Let me put it this way:
Graphics: GW2
Mechanics: Bloody GW2
Storyline: GW2 by a light year
Gameplay: That remains to be seen but potential-wise GW2, hands down
Innovation: The only MMO ballsy enough to push forward and in a good direction …
Guild Wars2 takes this, no contest. Judging from what you wrote I can't help but conclude you really have no clue about what GW2 would be like. Even if we can argue about which mistakes GW 1 has (as I consider it to be the absolute stand out prodigy…