Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

All time best mmorpg and worst mmorpg.

2»

Comments

  • MW2KMW2K Member UncommonPosts: 1,036


    Originally posted by Jorev
    Best- EQ1 prior to Planes of Power
    Worst- EQ2

    Agree with your best, as for worst - The Sims Online

  • brownhackerbrownhacker Member Posts: 60
    I agree with Kaibigan34, EQ2 could be the best mmorpg. I simply love the game. It brings players into its world with a powerful epic storyline and gives them the power to be the hero or villain in their personal advernture. :D

    EverQuest
    II brings players into its world with a powerful epic storyline and
    gives them the power to be the hero or villain in their personal
    adventure.

    EverQuest
    II brings players into its world with a powerful epic storyline and
    gives them the power to be the hero or villain in their personal
    adventure.

    EverQuest
    II brings players into its world with a powerful epic storyline and
    gives them the power to be the hero or villain in their personal
    adventure.

    EverQuest
    II brings players into its world with a powerful epic storyline and
    gives them the power to be the hero or villain in their personal
    adventure.



  • nthnaounnthnaoun Member Posts: 1,438


    Originally posted by Melendu

    I think the best all time mmorpg was EQ, im not EQ fan boy and yes i played it, but EQ really set the bar for many many other mmorpgs to exist and for being a OLD mmorpg its still hanging in their strong and alot of flowing content.
    Worst mmorpg of all time is no doubt Dark and light. Needs NO explanation.



    This is going to get tedious, but let me name off all the ones I have played and then I will tell you which I believe to be the best and worst.

    Motor City Online, DAOC, SWG, Runescape, EQ, EQ2, COH, GW, WOW, EVE, DDO, Lineage 2, and Saga of Ryzom. I think that's it.

    Best- DAoC before the Trials of Atlantis Expansion. Before that expansion there were tons of people everywhere and the game felt new and fun. No instanced combat like that with the Catacombs expansion. No super classes either. ToA brought the worse out in the cummunity by making them fight over spawns that took 24 hours or more to spawn.

    Worst- I want to say Lineage 2, because of the horrible community and long boring grind, but the grind is the only part that actually was made by the developers. So even know it was my favorite game, I'd have to say SWG was the worst, because all the horrible bugs and SOE's inability to treat the customers right.

  • fizzle322fizzle322 Member Posts: 723
    Best : Eve
    Worst : EQ


  • VixenHeartVixenHeart Member Posts: 458


    Originally posted by fizzle322
    Best : Eve
    Worst : EQ



    EQ is worse?  It is the game that pretty much launced MMORPGs into where it is now.

    By today's standards, it's not good anymore, but it's still good.

    Best: Everquest 2
    Worse: World of Warcraft

    I can just feel the flames coming. ;)  This is by no means bait, or trolling.  This is actually how I feel.

  • MW2KMW2K Member UncommonPosts: 1,036

    Whoopee do what EQ achieved. The OP asked for an opinion on what's worst and what's best.

  • SpungeXSpungeX Member Posts: 144
    From what i've played:

    Best: Eve
    Worst: Kal online


  • SoSikWitItSoSikWitIt Member Posts: 65


    Originally posted by VixenHeart

    Originally posted by fizzle322
    Best : Eve
    Worst : EQ


    EQ is worse?  It is the game that pretty much launced MMORPGs into where it is now.

    By today's standards, it's not good anymore, but it's still good.

    Best: Everquest 2
    Worse: World of Warcraft

    I can just feel the flames coming. ;)  This is by no means bait, or trolling.  This is actually how I feel.


    Well, we certainly can’t flame you for having a preference in games can we?

    I just have one small question.

    Have you ever actually played WoW?

    I don’t see how it’s possible not to have fun during at least the first few hours of gameplay.

    I mean…if it’s the worse, that means you’d have more fun playing a MMO like Runescape, which is mind-boggling.
  • MW2KMW2K Member UncommonPosts: 1,036

    The above post was brought to you by the Mamas and Papas and the letter "P".

  • GishForeverGishForever Member Posts: 15
    Even though I hate it now for various reasons, I would say the best MMO I've played is World of Warcraft.  As for the worst, I'd have to say Auto Assault.

  • JaziaJazia Member Posts: 584

    1. You can't say which is the best, which is the worst...without have played ALL the MMORPG out there first.


    2. For those who said wow is the best or "used to be the best"...I can only laugh. Someone said certain game has good idea in PvP, but too many bads in other...while said WOW used to be the best. Well what's good about WOW?

    I can safely say, ALL MMORPG has the same crappy PvE grinding. WOW is NO execption. Then some games have a little good ideas here and there, good PvP is a big bonus. What does WOW have? crappy PvP too. Not saying WOW is the worst, but it's no where near the best, nor any immature who said WOW is the best or used to be the best have the right to judge any other game.

  • SoSikWitItSoSikWitIt Member Posts: 65


    Originally posted by Ulujain

    The above post was brought to you by the Mamas and Papas and the letter "P".


    Don't you be dissing my font.

  • lomillerlomiller Member Posts: 1,810


    Originally posted by SoSikWitIt


    I just have one small question.

    Have you ever actually played WoW?

    I don’t see how it’s possible not to have fun during at least the first few hours of gameplay.




    I certainly didn’t.  I’m not saying WoW is the worst MMO ever, but it is the worst I’ve given any real attempt to play.


    No MMO I’ve ever played had less magic then my first few hours of WoW.  There was no excitement, no trepidation about what may be out there waiting around the corner, no sense of wonder at the marvels I may see and no excitement about what rewards may be in store. 
    On top of this looking for the detail I had come to expect but simply wasn’t there made my eyes sore and the music was uninspiring.  In short, there was nothing but a quick jump into grinding with no expectation or excitement that I would get something cool for my efforts.

    While other games get higher marks for certain things, the best overall mix for me is EQ2.  Whenever I loose interest in one part of the game for a while something else steps up to get me interested in something else.

  • myrrdinirlmyrrdinirl Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 314
    Best - Asheron's Call Worst - Shadowbane
  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182
    Favourite MMO: Ragnarok Online
    Least favourite: EVE.


  • TheodorykTheodoryk Member Posts: 1,453
    Well....I can't really say which game was best and worst to me, so I'll diversify a little.

    Fondest Memories: Ragnarok Online
    Most Hours Logged: World of Warcraft
    Currently Playing: Guild Wars
    Worst MMORPG Experience: Hard to pin down, really. Mu Online comes to mind.


    "Speaking haygywaygy or some other gibberish with your mum doesn't make you foreign."
    -baff

  • paranoidpvpparanoidpvp Member Posts: 539

    I'm still waiting for something to come out that I can truly call "the best", for now it is Guild Wars.

    Worst is a three way tie between Runescape, MU Online and Maplestory.

    image

  • MuddahMuddah Member UncommonPosts: 161

    Best:

    1:Everquest 1

    2:Worlds of Warcraft

    Worst:

    1:Kal Online-Silkroad-Knight Online-Hero Online-LastChaos-Lineage1&2- Nevermind I could go one forever for the most part its pretty safe to say Asian grind potion popping games aren't for me.

    2:D&D Online..what a let down it's a terrible game.

  • dannicusdannicus Member UncommonPosts: 99

    According to what I played

    Best- WoW but really bored of it now and EQold

    Worst- Earth and Beyound



  • Originally posted by VixenHeart

    Originally posted by fizzle322
    Best : Eve
    Worst : EQ


    EQ is worse?  It is the game that pretty much launced MMORPGs into where it is now.

    By today's standards, it's not good anymore, but it's still good.

    Best: Everquest 2
    Worse: World of Warcraft

    I can just feel the flames coming. ;)  This is by no means bait, or trolling.  This is actually how I feel.


    I always though EQ1 was a mediocre game.  It was just a rehash of MUDs I didn't like to begin with.  Its true it was a landmark in the industry (first 3d MMO), but there are a number of us who never really thought it was great.  I just never thought the basic RPG underpinings of EQ1 weren't anything great and it sounded like an utter unwieldly grind-fest.

    From my point if view it was actually inferior to many of its predessorss.
Sign In or Register to comment.