rating of best mmorpg

hercules

ok I got bored and decided why not making a review of best mmorpg based on different features so here is an attempt all please chip in your views on this catergories.No game in beta or not released please.

1)GRAPHICS- not an important feature for seasoned mmorpgers but a certain standard we all love.ATM I have to go with star wars galaxies(SWG).

2)ECONOMY/CRAFTING- less then a year ago I would say UO hands down but 2 games have blown it away in this feature -Horizons and SWG.Now atm I have to say SWG crafting is more diverse,rewarding and intresting but horizons promises direct impact from crafting such as bridges and building a house there is a slow process like in real life which adds color to the crafting.So a dead tie for me here -SWG and horizons

3)CONTENT- most new games add content as it goes on but to me everquest has by far the most content in a mmorpg atm

4)QUEST- for me everquest hands down.So many quest with good rewards and actually test your endurance and patience like a quest should.

5)DUNGEONS(or dungeon like areas)-Still yet to see a better game in dungeon crawl then everquest.There is a variety of dungeons,in each dungeon different  bosses or semi-bosses which drop different loot.Some dingeons require special tactics in pulling and fighting.You go deeper it becomes harder.Carelessness is punished and this adds to the adrenaline of a dungeon.

6)COMMUNITY-I found asheron's call 2 the most mature and friendliest community by a mile then any other game.Worst I found have been UO and SWG community.

7)GAMEPLAY-I would go with dark ages of camelot for this one .

8)CUSTOMER SERVICE- Anything with SoE logo has poor customer service.Turbine in my experience has lovely CSR which answer in no time.So I go with asheron's call series.

9)SERVER PERFORMANCE-Never had a problem with horizons and this is from launch >might just go with horizons to be honest but I guess this down to luck.I had loads of troubles in my EQ days while many i know never had an issue.

10)STORYLINE- none.all start up with a story and its forgotten after a while

11)PVP- this a matter of choice.I like organised ,non grief pvp with some general reason/purpose.So I would say dark ages of camelot.For grief,looting,just bash them I would play a FPS one but in mmorpg terms guess shadowbane

12)BUGS- I played FFXI a bit and while i did not like the game found little bug problem there.Another game i never suffered from much bugs was DAoC but think FFXI is has less  bugs then any other game.Very buggy game would be SWG still after 6 months has loads of bugs.Not game ending types anymore but many annoying ones.

So chip in guys and list your favourite in this caterogries.Hopefully it will help people looking for something spcific in a mmorpg(we all have our taste) a more broad like idea on what to get instead of a general statement on best ever mmorpg.