It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
This would require the implementation of a couple new things, but if you have a decent programmer neither would be too difficult.
Odds are there are people out there that rate games all 1's because they don't like it. I know there are people that give games lower than deserved ratings because they don't like them (I did it with EVE because I wanted to see it fall from first, but I still ended up giving it like a 6 or 7).
I was thinking of one of two things.
1) Add a reputation system, much like vBulletin and many other CMS and BB software. With this reputation, list two or three individual ratings of a game, prioritized by those with the highest forum rating (Obviously the number would have to have A LOT of growth potential so no one ever maxed).
2) List all individual ratings (like comments) on the ratings page(s) as there would probably be enough) and allow members to give each rating a 'thumbs up' or 'thumbs down'. This option is obviously a lot sloppier than option 1, but probably requires less scripting.
The modern MMORPG is simply not worthy, of the acronym RPG. The straight grind and lack of atmosphere leave me with no choice. From this day forth, World of Warcraft, Everquest 2, and all the games like them shall be referred to as PIGCRAP. People In Guilds Constantly Raiding And Power-leveling