Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

BEST AND WORST MMORPG

2

Comments

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182


    Originally posted by eriken

    Originally posted by Ruthgar
    Best: None so far
    Worst: DDO
    Most overrated: WoW





    If DDO is the worst one you played I guess you've never played any Korean MMOs :)


    OR maybe he actaully understood what Korean games are about, and realised many asian mmo's are better then DDO. could also be he never played an asian mmo, who knows.
  • JestorRodoJestorRodo Member UncommonPosts: 2,642



    Originally posted by MrAzgaard
    Must say

    Best: SWG Pre-Cu
    Worst: SWG NGE

    *Born to work*
       

    I was about to say the same thing but the NGE makes my prema-bann sweet , thanks SOE!

    Unaware of the Jestor?
    http://about.me/JestorRodo/

    Friends enjoy his classic Vblog - https://www.facebook.com/GoodOldReliableNathan

  • beaverboy123beaverboy123 Member Posts: 85
    eve online definetly overrated though it is quite good and guild wars overrated too
  • ferthalaferthala Member Posts: 129

    Best for me is UO

    worst: there are so many bad games its difficult to select one.

  • Vertex1980Vertex1980 Member Posts: 951

    BEST - None
    Worse - None
    Overrated - All of them

    image
  • kylecameron1kylecameron1 Member Posts: 240


    Originally posted by beaverboy123
    i think best is world of warcraft and worst swg and overrated guld wars

    lol, guild wars is over rated, then what is WoW exactly, under rated with its 6 million players.

    98% of the teenage population does or has tried smoking pot. If you're one of the 2% who hasn't, copy & paste this in your signature.

  • WizardryWizardry Member LegendaryPosts: 19,332

    My personal favourite was FFXI.[teamwork/satisfying accomplishments/exploration/battle system/quests/well balanced classes/spell system]

    Tough to put a handle on the worst ever because there was quite a few games i deleted from my HD after less than 15 minutes of gameplay.For some reason i keep thinking of planetside.Perhaps because it was one of my first beta tests,and was expecting too much from it.RYZOM and a few others never lasted more than 15 minutes on my HD.First impressions are huge.DnD is a close second because again i expected too much and got a kiddie hold my hand game instead,then i get an email saying they made the game more solo friendly,please come back...pfft.

    As easy my fave pick was,the over rated pick is just as easy>>>>WOW.It had only one thing it did better than FFXI or EQ2 and that is solo play.There isn't any other aspect of the game that can compare.I used those 2 games as examples because they are the closest thing to WOW,no sense trying to compare it to a totally different type of game.

    Never forget 3 mile Island and never trust a government official or company spokesman.

  • TeleboasTeleboas Member UncommonPosts: 184

    Best : Ultima Online, if they ever upgrade the graphics.  :P

    Worst : Dark and Light

    Overrated : I think most likely, it'll be Vanguard.

  • SouldrainerSouldrainer Member Posts: 1,857

    Best: COH/V- A game that improves with every patch.  No other MMO has ever accomplished this beyond 3 months, especially not WOW.

    Worst:  tie- EVE, Guild Wars, WOW.

    EVE- Glorified chatroom.  Once I learned how to play, the game quickly became boring.  I was like "people actually enjoy THIS?!?!"

    GW- I could never get over the fact that all men look like 12 year old girls.  Even warriors.  Too scrawny.

    WOW- The gameplay experience has been in steady decline since day 1.  With each patch, the game just gets worse, and in that sense, Burning Crusade is just another patch.

    Error: 37. Signature not found. Please connect to my server for signature access.

  • WurmriderWurmrider Member Posts: 10
    Best: Umm... Anarchy Online? :P

    Worst: Project Entropia



  • BababooeyBababooey Member Posts: 322
    Best: Don't know.
    Worst: Maplestory/RuneScape.


    * Want to see how dumb you are? Click here to take the dumb test!

  • PyndaPynda Member UncommonPosts: 856

    Played - AC1, DaoC, AO, SWG, CoH, WoW, EVE

    Best - AC1 by far. The sheer magnitude of the possibilities offered by using randomly generated items, a real "skill" based character system, having a huge world, interesting tradeskills and resource items, and the bucketloads of content AC1 had kept me playing for three years.

    Worst - CoH. Lack of any real content and a limiting "skill tree" type system (that wouldn't challenge even a 6th graders intellect) had me quitting before the game went retail. Nice character creation process though. Too bad there was nothing else.

    Overhyped - WoW. I was fairly entertained until I hit level 54 or so. But afterwards doing the same raid instance over and over again to obtain some cheesy limited spawn item was the absolute dregs....not to mention the meaningless and boring PvP. With the development money Blizzard had you'd think they could have come up with a better end game than that.

  • Shrimp10Shrimp10 Member Posts: 275


    Originally posted by Bababooey
    Best: Don't know.
    Worst: Maplestory/RuneScape.


    How are RS and MapleStory the worst MMO's...DDO and Roma Victor suck balls LITERALLY compared to them...

    Best MMOs - RuneScape and WoW
    Crappiest MMOs - Hero Online, SWG, DDO
    MMO's played - RS, WoW, GW, EVE, AO, PlanetSide, Jumpgate, Face of Mankind, MapleStory, SO, Liniege 1 & 2, City of Villains, Flyff, Realm Online, SWG, Seed, Sims Online, City of Heroes.

    98% of the teenage population does or has tried smoking pot. If you're one of the 2% who hasn't, copy & paste this in your signature.
    ----

  • KenobeeKenobee Member Posts: 32
    Best: Eve-Online, Ragnarok Online pre-bot insanity. Eve because it is very good for people that have work/eduction and dont have time to spend 8 hours a day playing a game. RO because it has a good community like Eve and good storyart and concept.
    Worst: L2 - A game designed on grinding with awful graphics, awful concept and downright disgusting customer service.
    Overhyped: WoW - A game that owes its "popularity" to psychological side affects of its loot system and the Warcraft series great popularity, and of course alot of fanboys and fangirls. You know who you are!


  • RuthgarRuthgar Member Posts: 730


    Originally posted by Gameloading

    Originally posted by eriken

    Originally posted by Ruthgar
    Best: None so far
    Worst: DDO
    Most overrated: WoW





    If DDO is the worst one you played I guess you've never played any Korean MMOs :)


    OR maybe he actaully understood what Korean games are about, and realised many asian mmo's are better then DDO. could also be he never played an asian mmo, who knows.


    I have played a few Korean games, and I when I played them I liked them for a while, I never liked DDO from the first minute I played.
  • stinkingDstinkingD Member Posts: 34

    Best : SWG pre-CU

    Worst : DDO

    Overhyped : Guildwars

  • AnofalyeAnofalye Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,433

    Best:  City of Villains  (and by FAR, it leave competition about 5 to 10 year behind on many DESIGN aspects).  It has some flaws, such as IoP, Accolades, Nerfs...but...still the best, by FAR.

    Second Best: EverQuest, I would prolly be playing it and cursing at raiding, if I didn't find better, and at least, CoV merely enforce some PvP and it is on a superficial level, still, it is bad that CoV enforce any PvP, but far less annoying than that raiding-trash enforcement.  LDoN is the best part of EQ, raiding is the worst.

    Worst: I dunno, I don't like to dwell too much on negativity, rather focus on positive aspect and on points to improve, talking about WoW here would bring nothing, I look at it, I dislike it, I turn the page.  It is over and settle.

    BioWare will change everything and they will make a masterpiece!  Yup they will!  And that day, I will praise them as gods! 

    - "If I understand you well, you are telling me until next time. " - Ren

  • AnofalyeAnofalye Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 7,433


    Originally posted by Souldrainer

    Best: COH/V- A game that improves with every patch.  No other MMO has ever accomplished this beyond 3 months, especially not WOW.


    I agree with you, but nerfs where unrequired and they destroy a LOT.  Nerfing me has made me allergic to the word: Game Balancing...O just hear it and I recoil while getting a cross in front of me! 

    - "If I understand you well, you are telling me until next time. " - Ren

  • nomadiannomadian Member Posts: 3,490
    Favourite: EQ pre PoP also.

    Worst: Dragonraja

    Most promising: AC2

    Biggest letdown: DDO

    Worst first impressions: EQ2/ Saga of Ryzom

    Best Value: Guild Wars

    Most 'fun orientated' mmorpg: WoW

    Most 'rpg' mmorpg: EQ

    Best 'free' mmorpg I tried : Silkroad Online

    Favourite 'pve' mmorpg: EQ

    Favourite 'pvp' mmorpg: WoW

    Most anticipated mmorpg: Warhammer

    Favourite community in a mmorpg:  All depends on the guild you find.

    Mmorpgs I feel more deserving of a higher audience than they get: DAoC

    Most 'frustrating' mmorpg: EQ

    Most 'original' mmorpg: Flyff

    Best 'endgame' in a mmorpg: yet to meet one but probably DAoC had I a max char.

    Favourite graphics in a mmorpg: Guild Wars(colour)/AC2(terrain/landscape)/EQ(style)






  • fizzle322fizzle322 Member Posts: 723
    Best  : Eve
    Worst: Auto Assault


  • WrayethWrayeth Member Posts: 229

    Best:  Tie between EVE and SWG pre- player jedi, CU, and NGE

    Worst:  SWG post- player jedi, CU, and NGE

    -Wrayeth
    image
    "Look, pa! I just contributed absolutely nothing to this thread!"

  • ElnatorElnator Member Posts: 6,077
    Best:  If you can forgive the graphics:  UO Classic (pre-trammel)   SWG Pre-NGE/CU was as well.  Alas for the demise of the best :( 

    Worst:  Hmmm now that's a tough one... lots of competitors here.  Have to go with DDO though because as BAD as the other "BAD" MMO's are at least they're "complete" MMO's.  DDO is only 1/3 of a game.   If that.

    Overrated:  WoW


    Currently Playing: Dungeons and Dragons Online.
    Sig image Pending
    Still in: A couple Betas

  • RemyVorenderRemyVorender Member RarePosts: 4,006

    Best - Everquest 1 (only because it owned my soul for 3 years)

    Honorable mention: Dark Age of Camelot

    Worst - Lineage 2 (economy, bot farmers, terrible avatar customization/class options and the community destroy this game beyond recognition)

    Dishonorable mention: Dungeons & Dragons Online

    Joined 2004 - I can't believe I've been a MMORPG.com member for 20 years! Get off my lawn!

  • BballdudeBballdude Member Posts: 34
    Best: WoW..idk i just like it
    Worst: Dark age of camelot..idk..the graphics weren't appealing to me..and the community seemed dead and i just couldnt get into it..i mean i know its a good game its jsut my least favorite
    Over-rated: EVE...doesnt appeal to me in the least bit...never played it though

    Lifes like a million dollars

    You think its alot untill its all gone

  • GearboxGearbox Member UncommonPosts: 25


    Originally posted by MrAzgaard
    Must say Best: SWG Pre-CuWorst: SWG NGE*Born to work*image
    ditto
Sign In or Register to comment.