PnP properties most deserving of a MMO

verdantrex

Okay, over in the fantasy novel poll people seemed to go gaga for a couple of the novel series that were based on PnP RPG games, so here's that poll to address them. : )

For the sake of this poll, I'm going to consider DDO to be an "Eberron" game, so other D&D properties are fair game.

V

Pantastic

Call of Cthulu just because it wouldn't be another EQ clone; a lot of the time you can't even hurt the things you encounter. I don't think it would be much of a broad success if done properly though, not only would it need permadeath but you also have creeping insanity which guarantees that your character will eventually 'reture' to spend the rest of his days gibbering in a padded room.

Amber could be a great setting, but it would need to be PVP focused and rely very little on the grind/gear paradign that's so common. The idea of player housing gets interesting when you can mold whole worlds if you spend enough time at it...

A silly MMORPG like Teenagers from Outer Space or Toon could be good too, would be interesting to see how popular it could be.