›

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Register

Quick Links

Fallout 76 or Red Dead Redemption 2?

LowellsandersLowellsanders Member UncommonPosts: 134
in General Gaming
Hi guys I'm indecisive on which game to get. Fallout 76 or Red Dead Redemption 2?
«1

Comments

  • VrikaVrika Member LegendaryPosts: 7,990
    Red Dead Redemption 2.

    Fallout 76 is a decent game, but Red Dead Redemption 2 is an excellent game.
    mikeb0817
     
  • AvanahAvanah Member RarePosts: 1,627
    If I had a Console I'd get RDR2. MoneyGrab 76 is Fallout 4 multiplayer, nothing more.

    "My Fantasy is having two men at once...

    One Cooking and One Cleaning!"

    ---------------------------

    "A good man can make you feel sexy,

    strong and able to take on the whole world...

    oh sorry...that's wine...wine does that..."





  • kitaradkitarad Member LegendaryPosts: 8,178
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is awesome from everything I have read and I am waiting for it to come to the PC . Fallout  76 from everything I'm reading  looks like its no match to RDR 2 and would be a waste of money.
    mikeb0817

  • RaquisRaquis Member RarePosts: 1,029
    edited November 2018
    Fallout 76 is a disaster stay away.
    Phry
  • ShodanasShodanas Member RarePosts: 1,933
    edited November 2018
    Are you indeed trying to compare these two games ?

    Let's see.. one is a multiplayer based game which when played alone you are tossed into a barren world with almost no npc's to interact with and a shallow story presented via audio tapes you find while roaming the empty world. This is paired with dated graphics and a number of glitches and bugs.

    The other is a fully fledged experience with an extremely detailed and wast world, a meaty and excellent presented story, memorable characters and solid gunfight & gameplay mechanics.

    Hmm.. tough choice indeed.
    mikeb0817
  • newbismxnewbismx Member UncommonPosts: 276
    edited November 2018
    RDR2 without question.

    RDR2 is just downright amazing- Its just an incredible experience as opposed to just being a game. 

    You will get one of the best single player experiences of this generation and imho one of the best games ever made- Plus you'll have access to the online portion which has potential to be something special. Even if the online portion ends up being a cash grab the single player portion is worth far more than the price of admission and online is just icing on the already amazing cake.

    I dont hate FO 76- It was one of those games I pre-ordered and messed around in the beta but its not a very solid title. Ive found myself not being able to pull myself away from RDR2 to even try 76 since the first beta. I hope sincerly it turns out to be great but right now its just- Not.

    -Id also say that even if 76 was great right now, I'd choose RDR2 because- Damn. Its just really that good.
  • AnthurAnthur Member UncommonPosts: 961
    @OP RDR2 is single player and F76 is only worth it if you really really want to play multiplayer in Fallout universe. Ohterwise I would suggest playing Fallout 4 instead.

    So, if it's for multiplayer go for F76. Singleplayer go for RDR2 or Fallout 4.

    Anyway, a strange selection on your side to choose from as those games really have nothing in common. ;)
  • newbismxnewbismx Member UncommonPosts: 276
    edited November 2018
    Anthur said:
    @OP RDR2 is single player and F76 is only worth it if you really really want to play multiplayer in Fallout universe. Ohterwise I would suggest playing Fallout 4 instead.

    So, if it's for multiplayer go for F76. Singleplayer go for RDR2 or Fallout 4.

    Anyway, a strange selection on your side to choose from as those games really have nothing in common. ;)
    Nah, sometimes you enjoy both styles of game and can only budget one title so you just look for the better game (in comparison to its respected genre)

    However, I'd say RDR2 online looks like it could be better online/multiplayer game than FO76- We dont know much outside of speculation and a few things Rockstar has said but with a continuing story, property ownership, camp upgrades , posses and the sandbox-ish world to play around it, I believe its going to far surpass FO76 even with its online portion alone.

    note- I'm know I come across as a fanboy on anything regarding this game and I'm okay with that . I havnt fanboyed about a game since Morrowind. I'm allowed to fanboy every now and again.
  • PhryPhry Member LegendaryPosts: 11,004
    RDR2 it is a no brainer really, its a fully fledged game and it works, where F76 is a buggy mess that barely works. :/
  • PhryPhry Member LegendaryPosts: 11,004
    Anthur said:
    @OP RDR2 is single player and F76 is only worth it if you really really want to play multiplayer in Fallout universe. Ohterwise I would suggest playing Fallout 4 instead.

    So, if it's for multiplayer go for F76. Singleplayer go for RDR2 or Fallout 4.

    Anyway, a strange selection on your side to choose from as those games really have nothing in common. ;)
    Multiplayer is coming to RDR2 and you can be very sure that it will be far better implemented than FO76 is, though i do have concerns about how badly the cash shop is, that is also a concern with FO76. :/
    ConstantineMerus
  • kitaradkitarad Member LegendaryPosts: 8,178
    Multiplayer and cash shop a marriage made in heaven or hell?

  • newbismxnewbismx Member UncommonPosts: 276
    edited November 2018
    Phry said:
    Anthur said:
    @OP RDR2 is single player and F76 is only worth it if you really really want to play multiplayer in Fallout universe. Ohterwise I would suggest playing Fallout 4 instead.

    So, if it's for multiplayer go for F76. Singleplayer go for RDR2 or Fallout 4.

    Anyway, a strange selection on your side to choose from as those games really have nothing in common. ;)
    Multiplayer is coming to RDR2 and you can be very sure that it will be far better implemented than FO76 is, though i do have concerns about how badly the cash shop is, that is also a concern with FO76. :/
    I honestly imagine the cash shop is going to be on par with how bad things have gotten in general- Rockstar claims it will be cheaper than GTA Online but that still leaves a ton of room to still be in 'rip off' territory.

    BUT-

    No matter how bad it is, the single player experience is incredible and worth every penny and the online portion is just a bonus. If I really enjoy it though, I wouldnt feel ripped off spending a hundred or so dollars a year mainly because I would be viewing it as a sort of F2P hybrid.

    I've more than gotten every pennies worth from the game and still have a ton of stuff left to do- I dont think there will be a really high level of replayability once you've done it all but I view the online as a sort of free DLC where even if it is terrible or the prices are insane- It doesnt diminish the game for me or its value in what ive already received.

    76 is different in that theres only that one mode and the cash shop could really be a dealbreaker depending on how its all handled considering I'm $60 dollars or so in and the cash shop affects the entire game and experience..
  • ConstantineMerusConstantineMerus Member EpicPosts: 3,338
    DMKano said:
    This is like asking 

    Root canal or a make out session with your SO

    RDR2 all the way

    FO76 is such a letdown, underwhelming PvE and underwhelming PvP... have no clue who the target audience was for this shell of a Fallout game
    I guess you never had to endure a sudden horrible toothache while vacationing in a remote island. The things I was willing to trade for a root canal......
    Sovrathkitarad
    Constantine, The Console Poster

    • "One of the most difficult tasks men can perform, however much others may despise it, is the invention of good games and it cannot be done by men out of touch with their instinctive selves." - Carl Jung
  • PhryPhry Member LegendaryPosts: 11,004
    kitarad said:
    Multiplayer and cash shop a marriage made in heaven or hell?
    Definitely not Heaven, though it has to be said, Hell has many levels, which grow progressively worse the deeper you go. ;)
  • Kayo83Kayo83 Member UncommonPosts: 399
    lol RDR2. I wouldnt pay for Fallout 76 even if it came with a bj.

    Wouldnt even play it if it was free and included everything in the cash shop.
  • JeffSpicoliJeffSpicoli Member EpicPosts: 2,849
    It really depends on you OP. RDR2 which i own, play & love is a Cowboy simulator not your typical GTA set in the wild west rockstar game, Know that going in.

      Fallout 76 which I dont own, never played but have watched streamed is a Open world Multi player survival game set in the fallout universe.

      With that said, the only way i could possibly recommend FO76 over RDR2 would be if you are a HUGE Fallout fan , otherwise in any other scenario it would have to be RDR2. Keep in mind RDR2 is getting multiplayer very soon so if Multiplayer/online is a big factor in your decision its just one more reason to go with the Cowboy simulator.
    [Deleted User]

    • Aloha Mr Hand ! 

  • uriel_mafessuriel_mafess Member UncommonPosts: 258
    edited November 2018
    You are comparing pretty different things.

    RDR2 its a game. A superb game by the way.

    FO76 is a new torture technique.
    newbismxAsheramJeffSpicolisomeforumguy
  • AsheramAsheram Member EpicPosts: 5,078
    Plus I bet RDR2 has a better soundtrack 
  • LowellsandersLowellsanders Member UncommonPosts: 134
    Don't you guys think that this game is over rated or Over hyped?
  • newbismxnewbismx Member UncommonPosts: 276
    edited November 2018
    Don't you guys think that this game is over rated or Over hyped?
    Not in the least, but I suppose much of that depends on your own perspective.

    To be completely honest I expected RDR2 to be really good but not even close to the masterpiece I believe it to be- Hence to me it was under hyped.

    I think as far as it being over rated, again thats totally subjective. Many of the complaints I hear from people are totally legit but those same complaints are things I enjoy. For instance, the slow pace of the game and the time it takes to really do things are positives to me but someone wanting a non stop action GTA style game is going to be disappointed if thats what they had expected. 

    To me, this game is solid 9/10 and the only way it could have been better would have been if it had been set up with more re-playability in mind...As it stands I dont really see any reason you would replay this once you have completed it (to see a different ending among 4 possible endings probably isnt going to be enough) but that being said , you're looking at a 60 hour experience and if you do all the side activities, you're probably far past 100 hours (I havnt completed all the side activities and I'm sitting at around 75 hours)

    edit- I'm also still playing since I plan to complete everything or at least attempt to until RDR Online drops and I hopefully just end up playing that as my main game.

    This game isnt going to be for everyone- Obviously someone wanting non stop action is going to find this game over-rated. Its a slow build.
    mikeb0817LowellsandersJeffSpicoliConstantineMerus
  • LowellsandersLowellsanders Member UncommonPosts: 134
    newbismx said:
    Don't you guys think that this game is over rated or Over hyped?
    Not in the least, but I suppose much of that depends on your own perspective.

    To be completely honest I expected RDR2 to be really good but not even close to the masterpiece I believe it to be- Hence to me it was under hyped.

    I think as far as it being over rated, again thats totally subjective. Many of the complaints I hear from people are totally legit but those same complaints are things I enjoy. For instance, the slow pace of the game and the time it takes to really do things are positives to me but someone wanting a non stop action GTA style game is going to be disappointed if thats what they had expected. 

    To me, this game is solid 9/10 and the only way it could have been better would have been if it had been set up with more re-playability in mind...As it stands I dont really see any reason you would replay this once you have completed it (to see a different ending among 4 possible endings probably isnt going to be enough) but that being said , you're looking at a 60 hour experience and if you do all the side activities, you're probably far past 100 hours (I havnt completed all the side activities and I'm sitting at around 75 hours)

    edit- I'm also still playing since I plan to complete everything or at least attempt to until RDR Online drops and I hopefully just end up playing that as my main game.

    This game isnt going to be for everyone- Obviously someone wanting non stop action is going to find this game over-rated. Its a slow build.
    And what about Fallout 76?
    Which in multiplayer
  • DwaaawffulDwaaawfful Member UncommonPosts: 65
    Call me a romantic, but nothing beats riding around a Godforsaken wilderness on an unruly mule before galloping into town in a cloud of tumbleweed and blowing some local hoodlums away.
     
    But hey, that's my day job.

    Likely I'd opt for Red Dead.  could be a great excuse to learn to play the banjo.
    Kyleran[Deleted User]
    Stumpiness & Unbridled Misery Masquerading as VIRTUE

    Need an AI-Free Elf Names Generator to bring your next elven character to life? Why ... course you do, you darn fool!
  • XarkoXarko Member EpicPosts: 1,180
    For people actually interested in FO76, give it at least another 6 months. The game is in early beta level of polish.
  • PhryPhry Member LegendaryPosts: 11,004
    Xarko said:
    For people actually interested in FO76, give it at least another 6 months. The game is in early beta level of polish.
    Remember NoMansSky at launch, that was better than FO76, the best you can realistically hope for is that in a years time FO76 is less 'buggy' but seeing as one of the main issues with FO76 is also the game engine the game was built using, i suspect that unlike NMS things are not really going to get any better.
    My only recommendation, which i am only really echoing others who have done far more in depth reviews of the game, is FO76, don't buy it. :/
    Xarko
  • erichoffmanerichoffman Member UncommonPosts: 11
    Red Dead Redemption 2 of course! It gives us an unparalleled atmosphere of the old American frontier with a huge open world to wander about.  
Sign In or Register to comment.