Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

EA or SOE? (poll)

  If you had to choose between one of these two companies to make an mmorpg, which one would you pick?  I would have to go with EA since they've merged with Mythic and Origin, my favorite mmorpg creators.

There are two kinds of mmorpg players...
One kind is the hunter,
The other is the hunted.
Which one are you?

«1

Comments

  • ValkanisarValkanisar Member UncommonPosts: 494

    I chose SOE cause when they ruin their games they dont actually take them offline for good. EA on the otherhand ruin the games and the company that made them then take them offline. Also the fact they ruin all their games but did still have sims online still up and running? There is no way that game had more subs than any of the other ones they took offline.

  • MuddahMuddah Member UncommonPosts: 161
    Has EA even made a MMO yet? Other then online sports console games I don't even think you can compare them to SoE. Heck from what Ive seen EQOA is better then anything EA's done MMORPGwise. Not to mention very successful EQ1 & EQ2.
  • AelfinnAelfinn Member Posts: 3,857
    If I had to choose between the two of them, Id quit MMORPGs for good, that simple. They both have screwed the heck out of way too many games that might have been great

    No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main. any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.
    Hemingway

  • TactisTactis Member Posts: 37

    um... both companies are horrible but I would choose EA just because I think what SOE did to SWG was wrong and EA hasn’t done that yet.

  • mozismozis Member Posts: 436
    EA, because of BF2 (sorry, I know this is mmorpg.com but I can never turn away from my one true love) From what my friends have told me about SOE their staff members deserve horrible, cruel punishment for what they did to SWG.

    image

  • MouserqMouserq Member Posts: 68

    SOE. I still enjoy both EQs. EA on the other hand is about as much of a hard-nosed, money grubbing company you can get. Their MMO business model would probably include monthly mandatory expansion packs and petitioning the US patent office to allow only them to produce MMOs in the future...from which they would shut down after 2 years.


  • NadrilNadril Member Posts: 1,276
    I'd probaly quit life. .

    Lol, my two most hated companies :P. Now I know how people felt in the election.


  • Navi032592Navi032592 Member Posts: 79

    what is SOE..??(Sorry I don't seem to be familiar with this...)::::13:: but I know EA,they make those games that are available in Gameboys and some Sports like Need For Speed..and Harry Potter The Goblet of Firew GBA SP..

    image
    image
    image
    image

  • NadrilNadril Member Posts: 1,276


    Originally posted by Navi032592

    what is SOE..??(Sorry I don't seem to be familiar with this...)::::13:: but I know EA,they make those games that are available in Gameboys and some Sports like Need For Speed..and Harry Potter The Goblet of Firew GBA SP..


    Sony online "Entertainment".

    Notice the quotes .
  • mozismozis Member Posts: 436


    Originally posted by Navi032592

    what is SOE..??(Sorry I don't seem to be familiar with this...)::::13:: but I know EA,they make those games that are available in Gameboys and some Sports like Need For Speed..and Harry Potter The Goblet of Firew GBA SP..


    Sony Online Entertainment, creators of the infamous SWG.

    image

  • herculeshercules Member UncommonPosts: 4,925


    Originally posted by Tactis

    um... both companies are horrible but I would choose EA just because I think what SOE did to SWG was wrong and EA hasn’t done that yet.


    lol thats actually funny.You know little about EA history in mmorpg i can see.
  • JestorRodoJestorRodo Member UncommonPosts: 2,642


    Originally posted by skitzdout

    I chose SOE cause when they ruin their games they dont actually take them offline for good. EA on the otherhand ruin the games and the company that made them then take them offline. Also the fact they ruin all their games but did still have sims online still up and running? There is no way that game had more subs than any of the other ones they took offline.


           You are right , SOE would  keep the game up and take the heat from the players who think that they should take it down thus becoming more unpopular .  EA cuts and runs and goes to the next thing - players may hate them for closing servers but its truly less embrassing then doing whatever you want and screwing the players in the process like SOE does.

    Unaware of the Jestor?
    http://about.me/JestorRodo/

    Friends enjoy his classic Vblog - https://www.facebook.com/GoodOldReliableNathan

  • MW2KMW2K Member UncommonPosts: 1,036

    SOE...they can actually announce games, and then make them and release them to the public, not like EA who announce stuff, build 90% of it, hype the world up and then nix the project.

    EA sucks - they need to sell Origin back to someone so we may see some innovation in gaming once more. "We Create Words"...and they weren't kidding.

  • freebirdpatfreebirdpat Member Posts: 568


    Originally posted by Ulujain
    SOE...they can actually announce games, and then make them and release them to the public, not like EA who announce stuff, build 90% of it, hype the world up and then release it.EA sucks - they need to sell Origin back to someone so we may see some innovation in gaming once more. "We Create Words"...and they weren't kidding.
    Fixed, I added a release. EA make games 90% complete, then release them all full of nice nasty bugs and errors. They also seem to release games for "seasons" instead of "when its done". I can bitch and moan about Duke Nukem Forever being late on release for the past 10 years, but at least they didn't make 10 crappy duke nukem games in the process.
  • swimjoint92swimjoint92 Member Posts: 11
    I can never say that anyone is better game creator then Electronic Arts (EA).  If you look at the games they have not only created on the PS2, X-box 360, but also on he computer, there is almost no comparison.  With the merger EA has gone through, this will only help create greater games, possibly the best we have ever seen, but that is still all up to them and how they use there new asests. 
  • SoejckdswgSoejckdswg Member Posts: 338

    if anything sony just runs a skeleton crew for the games that aren't doing well but they have yet to shut a game down, EA has a proven track record of shutting games down ex: Earth and Beyond, SWG Japan it seems everything EA touches gets shut down, it seems everything SOE touches gets nerf'd down...can't say i would play either of them...

    Defiant

  • HocheteHochete Member CommonPosts: 1,210


    Originally posted by Holofamer

    I would have to go with EA since they've merged with Mythic and Origin, my favorite mmorpg creators.


    Merged? You mean EA bought out and liquidated? I'm willing to bet not a single member of the original Origin staff still work for EA, well... maybe the tea boy or something.

    SOE, while they have made mistakes, have made some good, solid MMO's. Unlike EA, who have simply bought out companies that have already done all the hard work, then proceeded to destroy the game they worked so hard to create.
  • KidWickedKidWicked Member Posts: 67


    Originally posted by Holofamer

      If you had to choose between one of these two companies to make an mmorpg, which one would you pick?  I would have to go with EA since they've merged with Mythic and Origin, my favorite mmorpg creators.


    EA is horrible. they cancel everything
  • MW2KMW2K Member UncommonPosts: 1,036


    Originally posted by freebirdpat
    Originally posted by UlujainFixed, I added a release. EA make games 90% complete, then release them all full of nice nasty bugs and errors. They also seem to release games for "seasons" instead of "when its done". I can bitch and moan about Duke Nukem Forever being late on release for the past 10 years, but at least they didn't make 10 crappy duke nukem games in the process.

    You didn't fix shit. My post as written stands. As far as MMORPG's go (what this forum is about, mind you), EA are renown for cancelling stuff. Two UO sequels ring any bells with you?

    They need to get out of the MMORPG business and go back to what they actually do best: make sports games.

  • DarkchronicDarkchronic Member Posts: 1,088
    Motor City Online and Earth and Beyond anyone?

    ---------------------------------------
    No Userbar here, sorry to disappoint.

  • HolofamerHolofamer Member Posts: 43

      I'm really surprised SOE has more votes than EA at this point.

    There are two kinds of mmorpg players...
    One kind is the hunter,
    The other is the hunted.
    Which one are you?

  • EchobeEchobe Member Posts: 262

    That's like choosing between a tape worm or chiggers.

    Atleast the tape worm doesn't itch, I guess. I think I'd rather commit suicide with a double-barrel shotgun blast to the head...

  • AnofalyeAnofalye Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,433
    This post and the opinions of the users is working as intended(tm). 

    - "If I understand you well, you are telling me until next time. " - Ren

  • ralazoralazo Member Posts: 33
    i choose for EA bcoz i play the most games of EA dont play so much mmo on this time 

  • HarafnirHarafnir Member UncommonPosts: 1,350
    Singleplayer games. Only choice left

    "This is not a game to be tossed aside lightly.
    It should be thrown with great force"

Sign In or Register to comment.