Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Ultima Online: Kingdom Reborn

PraetorianiPraetoriani Member Posts: 1,147
Hiya. I have a question to the MMORPG.com community - are you interested in Ultima Online: Kingdom Reborn, due to be released this summer? For those of you who don't know - Kingdom Reborn will update the Ultima Online graphics in all aspects. It won't look spectacular, but it'll definitely be competitive with some other MMORPGs that were released this and last generation. Before, I was held back playing Ultima Online - but now I'm actually thinking of trying it because of this update.



I was wondering - will any of you UO vets resubscribe? And if you're not an UO vet - are you thinking of trying it? I'm trying to gauge if and how much the UO community will grow. I believe that in many aspects (even though I haven't actually tried it yet) Ultima Online is still one of the best games gameplay wise, due to the amazing variety of things you can persue - not to mention nearly ten years of content.



Also, I'm European. Should I join up on the Europa shard, or is there a shard with a more active population, even during European daytime?
«13

Comments

  • blahmeisterblahmeister Member Posts: 15
    I miss the content of UO, but the graphics need a major upgrade in order for me to consider going back.  If the graphics turn out to be decent, and if the game mechanics get an upgrade too (I hate using my mouse to navigate, I prefer using the keyboard), then I'll consider it. 
  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082

    I will never play UO again unless Siege Perilous has a huge overhaul or they release a Classic pre-Renaissance shard.  I stuck with UO from the beginning for many years and was burned far too many times to ever want to play that game again, even though I have vast experience and knowledge of the game.

    The typical EA cycle is to develop an aspect of the game that is new or hard to obtain, let players struggle with obtaining or achieving it and then giving away similar abilities or aspects for free merely with the purchase of their next yearly expansion -  it's a trap, a dangling carrot that typically destroys the efforts of their player base in favor of the hope of obtaining new customers.

    If you play on any shard, I would recommend Atlantic for population, Siege Perilous for the best gameplay and community, and Europa for your location.

    But, I don't recommend Ultima Online for any experienced MMOG players, it has devolved into mass market crap and a graphics update is not going to change that, only the appearance.

    Why Ultima Online Currently Sucks?

  • fariic1fariic1 Member Posts: 253

    I never played UO until recently.  I gave the free trial a shot and I'm confused.

    I logged on one day and there was an option to run the game in 3d, logged in the next day and could only run the game in 2d.  Is the 3d UO that I got to try how Kingdom Reborn will look, or is it going to be dif?  I wasn't very impressed with what I saw from the 3d version.

    I want to play, but I'm a graphics whore and unless Kingdom Reborn is doing more for the engine then I saw I don't think I'll give it a second shot.

  • ManmadegodManmadegod Member Posts: 501
    Originally posted by sempiternal


    I will never play UO again unless Siege Perilous has a huge overhall or they release a Classic pre-Renaissance shard.  I stuck with UO from the beginning for many years and was burned far too many times to ever want to play that game again, even though I have vast experience and knowledge of the game.
    The typical EA cycle is to develop an aspect of the game that is new or hard to obtain, let players struggle with obtaining or achieving it and then giving away similar abilities or aspects for free merely with the purchase of their next yearly expansion -  it's a trap, a dangling carrot.
    If you play on any shard, I would recommend Atlantic for population, Siege Perilous for the best gameplay and community, and Europa for your location.
    But, I don't recommend Ultima Online for any experienced MMOG players, it's has devlolved into mass market crap and a graphics update is not going to change that, only the appearance.
    Well said.
  • Zaxx99Zaxx99 Member Posts: 1,761

    Ultima Online still continues after TEN YEARS since it's initial release way back in 1997. There is a reason for that.

    With a fresh graphics overhaul I will definitely give UO more game time. If the graphics and graphics engine are smooth and still offer the same game mechanics and freedom that todays UO offers, then I can see myself very likely going back to it.

    The same would happen IF Asherons Call would just do the same.

    Regardless of how much UO has screwed stuff up since the addition of Trammel way back when, UO still is a much better mmo then 90% of the games released today.

    I've said it a million times it seems like. Asherons Call and Ultima Online are STILL the two best mmos ever produced. People argue with me on this all the time, but there still isn't any mmo that comes close to offering the freedom and the complete avatar control that AC and UO offer. No mmo comes close to offering the depth that these two great mmos offer. Comparing a game like WOW and UO depth-wise is comparing a backyard garden canal with the grand canyon.

    So yes, if this new graphics overhaul and engine in Kingdom Reborn is quality stuff and not crap like their 3D client now is, then I would definitely go back to one of the deepest and most rewarding mmos ever produced.

    image

  • ManmadegodManmadegod Member Posts: 501
    AFAIK - Still going to be pvpless, lootless, shell of it's former self... Filled with ninja's, samurai, neon clothing, artifact dependant, game...





    I will agree that Ultima Online used to be the best game going, that fell through about the same time Trammel came into existance.... They open up some classic servers, i'll play..... I refuse to play with freaking ninja's, samurai, elves and other annoyances that have no place in this game or it's lore.... This game was ruined. It truly was a shame.
  • PraetorianiPraetoriani Member Posts: 1,147
    I just bought the game from the online store, and I have to say I'm both pleasantly and unpleasantly surprised.



    The graphics and animation are worse than I thought. The window is also rather small on my 19" screen on a high resolution. However, I'm guessing this will be a moot point in a month or three so I'll be fine.



    However, the moment I logged in on Europa (literally) someone asked me if I needed help. At first I thought it was an NPC - but to my surprise he replied as I talked. Showed me the ropes and was overall very friendly in an RP-style. Even though I've been playing for an odd 20 minutes now, I must say I've never been met with such friendliness in an MMORPG community.
  • xmoleculexxmoleculex Member Posts: 98
    I currently play UO, and have played almost continuously since I got into the beta so many years ago...



    Richard Garriott and Raph Koster made a helluva game, no doubt. Some of the other developers that came afterwards didn't share their vision and implemented some bad things into the game... We've seen some rough spots, for sure. The current dev team, led by Aaron Cohen, is quite simply kicking ass. They've been working hard on UO:KR, but have also found time to start working towards fixing existing problems. The Siege Perilous blessing imbalance is getting fixed in the next week or so. Old, worthless skills, like Arms Lore, are being made worthwhile again. Khaldun puzzle boxes are getting fixed! Kingdom Reborn is going to nerf most of the neon. Change is happening, and I think that by the end of 2007, Ultima Online is going to reach a new golden-age!



    The only thing that the current team has really had trouble with is PvP balancing. They are currently saying they'll revisit it after the next expansion, Stygian Abyss (to be released late this summer)... which is not only a revisit to it's Ultima roots, but will also introduce Gargoyles as a playable race. Ultima fans are rejoicing... or should I say... "To be rejoicing, we Ultima fans are..."



    Yes, there are Ninjas and Samurai, but you know what? Half of the game's population is in Japan now... an Asian based expansion made sense to the EA suits. Western players may not agree, but no one is forcing you to use those skills.



    But if you can look around the problems, what you'll find is a game that is completely unrivaled in terms of depth and choice.



    And by the way, the new graphics look great.
  • daarcodaarco Member UncommonPosts: 4,276

    I will try it again.

    The graphics scaerd the shit out me before.

  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082
    Originally posted by xmoleculex



    But if you can look around the problems, what you'll find is a game that is completely unrivaled in terms of depth and choice.

    Not even!  That may have been the case years ago, but not anymore, you are diluding yourself by continuing to tell yourself such things. UO is now quite shallow in comparison to other MMOGs, from combat and crafting to skills and even diet:

    Roma Victor Features

     

    Ultima Online Skill List

    Roma Victor Skill Tree

    Ultima Online is a good study in MMOGs, it has been morphed from the side-project, labor of love, of a small group of caring, experienced, intelligent developers at Origin, Inc. that exploded into a great success, only to be ignorantly taken over and wrecked piece by piece by the Electronic Arts corporation that owned it; in favor of seeking the short-term profits of the standard perceived teen computer gaming market, with unremarkable gaming designs catered to the lowest common denominator.

    Basically Ultima Online was converted from an outstanding multiplayer game design that kept players competing and interested in playing often, even with very little developer content, into merely a vehicle for EA to sell some extra boxes every year.

     

    And that's the main point, a graphics update will change very little, when it's the gameplay and design that are paramount; the years of foolish develpment and design cannot be so easily patched up as updating the graphics, but at least it is a step in the right direction.

  • ManmadegodManmadegod Member Posts: 501
    Originally posted by sempiternal

    Originally posted by xmoleculex



    But if you can look around the problems, what you'll find is a game that is completely unrivaled in terms of depth and choice.

    Not even!  That may have been the case years ago, but not anymore, you are diluding yourself by continuing to tell yourself such things. UO is now quite shallow in comparison to other MMOGs, from combat and crafting to skills and even diet:

    Roma Victor Features

     

    Ultima Online Skill List

    Roma Victor Skill Tree

    Ultima Online is a good study in MMOGs, it has been morphed from the side-project, labor of love, of a small group of caring, experienced, intelligent developers at Origin, Inc. that exploded into a great success, only to be ignorantly taken over and wrecked piece by piece by the Electronic Arts corporation that owned it; in favor of seeking the short-term profits of the standard perceived teen computer gaming market, with unremarkable gaming designs catered to the lowest common denominator.

    Basically Ultima Online was converted from an outstanding multiplayer game design that kept players competing and interested in playing often, even with very little developer content, into merely a vehicle for EA to sell some extra boxes every year.

     

    And that's the main point, a graphics update will change very little, when it's the gameplay and design that are paramount; the years of foolish develpment and design cannot be so easily patched up as updating the graphics, but at least it is a step in the right direction.





    Are you serious? Ultima Online has better graphics than Roma Victor.. I have played and own both.... Are you aware that in RV the skills you list arent even all useable... For instance when I first got RV animals simply were not spawning AT ALL, despite the fact that I chose to be an animal handler.... much of RV broken, much of RV are broken promises.... That game is just as broken and awful as VSOH and that is saying a lot....



    No thanks, I'd play Ultima Online even in its current idiot form before I'd touch RV again.



    Forgot to mention that you make your character through a web browser... uhhh what?
  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082

    It's come a long way.  Ultima Online was just as "broken" if not worse in it's first year and it was funded by the EA giant.

    And NO! UO does not have better graphics than Roma Victor, not visually or technically.  I challenge you to either post a comparison or retract that foolish statement!

    Many of those skills are implemented now and so are animals, maybe it's time for you to log back in?  Ultima Online would just be a waste of your time.

    A bad impression was made from the initial launch, but what is most important, even from the start, is that the Roma Victor gameplay and design are headed in the right direction, the virtual world concept, rather than the video game concept of current Ultima Online and many other MMOGs.

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182
    I also agree that UO looks better then RV. Imo, its better to make a good looking 2D game then a bad looking 3D game.
  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082

    If your taste is for 2d cartoons, then yeah, UO has "better" graphics.

     

  • GerecGerec Member CommonPosts: 185
    Originally posted by fariic1


    I never played UO until recently.  I gave the free trial a shot and I'm confused.
    I logged on one day and there was an option to run the game in 3d, logged in the next day and could only run the game in 2d.  Is the 3d UO that I got to try how Kingdom Reborn will look, or is it going to be dif?  I wasn't very impressed with what I saw from the 3d version.
    I want to play, but I'm a graphics whore and unless Kingdom Reborn is doing more for the engine then I saw I don't think I'll give it a second shot.
    No, the 3d version has been there for as long as I can remember (which isn't to say I've been playing since launch, cause I haven't so I don't know when it was added or if it came at launch or what), but it always looked terrible to me. I preferred to play in the 2d, looks better to me. Kingdom Reborn will be all new stuff, looks pretty good to me. Puts it on the level of something like NWN or so.
  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082

     

    Originally posted by Manmadegod

    Are you serious? Ultima Online has better graphics than Roma Victor.. I have played and own both....

     

    Originally posted by Gameloading

    I also agree that UO looks better then RV.

     

    Just so everyone is clear about the value of your opinions, here is a direct comparison:

    Ultima Online: Kingdom Reborn / Roma Victorimg456/1003/uovsrvrg2.jpg

     

  • ManmadegodManmadegod Member Posts: 501
    Nice job zooming and then posting an ultra awful quality UO pic tho... Really.... Anyways, its gonna be subjective and a blind fanboi isn't going to change his mind.
  • sempiternalsempiternal Member UncommonPosts: 1,082

    Funny you should say that.  That is the exact screenshot that Electronic Arts themselves is using to advertise Kingdom Reborn!

    Both are actual screenshots from both games and both are cropped to the exact same size and compared sided by side.

    You can't get fairer than that.

    So who's blind?

  • DeathTrippDeathTripp Member UncommonPosts: 263
    I don't know anything about either of these games , but yeah you did zoom in on the UO screenshot. Heres a link to the original screen

    http://www.vokr.com/novinky_ze_sveta/27-08-06_12.jpg

    -----------------------------
    Real as Reality Television!!!

  • AngelboundAngelbound Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 1,437
    Space some more when you link other wise it doesnt link.
  • ManmadegodManmadegod Member Posts: 501
    Fanboi i dont even play Ultima Online, not since they queer'd it up with Trammel... lol
  • ZorvanZorvan Member CommonPosts: 8,912
    Sorry, half assed paintjobs don't make a "graphics upgrade" for me. And UO is so far from 3D it's laughable.
  • GarrikGarrik Member UncommonPosts: 965

    Its great to see semp in yet another UO post, we all know how you feel about UO semp, it would be impossible for us not to seeing as you have a never ending source of hatred for UO.

    At first i actually used to take in what you said but now its all the same drivel that you have said 200000 times before and its just getting really old, its not even constructive anymore, its just pure trolling of everything UO.

    The most hilarious thing is that you play RV and bash UO, pretty much every game on the market is better than RV right now and most people would agree with that, so tell me why should we listen to the words of someone who enjoys playing with shit ? afterall you must be into half finished, bug ridden games otherwise you wouldnt be playing RV.

    Garrik

    ________________________________

    "once upon a midnight dreary, while i porn surfed, weak and weary, over many a strange and spurious site of 'hot xxx galore'. While i clicked my fav'rite bookmark, suddenly there came a warning, and my heart was filled with mourning, mourning for my dear amour, " 'Tis not possible!", i muttered, "give me back my free hardcore!"..... quoth the server, 404."

  • obiiobii Member UncommonPosts: 804
    Playing for what ea say 94 months now.



    It really depends what you expect from a the game.



    If you are in for the roleplay or freedom then UO is your choice.

    For gameplay with storylines, quests or loot chose a levelbased system which are FAR superior than UO.

    (I play wow at the moment too so I can compare the two and each has its strengths)



    UO is broken in many core aspects, though newbies will not feel it that much at the beginning anyway and so definitely worth a try.



    And I bet it was paidric that helped you, guy in black robe, looking like death incarnated.



    For the servers europa has the giggest roleplay community I think. Atlantic is the server with the biggest population.

    And some claim the asian servers have the best pvp, but that is open to discussion and only relevant if you speak japanese i guess.



    And for starting really wait until KR is out - it is a free upgrade and there are free trials for it too

    KR should be out in the next 1-2 month and will be pretty buggy (my guess from previous ea releases), but playable and judge the game then



    :)
  • HocheteHochete Member CommonPosts: 1,210
    I played UO for a good 4 years before quitting after EA destroyed it. I'll be returning to give Kingdom Reborn a go, especially because when EA were asked about making a pre UO:R shard, they're response was 'we will be making a unique skillset shard upon release of Kingdom Reborn'... Which sounds very, very hopeful. I'll at least be playing Kingdom Reborn until Darkfall is released (if it's released).
Sign In or Register to comment.