrol of Storm Troopers right outside the door, I was a weak novice marksman at the time, but also a dirty reb so I  had to burst run out the door and as far away as I could to get out my speeder bike before they scanned me overt lol.
    Everquest 2 also had that although it was instanced. You can visit a home and even buy things off the racks in the house. The game allowed people to see people's home and how it was decorated.
    Garrus Signature
  • ScotScot Member LegendaryPosts: 24,445
    I hate to say this but I think housing made a come back because MMOs became cash shop based. When you have a subscription and you cannot buy anything for housing a question mark was raised over the head of the whole idea. If you can buy items for your house (only cosmetic preferably), housing becomes a viable option.

    What should happen of course, is that MMO housing should be a valued feature which any subscription MMO was lauded as having, but it was just one of the many MMO elements which were deemed not needed for "streamlining" or designing easymode solo MMOs as I believe.

    To me it was and is a staple of MMOs even though not having one never bothered me that much, but if you start to only speak out for what you enjoy in a MMO don't get surprised when they ditch raids too.
    [Deleted User]anemoAlBQuirkyGdemami
  • TillerTiller Member LegendaryPosts: 11,486
    cheyane said:
    Tiller said:
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    You just pointed out why I like open world housing in games like what SWG had. I used to spend hours just cruising all over planets looking inside people's homes to see what they had or how they decorated. Now to get design ideas for games like ESO I have to find a Youtube video, kinda defeats the purpose of designing your house to show off if few will ever see it.
     
    The first person I ever added to my friendlist I met when I happened to run into her house to get away from a bunch of Womprats lol. She was grinding out armorsmith and hooked me up with some gear to make it back to Mos Eisely.

    Then there was the time I logged into my house and there was a stupid patrol of Storm Troopers right outside the door, I was a weak novice marksman at the time, but also a dirty reb so I  had to burst run out the door and as far away as I could to get out my speeder bike before they scanned me overt lol.
    Everquest 2 also had that although it was instanced. You can visit a home and even buy things off the racks in the house. The game allowed people to see people's home and how it was decorated.
    Yeah I used to go other peoples homes in that game as well, it was an instance list sot of like BDO. Something was just fun though about finding a random house in swg in the middle of now where and seeing if you could go in. One of the better housing systems in an MMO these days is FF14; the neighborhoods they have are cool to explore because people can decorate the outsides.
    Octagon7711
    SWG Bloodfin vet
    Elder Jedi/Elder Bounty Hunter
     
  • Octagon7711Octagon7711 Member LegendaryPosts: 9,004
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    Great decor!  I also liked what they did with the SoroSuub Personal Luxury Yacht 3000.  A ship that was a home and a place to party that could travel the galaxy.



    "We all do the best we can based on life experience, point of view, and our ability to believe in ourselves." - Naropa      "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are."  SR Covey

  • TillerTiller Member LegendaryPosts: 11,486
    Look at this house:



    I was so amazed when I first played SWG because of the housing. Even though PoE has hideouts, I could care less about decorating my hideout. In SWG, when I played I was a gun crafter, so I had guns and weapons arrayed as if I was a shop. I could own a shop in Entropia but i'm not paying $100-500 for it. Even though it is in the game, it's just not really worth it in a game like Entropia. 

    Cryomatrix
    Great decor!  I also liked what they did with the SoroSuub Personal Luxury Yacht 3000.  A ship that was a home and a place to party that could travel the galaxy.



    I used to spend hours decorating that yacht, actually I had 4 of them most storage. I remember one night I was just kickin back at the bar at the center of my ship, and some nub comes rollin up in his TIE fighter right up to the big windows on my starboard side and starts pew pewing and bumping into my ship for 15min. I guess he thought it would annoy me, but to be honest it was kinda funny that it was even a thing.
    Octagon7711
    SWG Bloodfin vet
    Elder Jedi/Elder Bounty Hunter
     
  • IsilithTehrothIsilithTehroth Member RarePosts: 616
    See housing like that is sorely needed in today's mmorpg and a lot of features from SWG to be honest. Sadly I never played swg in its prime and am sad I missed out(tried the emulator but the graphics are too dated). Closest to that is Darkfall online's housing but it falls very, very short compared to swg.
    Octagon7711ScotGdemami

    MurderHerd

Sign In or Register to comment.