Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Where is the sandbox?

2

Comments

  • SmikisSmikis Member UncommonPosts: 1,045
    Originally posted by BigMango

    Originally posted by Ozmodan


    Chances are not good that this game will survive considering the very shaky status of it.

     

    I'd say chances are not that bad at all

    Look at it this way: AoC with a 120 developers team, huge marketing expenses, etc... has been surviving for months with roughly 100k subscribers. Ok, you will say that they had lots of cash in the bank, have sold about 700k at launch and then more there after; but don't forget that they are selling though retail channels and also have a lot more expenses running a bigger company with northern European and US wages compared to the low Greek ones.

    Now, if AoC with 100k subs can survive with 120 devs + marketing + lower margin on retail sales, etc.. I think DF with 30 developers, the low Greek wages, no maketing expenses, no packaging - only direct download, less servers, direct sales to the customers (they get all of the cash minus the Globalcollect commission) should eventually break even with 20-30k subs until the content gets patched in.

     

    i wouldnt call millions in losses.. as surviving.. well ye surviving.. , but not maintaining it..  .. as they dont make enough to cover the cost.. even without any reasonable profit..

  • VyethVyeth Member UncommonPosts: 1,461
    Originally posted by altairzq

    Originally posted by Dameonk

    Originally posted by argos5


    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    There won't be an economy.  The only way to trade with other players is face to face interaction.  No way to display what you are selling or complete a long distance transaction.

    Good luck getting a player run economy going with no mailbox, player vendors, auction house, or global trade chat.

     

    We didn't have all that in classic EQ and there was the best player economy I have ever seen in a MMO. But.. there was a way to see what you were going to buy.

     

    the good ol tunnel..  best community hub ever..

  • daarcodaarco Member UncommonPosts: 4,276

    If you login to EVE or Darkfall, and fail to understand what sandbox gameplay is....then MMORPGs might not be the thing for you.

    Seriously!

  • Random_mageRandom_mage Member UncommonPosts: 1,093
    Originally posted by Hotjazz

    Originally posted by argos5


    We've been promised this would operate just like a Sandbox game.
     
    Where the hell is it?
     
     
    EVE-Online is a straight up sandbox game.
     
    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!



     

    WTF do you care, you play WAR. You need to pretend you play EVE to get some cred in here?

    Quote :

    "I'm on Skull Throne, where Destruction is daily and weekly getting rolled-over by Order."

    http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/post/2667366#2667366

     

    right.. because people are only allowed to play ONE MMORPG at a time...

    Currently playing Real Life..

    http://i36.tinypic.com/2uyod3k.gif

    For all your stalking needs..
    http://www.plurk.com/Random_

  • warppwarpp Member Posts: 258
    Originally posted by argos5


    We've been promised this would operate just like a Sandbox game.
     
    Where the hell is it?
     
     
    EVE-Online is a straight up sandbox game.
     
    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

    Anyone who believed tasos and his crew deserve everything they get. The so called trolls who tried to tell you that this game is fail were told to stfu and go back to WOW ,now we have the same rabid fanboys on these forums complaining.

    The fanboys got ripped off and i for one am smiling.

    Jah Rasta For I.
    The Wicked Shall Fall..





    http://www.ethnic2020.com/images/Ebay/black-jesus.jpg

  • WyldsongWyldsong Member Posts: 271
    Originally posted by Vyeth

    Originally posted by altairzq

    Originally posted by Dameonk

    Originally posted by argos5


    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    There won't be an economy.  The only way to trade with other players is face to face interaction.  No way to display what you are selling or complete a long distance transaction.

    Good luck getting a player run economy going with no mailbox, player vendors, auction house, or global trade chat.

     

    We didn't have all that in classic EQ and there was the best player economy I have ever seen in a MMO. But.. there was a way to see what you were going to buy.

     

    the good ol tunnel..  best community hub ever..



     

    That brings back some good memories.  Cannot for the life of me remember the connecting zones though...Eastern Commons and the other was a desert? And if you ever played on the pvp server, there was Feymart.

  • argos5argos5 Member UncommonPosts: 219

    LOL. I love you guys.

     

    Just a quick response, I play EVE, WoW, and WAR. I dunno if its in my profile, I haven't updated it. I mostly play EVE and WoW. What I noticed between EVE and Darkfall is that EVE already had tools and options to allow the economy to exist... like one person said earlier, some of these options are disabled or don't exist in Darkfall.

     

    One other thing... someone mentioned about "skilling up" and doing whatever you wanted is characteristic of a Sandbox... but there is a difference between intentional sandbox where they give you a shitload of options to help you do what you want--- and lack of development where they just give you a landscape to rampage across.... So Darkfall is coming off as a "sandbox" without giving players a shovel and pail. Only your shit to fling at eachother, the sand itself to kick into eachothers' eyes, and to each a bottle of water to build a small castle.

     

    So, stepping back. Can anyone express Darkfall's currently implemented Sandbox options? Aside from skilling and town-building...

  • TheNinjaboyTheNinjaboy Member Posts: 243

    I chuckle when I hear the word Sandbox.

    Most MMOs give you some limited freedom to do whatever you want and control the world as you please.

    It's called World PvP.

     

    Darkfall limited it's sandbox ability like most MMOs with the Rogue criminal system.

    They need to revamp it.

     

  • oronisioronisi Member Posts: 284
    Originally posted by BigMango

    Originally posted by Evasia

     


    World is empty prolly done so not many whine to much when pvping they been killed by mobs now 70% of world is without mobs so no danger at all only when you see other players result also simple gameplay.

     

    Ok, so then at least populate the world with some non-aggressive wildlife (you can still hunt it for skinning/crafting/cooking) and scripted NPCS living in the world to bring it alive, add to this the weather system (should be ready I hear?) and player shops (no trade house please) with a trade channel to get an economy rolling and RPG folks would feel at home.

    This is really not much and could be done pretty quickly. It would be enough to satisfy me. If the world feels alive, I have no problem with going out to find the mobs.

    Now add to this the housing system and some more goodies and this would be pure awesomeness.

    Really not much is missing to make it acceptable, I am sure they can make it.

     

     



     

    What in your experience with game development companies makes you think all that stuff "could be done pretty quickly"?  Games like AoC, WAR, Vanguard, etc, that had serious money, talent, and resources to back it up, couldn't implement their small list of corrections that would make it a good game.  What makes you think this small company that has not knocked a single ball out of the park is capable of quickly implementing entire game systems to fix the game?

     

    For reference, I felt the same way about AoC as your last line...and 9 months later they are still trying to figure out what they need to do.  I felt the same way about DDO any 2 years later, they are still moving in the wrong direction half the time...

  • ArckenArcken Member Posts: 2,431
    Originally posted by Evasia

    Originally posted by argos5


    We've been promised this would operate just like a Sandbox game.
     
    Where the hell is it?
     
     
    EVE-Online is a straight up sandbox game.
     
    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!



     

    Its gone they eather have lied or scrap all of most featers.

    Its now a rather simple game with not much depth and only thing you can shape with simple tools is build clancity and pvp.

    Not much left of dynamic spawns or any of that all gone.

    But deep gameplay rpg style or complex combat or complex crafting/harvesting is not in this game.

    World is empty prolly done so not many whine to much when pvping they been killed by mobs now 70% of world is without mobs so no danger at all only when you see other players result also simple gameplay.

    But still it can be fun game only its not what they few years up to year ago promised its all gone:(

    Its one big arena pvp world thats all.



     

    If there was ever a time in my life when it was more appropriate to say "I told you so" then right now, I cant remember it.

  • downtoearthdowntoearth Member Posts: 3,558
    Originally posted by Dameonk

    Originally posted by argos5


    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    There won't be an economy.  The only way to trade with other players is face to face interaction.  No way to display what you are selling or complete a long distance transaction.

    Good luck getting a player run economy going with no mailbox, player vendors, auction house, or global trade chat.



     

    there will be that player trade boards probly within the next week or 2. i guess you could use the clan baords in game to sell stuff for know

  • ArckenArcken Member Posts: 2,431
    Originally posted by downtoearth

    Originally posted by Dameonk

    Originally posted by argos5


    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    There won't be an economy.  The only way to trade with other players is face to face interaction.  No way to display what you are selling or complete a long distance transaction.

    Good luck getting a player run economy going with no mailbox, player vendors, auction house, or global trade chat.



     

    there will be that player trade boards probly within the next week or 2. i guess you could use the clan baords in game to sell stuff for know

    For a guy who seems to know so much about the "future" when it comes to darkfall, how come you didnt tell us it was going to be subpar?

     

  • APEistAPEist Member UncommonPosts: 409

     So, if Darkfall isn't a sandbox, what is it then? 

    Is it linear?  Is it a themepark?

     

    DF is a sandbox.  It just needs to take some lessons from SWG and create a system to facilitate the economy.

    _______________________________________________
    Games looking forward to: Fallen Earth, Mortal Online

    The noob formally not known as not being the formally not unkown known APEist; The Stone Cold Killer of Tarq.

  • APEistAPEist Member UncommonPosts: 409
    Originally posted by BizkitNL

    Originally posted by jimsmith08


    this must mean shadowbane is a sandbox too...

     

    According to APEist.

     

    I've never played shadowbane.  It's not a sandbox?  Why not?

    _______________________________________________
    Games looking forward to: Fallen Earth, Mortal Online

    The noob formally not known as not being the formally not unkown known APEist; The Stone Cold Killer of Tarq.

  • APEistAPEist Member UncommonPosts: 409

     I see a lot of people talking about 'sandbox features' and 'what about the pail, rake, and shovel' crap... What specifically do you mean when you say these things?  I don't think your aware of what you yourselves are saying.

    _______________________________________________
    Games looking forward to: Fallen Earth, Mortal Online

    The noob formally not known as not being the formally not unkown known APEist; The Stone Cold Killer of Tarq.

  • thinktank001thinktank001 Member UncommonPosts: 2,144
    Originally posted by APEist


     I see a lot of people talking about 'sandbox features' and 'what about the pail, rake, and shovel' crap... What specifically do you mean when you say these things?  I don't think your aware of what you yourselves are saying.



     

     

    It doesn't make any sense because SANDBOX IS NOT A GAME TYPE / GENRE.   Its a feature just like skill based, clan cities, alignment system, crafting, etc.

     

    It doesn't mean anything more than being able to do what you want while ignoring the plot line.  Thats all the sandbox feature means. 

  • curiousdaoccuriousdaoc Member Posts: 203
    Originally posted by Evasia



    Its gone they eather have lied or scrap all of most featers.
    Its now a rather simple game with not much depth and only thing you can shape with simple tools is build clancity and pvp.
    Not much left of dynamic spawns or any of that all gone.
    But deep gameplay rpg style or complex combat or complex crafting/harvesting is not in this game.
    World is empty prolly done so not many whine to much when pvping they been killed by mobs now 70% of world is without mobs so no danger at all only when you see other players result also simple gameplay.
    But still it can be fun game only its not what they few years up to year ago promised its all gone:(
    Its one big arena pvp world thats all.

     

    Hilarious, it took less than a week for you to flip flop on your opinion of the game. Pretty good indicator of straight up fail when the biggest fanboy on these forums turns they're back on the game, all before a week of live play has even passed.

    I guess it turned out to be exactly what the "trolls" claimed it would, eh?

  • artemisentr4artemisentr4 Member UncommonPosts: 1,431
    Originally posted by APEist

    Originally posted by argos5


    We've been promised this would operate just like a Sandbox game.
     
    Where the hell is it?
     
     
    EVE-Online is a straight up sandbox game.
     
    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    What the hell do you mean?

    You log in, and you can do whatever the heck you want.

    You can go PvE.  You can go do a quest.  You can go solo pk.  You can go craft anything you want.  You can go anywhere you want to in the world.  You can interact with everyone of all races, however you wish to interact with them.  You can claim and build a city.  You can form an alliance with a guild that owns a city and help protect their land in exchange for usage of the cities amenities.  You can go roll in a pk squad.  You can skill up and use any weapon you want, whenever you want.

    It's pretty damn sandboxy.

    There are only a few things standing in the way of Darkfall becoming a truely great sandbox:

    • Lack of player shops/vendors
    • Current lack of ingame trade boards
    • Lack of customizable (decorable) player housing

    Also, players could succesfully argue that having lesser magic and greater magic as pre-reqs for the 'real' magic schools is anti-sandbox, but I think it's a good element.  Someone who has been ingame for 20 minutes shouldn't be able to recieve 5k gold from their guild and then go running  around casting fireballs of doom.

    If they implemented my three bullet points above, and revamped the harvesting system, and added unique specials for each melee weapon, the game would be perfect for me.

    So, until then, 7/10.



     

                /thread

    “How many people long for that "past, simpler, and better world," I wonder, without ever recognizing the truth that perhaps it was they who were simpler and better, and not the world about them?”
    R.A.Salvatore

  • BigMangoBigMango Member UncommonPosts: 1,821
    Originally posted by oronisi

    Originally posted by BigMango

    Originally posted by Evasia

     


    World is empty prolly done so not many whine to much when pvping they been killed by mobs now 70% of world is without mobs so no danger at all only when you see other players result also simple gameplay.

     

    Ok, so then at least populate the world with some non-aggressive wildlife (you can still hunt it for skinning/crafting/cooking) and scripted NPCS living in the world to bring it alive, add to this the weather system (should be ready I hear?) and player shops (no trade house please) with a trade channel to get an economy rolling and RPG folks would feel at home.

    This is really not much and could be done pretty quickly. It would be enough to satisfy me. If the world feels alive, I have no problem with going out to find the mobs.

    Now add to this the housing system and some more goodies and this would be pure awesomeness.

    Really not much is missing to make it acceptable, I am sure they can make it.

     

     



     

    What in your experience with game development companies makes you think all that stuff "could be done pretty quickly"?  Games like AoC, WAR, Vanguard, etc, that had serious money, talent, and resources to back it up, couldn't implement their small list of corrections that would make it a good game.  What makes you think this small company that has not knocked a single ball out of the park is capable of quickly implementing entire game systems to fix the game?

     

    For reference, I felt the same way about AoC as your last line...and 9 months later they are still trying to figure out what they need to do.  I felt the same way about DDO any 2 years later, they are still moving in the wrong direction half the time...

     

    Ahhh .... yes you are right. Now you have me worrying again

    I remember about waiting for months for Vanguard to get improved like this. After 2 years that game still doesn't have a life, no scripted or AI NPCs living in the world and simple things like object shadows (yes other that the tree and avatars, there are no shadows in that 2007 game), and ... and... oh and also... 

    Reality hits you hard when you know this and realize that here we are talking about a 30 developers indy company.

    Well, let's hope for the best. On the forums Tasos has already said they had wildlife (wolves, lions, etc...), he said they had enabled it (I think it was at the end of beta?), but it doesn't seem to be in at launch. Strange. Also the weather is supposed to be ready? And they say they have the NPCs but have disabled them to allow for more players (WTF?). Trading is also coming I hear? And housing was temporarily not ready but should be coming too?

     

  • heartlessheartless Member UncommonPosts: 4,993
    Originally posted by APEist


     So, if Darkfall isn't a sandbox, what is it then? 
    Is it linear?  Is it a themepark?
     
    DF is a sandbox.  It just needs to take some lessons from SWG and create a system to facilitate the economy.

    A lot of people confuse "sandbox" with "open ended". Sandbox games have a main plot but offer other activities which a player can potentially do if he or she does not wish to follow the main storyline. Open ended games have no objectives and no real story.

    EVE and UO are sandbox games. DF is an open-ended game with no objectives.

     

    image

  • TheNinjaboyTheNinjaboy Member Posts: 243
    Originally posted by APEist


     So, if Darkfall isn't a sandbox, what is it then? 
    Is it linear?  Is it a themepark?
     
    DF is a sandbox.  It just needs to take some lessons from SWG and create a system to facilitate the economy.

     

    Themepark is what describes the PvE ASPECT of most MMOs.

    MMOs that allow nearly unrestricted world PvP are all "sandbox".

    Especially those that allow you to siege other player's towns and battlekeeps.

     

    Darkfall's rogue system is similar (no NOT IDENTICAL) to AoC's murder system.

    Darkfall's PvP siege challenge system is similar to AoC's PvP siege system.

    Darkfall's world PvP is similar to just about any other world PvP system EXCEPT they limit your -rep based on race where Conan does it on levels.

     

    World of Warcraft and Warhammer Online have similarities as well.

     

    Darkfall you still have to "level" they just hide it by calling it skills instead.

    You still have to grind it just like any other linear /  theme parked based MMO.

     

     Sandbox is just the new buzz word right now for hyping up a PvP game.

  • DiviousDivious Member Posts: 37
    Originally posted by argos5


    .... So Darkfall is coming off as a "sandbox" without giving players a shovel and pail. Only your shit to fling at eachother, the sand itself to kick into eachothers' eyes, and to each a bottle of water to build a small castle.

     

    Just for this, the thread deserves a sticky, aleluya bro!

  • APEistAPEist Member UncommonPosts: 409
    Originally posted by Divious

    Originally posted by argos5


    .... So Darkfall is coming off as a "sandbox" without giving players a shovel and pail. Only your shit to fling at eachother, the sand itself to kick into eachothers' eyes, and to each a bottle of water to build a small castle.

     

    Just for this, the thread deserves a sticky, aleluya bro!

     

    Hallelujah.

    _______________________________________________
    Games looking forward to: Fallen Earth, Mortal Online

    The noob formally not known as not being the formally not unkown known APEist; The Stone Cold Killer of Tarq.

  • strongaxestrongaxe Member Posts: 848
    Originally posted by artemisentr4

    Originally posted by APEist

    Originally posted by argos5


    We've been promised this would operate just like a Sandbox game.
     
    Where the hell is it?
     
     
    EVE-Online is a straight up sandbox game.
     
    So stating that... where are the features promised? The economy and the living world dynamic. Is everyone just bent on PvP and capturing towns like its AoC/WAR 5.0?!

     

    What the hell do you mean?

    You log in, and you can do whatever the heck you want.

    You can go PvE.  You can go do a quest.  You can go solo pk.  You can go craft anything you want.  You can go anywhere you want to in the world.  You can interact with everyone of all races, however you wish to interact with them.  You can claim and build a city.  You can form an alliance with a guild that owns a city and help protect their land in exchange for usage of the cities amenities.  You can go roll in a pk squad.  You can skill up and use any weapon you want, whenever you want.

    It's pretty damn sandboxy.

    There are only a few things standing in the way of Darkfall becoming a truely great sandbox:

    • Lack of player shops/vendors
    • Current lack of ingame trade boards
    • Lack of customizable (decorable) player housing

    Also, players could succesfully argue that having lesser magic and greater magic as pre-reqs for the 'real' magic schools is anti-sandbox, but I think it's a good element.  Someone who has been ingame for 20 minutes shouldn't be able to recieve 5k gold from their guild and then go running  around casting fireballs of doom.

    If they implemented my three bullet points above, and revamped the harvesting system, and added unique specials for each melee weapon, the game would be perfect for me.

    So, until then, 7/10.



     

                /thread

    Why is this thread still going? You cannot ignore post like this trolls........its against the rules of war.

  • jonyakjonyak Member Posts: 320

    I want player shops and trading boards... but realisticaly they are NOT sandbox elements... the whole point is for the players to organise that kind of thing... that is sandbox.

    not very realistic, but it is what it is.

Sign In or Register to comment.