Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

SWG or FFXI?

Im a FF maniac.

I used to play FFVII and FFIX everyday. I luv everything related to Final Fantasy: Chocobos, Moogles, Summons.....

BUT

Im a SW fan. I luv the movies (first trilogy). N I luv everything related to it: Jawas, Speedbikes, Jedi, The Empire.....

Oh sht, this is very difficult.

PLZ help me choose the right game.

«1

Comments

  • SufinsilSufinsil Member Posts: 38

    If you that much of a fan, im sure you will like both.

    If you want to relive the movies, you can visit all the places in game for the most part.

    Too bad you weren;t around for the 14 day trial for SWG. Seemed ok, if you got creative and explored around a bit it was fun. Though missions are far and few different unless you get out there and find some from certain NPCs.

    Really though, hard to say.

  • NeoKyosuke18NeoKyosuke18 Member Posts: 204

    more variety will help you..

    I will just tell you this..

    try out SWG for the free period if fileplanet still has the d/l.

    and if your thinkin of FFXI atleast be smart, and get PC to save money incase you don't like it

    also: in my poll anything but those 2 refers to your 2 not mine!

  • EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384
    do you have a third game in mind? image


    Originally posted by WizGamer
    Now hear me out, its just an opinion, I don't want yours. .
    image

    People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

  • diegolinkdiegolink Member Posts: 195

    Sorry, but Im a hardcore FF/SW fan image

    Plz help me.

    PS: Erase your poll vout EQ2 and WoW, I may wait for those ´til  fall 05, to see how things go image

    Right now is FFXI or SWG

  • FinweFinwe Member CommonPosts: 3,106
    This is sort of askin which poison you'd prefer to be killed with.

    "The greatest trick the devil played on humanity in the 20th century was convincing them that he didn't exist." (Paraphrasing) C.S. Lewis

    "The greatest trick the devil played on humanity in the 20th century was convincing them that he didn't exist." (Paraphrasing) C.S. Lewis

    "If a mother can kill her own child, what is left before I kill you and you kill me?" -Mother Teresa when talking about abortion after accepting the Nobel Peace Prize in 1979

  • diegolinkdiegolink Member Posts: 195

    Im not kidding

    BTW.....here i leave my PC specs:

    2.8 GHz (Pentium 4)
    512 RAM
    ATI Radeon 9600 w/256MB

    which should i play?

  • GatsuSLOGatsuSLO Member Posts: 1


    Originally posted by diegolink
    Im not kidding
    BTW.....here i leave my PC specs:
    2.8 GHz (Pentium 4)512 RAMATI Radeon 9600 w/256MB
    which should i play?


    With this PC u can play both games, but for SWG it wouldnt hurt if u had 1GB of ram, cause its realy memory eating game. On the other hand in terms what to choose i would go for FFXI, cause its almost bug free, very good populated, lots of stuff to do game. I bought it this week, but dont like it that much, cause now when i played WOW stress test i really cant play any other game anymore :) WOW will realy be the ONE and if u live in USA u should consider waiting for it, cause the release will be next month and open beta even sooner.

  • p00kap00ka Member Posts: 167

    How about:

    [option c] Wait until something better comes along.

    C) all the way. ::::02::

    -pooka

  • DarkmastershDarkmastersh Member Posts: 205

    FFXI: Nice graphics, bug-free, linear, bad char customization, good sound/music,good quests

    SWG: Great graphics, buggy, non-linear, good char customization, horrible quests.

    Its up to you

  • diegolinkdiegolink Member Posts: 195



    Originally posted by NeoKyosuke18

    and if your thinkin of FFXI atleast be smart, and get PC to save money incase you don't like it

    Lol, of course im buy the PC version!

    Hate PS crap, XBox alive image! (PC is first)

  • AdoraAdora Member Posts: 320
    FFXI! image

    image

  • aaddamaaddam Member Posts: 83

    As a Hardcore ff fan myself i could not wait for ffXI and now i got it i wish i had not bothered it is one of the worst mmorpg's out there, i don't think it should have the final fantasy name as it is a disgrase to the series.

    You can tell the game has been big time dumbed down to allow ps2 players easyer gameplay, the combat is the slowest i have ever seen(even worse than eq), char customisation is a big time joke and the play online login system is the worst login system out there of any game(if you get diconnected while patching you have to totally reinstall the game).

     

    SWG's main problems are bug's and lack of content so if you wanted to try it i would wait for the jump to lightspeed addon to try it as it shoould be adding more content to the game.

  • CyrisCyris Member Posts: 84

    I've never played SWG myself. I played FFXI which I had a lot of fun with. A friend of mine though started out with SWG and was not happy at all. A couple months after I started FFXI he switched over and has since said he was much happier with FFXI. We are both big fans of the final fantasy series. He is a big fan of star wars where as I am not really.

     

    FFXI while great for a while.. after a year of play though it has somewhat gotten boring.. you do a lot of the same things repeatedly until you're a really high level. We are currentely looking at what other options are out there for us. Looking at World of Warcraft and Everquest2, but really both of those games are more of the same repetative boring grind.. crap. Really waiting for Wish and Dark and light, but not sure if we want to wait the extra 4-6 months for those 2 to be released.

  • RealmreaverRealmreaver Member Posts: 380

    SW: G pretty graphics, Star Wars Theme park, No Galactic Civil War, and people wear cylon armor then stormtroooper/rebel armor. If you expected an INTERACTIVE Star Wars game you wasted your money.

    FFXI has pretty graphics, horrid force grouping, GREAT storyline. If you don't have a friend who is a white mage you just wasted money buying this game.

    Former Stress Tester of WoW

    Realmreaver formally of EQ, SWG, FFXI and WoW.

    Malis/Pirotess of PSO.

    Some named of Diablo 1 and 2 =)

    Grendel Kinguard of GW.

  • CyrisCyris Member Posts: 84



    Originally posted by Realmreaver

    FFXI has pretty graphics, horrid force grouping, GREAT storyline. If you don't have a friend who is a white mage you just wasted money buying this game.





    or maybe he goes Beastmaster in which case he CAN solo and because of the ability to change your jobs at your mog house without changing characters he doesn't have to redo all the quests atain all the ranks and earn all the money all over again.

    no white mage? create your own white mage or better yet red mage which is far favored for parties at higher levels regardless.

  • KilguriKilguri Member Posts: 119

    One aspect that's been left out is the community which is really different in both games.

    SW:G is a social oriented MMORPG, there is lots of interaction with other players and you can play exclusively only chatting or doing tradeskills or whatnot (okay, there isn't much content outside of that, but you get the idea)

    FFXI on the other hand, meh, if the community there is bad enough to get to me... I won't get into it, but if I was you I wouldn't make any hopes meeting even half competent people on that game, they are just too rare and in between.

    Anyhow, choice is yours and it really depends on what you are looking for. If it's solid gameplay you wish go with FFXI, if you want a good community on the other hand choose SW:G.

    ------------------------------------
    Always run with scissors. The quicker you go, the quicker you'll get to your destination and the quicker you'll finish using the scissors, therefore significantly reducing your chances of injuring yourself

  • dosenpfaendldosenpfaendl Member Posts: 3

    Hey!

    I think you should buy Final Fantasy! I am a SW fan also, never played FF but I love it!

    Later you can buy SWG also! But it's your choice. But if you ask me, buy FF! :)

    » Si vis pacem, para bellum. «

    » Si vis pacem, para bellum. «

  • badbrainsbadbrains Member Posts: 9

    Both of those games will get ungoldy boring in no time. Tried them both and they offer nothing other then pretty graphics.

  • NeoKyosuke18NeoKyosuke18 Member Posts: 204

    "Sorry, but Im a hardcore FF/SW fan

    Plz help me.

    PS: Erase your poll vout EQ2 and WoW, I may wait for those ´til fall 05, to see how things go

    Right now is FFXI or SWG"

    Wait till fall 05 eh??

    Well tip for you.

    if you get FFXI right now and start playing.. you will probably have a hard time finding players to party with or just hang around w/ at lower levels... there aren't too many new sign ups into the game and players who have been on for a while are high level and can't help ya.

    now as for you 05 comment... if you wait ... you will experience the SAME thing in those 2 games... high level players not able to really help you the newb out

    It took me 3 years to finially join up into EQ and when I did there weren't Any low level players around to party with or help me out.. i had to rely on high level players who were always too far away to come help me

  • diegolinkdiegolink Member Posts: 195

    No offense but I tried EQ: great gameplay, content, bad community (they wont help you.....ever! specialy if u r a n00b) and horible CS. Its a grind fest image. Every char in the game is lvl 20+

    Ok, youll tell me FFXI is The Grind Fest. Well, I found a good LS, i think this will help

  • Nimrod4154Nimrod4154 Member Posts: 864

    I would personally go with FFXi but it is up to you. If you are looking for the more technology based game go with SWG, if you want to go with the usual fantasy then go with FFXI. FFXI is a pretty decent game although i dont play anymore.

     

    I thought EQ's community was fine. A lot of high level characters helped out lower levels on my server atleast. I brought in a lot of Platinum so i would occasionaly give out a set of armor or a weapon.

    -Nimrod4154-
    Waiting to tryout WoW!

    image

  • KilguriKilguri Member Posts: 119


    Originally posted by diegolink
    No offense but I tried EQ: great gameplay, content, bad community (they wont help you.....ever! specialy if u r a n00b) and horible CS. Its a grind fest image. Every char in the game is lvl 20+
    Ok, youll tell me FFXI is The Grind Fest. Well, I found a good LS, i think this will help

    Most of the people in EQ won't help you if ur a n00b bcuz mst ppl ter dn't liek ppl who tlk liek dat or beg or as for platz$$ but on the other hand, if you ask politely people are more than friendly. They won't help you ever? funny, I remember when I started that game every single person out there helped me, sure it was 5 years ago and the community is ever changing, but even today it's filled with great people.


    ------------------------------------
    Always run with scissors. The quicker you go, the quicker you'll get to your destination and the quicker you'll finish using the scissors, therefore significantly reducing your chances of injuring yourself

  • diegolinkdiegolink Member Posts: 195

    I dont beg for money. Some examples of the great EQ community

    Diegolink: whazzup, do you know where can i find gnolls?
    Player2: Yes
    Diegolink: can you lead me there?
    Player2: Gimme 1 plat
    Diegolink: hey, im a n00b, remember? i dont have that amount of money
    Player2: Bye
    Diegolink: Can you tell me where is it?
    *Player2 runs away*

    --------or how bout this:

    Player: Hey n00b! get the f* outta here
    Diegolink: Why?
    Player: Cuz we are going to do a raid
    Diegolink: So?
    Player: This place is mine
    Diegolink: hey, ive been here half hour!
    Player: We came before you
    Diegolink: You werent here
    Player: Cuz we left
    Diegolink: so?
    Player: This zone belongs to my guild
    Diegolink: Really? I dont see your name here
    Player: G0 f* yourself
    *Player starts stealing Diegolink´s mobs*
    Diegolink: WTF?
    Players: I said GET OUT
    * Guild mates start insulting Diegolink*
    Diegolink: Hey! Ill call a GM
    Player: We did it already
    Diegolink: what?

    *the next day I received a message from SOE.......it says.....I was threatening people and insulting their family????*

    So I wrote a message to SOE, and they activated my account the next week.

    Player: hahaha u n00b
    Diegolink: Why the $%&/# did you do that?
    Player: Cuz i wanted to

  • EnigmaEnigma Member UncommonPosts: 11,384



    Originally posted by diegolink

    I dont beg for money. Some examples of the great EQ community
    Diegolink: whazzup, do you know where can i find gnolls?
    Player2: Yes
    Diegolink: can you lead me there?
    Player2: Gimme 1 plat
    Diegolink: hey, im a n00b, remember? i dont have that amount of money
    Player2: Bye
    Diegolink: Can you tell me where is it?
    *Player2 runs away*
    --------or how bout this:
    Player: Hey n00b! get the f* outta here
    Diegolink: Why?
    Player: Cuz we are going to do a raid
    Diegolink: So?
    Player: This place is mine
    Diegolink: hey, ive been here half hour!
    Player: We came before you
    Diegolink: You werent here
    Player: Cuz we left
    Diegolink: so?
    Player: This zone belongs to my guild
    Diegolink: Really? I dont see your name here
    Player: G0 f* yourself
    *Player starts stealing Diegolink´s mobs*
    Diegolink: WTF?
    Players: I said GET OUT
    * Guild mates start insulting Diegolink*
    Diegolink: Hey! Ill call a GM
    Player: We did it already
    Diegolink: what?
    *the next day I received a message from SOE.......it says.....I was threatening people and insulting their family????*
    So I wrote a message to SOE, and they activated my account the next week.
    Player: hahaha u n00b
    Diegolink: Why the $%&/# did you do that?
    Player: Cuz i wanted to



    lol, are you serious?


    Originally posted by WizGamer
    Now hear me out, its just an opinion, I don't want yours. .
    image

    People who have to create conspiracy and hate threads to further a cause lacks in intellectual comprehension of diversity.

  • DarkmastershDarkmastersh Member Posts: 205

    Of course he is serious.
    L33t H4x0r players tend to hate n00bs in EQ
    I experienced it image

Sign In or Register to comment.