Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

GLBT Guilds in WAR

124

Comments

  • andeemann10andeemann10 Member Posts: 237
    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by andeemann10

    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by Majinash

    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.

     

    there is no freedom of speech on the internet.  in MMOs, on forums, in chatrooms or anywhere else you do not have free speech,.

     

    and freedom of assembly?  erm, its an online game so I don't see how this applies.

    that's why i said it would be interesting :) cause technically it is an assembly of people gathering for a social function......



     

    Freedom of assembly only applies to government intervention. Private entities can deny any sort of assembly they please, I.E. shopping malls wallmarts resturants and video games.

    but picketing, strikes, and boycotts are legal.......so far as they do not impose upon an individuals rights.

    Yes, but a private entity doesn't have to allow it on their property. you can picket and protest outside of someones property, but not on it if they don't want you to.

     

    ------------------------------
    "Capitalism is currently working as intended."

  • miagisanmiagisan Member Posts: 5,156
    Originally posted by brostyn

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.



     

    qft

     

    Online games are private property. Therefore, have no freedom of assembly or free speech, which only applies to a public forum. This is why you can't walk into Wal-Mart to start a demonstration. You'd quickly be arrested. Not much of a discussion.

    ahh true...you can, say picket a company or boycott it as long as you are not within their property, such as on a street or such. thanks :) i deal with environmental law, so i am not familiar with these.

    image

  • miagisanmiagisan Member Posts: 5,156
    Originally posted by ABRaquel

    Originally posted by andeemann10

    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by Majinash

    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.

     

    there is no freedom of speech on the internet.  in MMOs, on forums, in chatrooms or anywhere else you do not have free speech,.

     

    and freedom of assembly?  erm, its an online game so I don't see how this applies.

    that's why i said it would be interesting :) cause technically it is an assembly of people gathering for a social function......



     

    Freedom of assembly only applies to government intervention. Private entities can deny any sort of assembly they please, I.E. shopping malls wallmarts resturants and video games.

     

    I think if a company allows Religious Guilds and whatnot but doesn't allow GLBT (friendly) Guilds, that's discrimination. If I'm not mistaken even if its a private company, discrimination is against the law if you are providing a paid service for everyone and not just a select few.

    Of course this is my opinion and I may be completely wrong.

    no this is true....you cannot deny employment or benefits based on race, creed, or nationality.

    image

  • andeemann10andeemann10 Member Posts: 237
    Originally posted by ABRaquel

    Originally posted by andeemann10

    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by Majinash

    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.

     

    there is no freedom of speech on the internet.  in MMOs, on forums, in chatrooms or anywhere else you do not have free speech,.

     

    and freedom of assembly?  erm, its an online game so I don't see how this applies.

    that's why i said it would be interesting :) cause technically it is an assembly of people gathering for a social function......



     

    Freedom of assembly only applies to government intervention. Private entities can deny any sort of assembly they please, I.E. shopping malls wallmarts resturants and video games.

     

    I think if a company allows Religious Guilds and whatnot but doesn't allow GLBT (friendly) Guilds, that's discrimination. If I'm not mistaken even if its a private company, discrimination is against the law if you are providing a paid service for everyone and not just a select few.

    Of course this is my opinion and I may be completely wrong.

    It's always a bit of a gray area, and is one of the most difficult things to bring to court because it's difficult to prove their intentions.

     

    ------------------------------
    "Capitalism is currently working as intended."

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    Ok but this assumption is going to be totally out of thin air but lets say this

    the ratio of gay people is roughly 1/100 (in most cases this is what i have seen in personal experience)

    that means roughly 100,000 players are gay in WoW

    and even if the ratio is 1/200

    that means 50,000 players are.

    50,000 x 15$ = 750k per month

    i don't think any game is willing to lose that.

    and thats not counting friends/others who are against their decision

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by brostyn

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.



     

    qft

     

    Online games are private property. Therefore, have no freedom of assembly or free speech, which only applies to a public forum. This is why you can't walk into Wal-Mart to start a demonstration. You'd quickly be arrested. Not much of a discussion.

    ahh true...you can, say picket a company or boycott it as long as you are not within their property, such as on a street or such. thanks :) i deal with environmental law, so i am not familiar with these.



     

    Uhoh...I better stop dumping my toxic waste in the local swimming hole!

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • RetradRetrad Member UncommonPosts: 274

    There is no need to advertise a GLBT friendly guild in a game. For the most part, people who play MMOs are accepting of everyone. There is no need for specific GLBT guilds or GLBT friendly guilds. If you join a guild and tell people you're gay and they ridicule you...leave. But really that topic shouldn't come up unless it's asked of that person. Someone going around screaming IM GAY IM GAY or IM STRAIGHT IM STRAIGHT is annoying.

     

    There was a gay dude in my old WoW guild, he was funny as hell. He wasn't uber sensitive about us still using the term "fag" and "gay" to describe things and such, and didn't care when we called him it jokingly. Hell, he even used it against us. He'd even make gay sexual remarks, but it was funny as hell.

     

    To simply put it...there's no need for these type of guilds or advertising of them. Get in where you fit in, and most of the time people don't care whether you like cocks or vaginas, but whether you've got a sense of humor, personality, and other characteristics that mesh with theirs.

  • miagisanmiagisan Member Posts: 5,156
    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by miagisan

    Originally posted by brostyn

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by miagisan


    as a side note....i think this would be a fascinating legal discussion regarding freedom of assembly and free speech.



     

    qft

     

    Online games are private property. Therefore, have no freedom of assembly or free speech, which only applies to a public forum. This is why you can't walk into Wal-Mart to start a demonstration. You'd quickly be arrested. Not much of a discussion.

    ahh true...you can, say picket a company or boycott it as long as you are not within their property, such as on a street or such. thanks :) i deal with environmental law, so i am not familiar with these.



     

    Uhoh...I better stop dumping my toxic waste in the local swimming hole!

     

    image

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    oh yea on the whole communist subject

    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system

    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    oh yea on the whole communist subject
    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system
    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us



     

    I'm coming. Don't worry.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • ABRaquelABRaquel Member UncommonPosts: 541
    Originally posted by Retrad


    There is no need to advertise a GLBT friendly guild in a game. For the most part, people who play MMOs are accepting of everyone. There is no need for specific GLBT guilds or GLBT friendly guilds. If you join a guild and tell people you're gay and they ridicule you...leave. But really that topic shouldn't come up unless it's asked of that person. Someone going around screaming IM GAY IM GAY or IM STRAIGHT IM STRAIGHT is annoying.
     
    There was a gay dude in my old WoW guild, he was funny as hell. He wasn't uber sensitive about us still using the term "fag" and "gay" to describe things and such, and didn't care when we called him it jokingly. Hell, he even used it against us. He'd even make gay sexual remarks, but it was funny as hell.
     
    To simply put it...there's no need for these type of guilds or advertising of them. Get in where you fit in, and most of the time people don't care whether you like cocks or vaginas, but whether you've got a sense of humor, personality, and other characteristics that mesh with theirs.

     

    What about those that want to create a specific GLBT Guild or Religious Guild?

    So what I understand from you, any kind of guild that touches sociopolitical subjects shouldn't be allowed? If that's the case, I agree!

    The best way to take care of discrimination or anyone being uncomfortable with a specific guild that touches a sociopolitical subject is to BAN ALL OF THEM and keep the game clean.

    For me, I don't care. Come as a friend, come as you are.

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    oh yea on the whole communist subject
    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system
    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us



     

    I'm coming. Don't worry.



     

    oh god we are screwed

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    oh yea on the whole communist subject
    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system
    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us



     

    I'm coming. Don't worry.



     

    oh god we are screwed



     

    Yes...yes we are. =P

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891
    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    oh yea on the whole communist subject
    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system
    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us



     

    I'm coming. Don't worry.



     

    oh god we are screwed



     

    Yes...yes we are. =P

    can you make a "international gaming holiday"?

     

    xD

    well anyways seriously

    like i have seen atleast 5-6 animes which show america in a civil war by 2035

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY

    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    Originally posted by Capn23

    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    oh yea on the whole communist subject
    looking at the whole downhill slide america is on i think having a new governing system
    or less idiotic politicians might benefit us



     

    I'm coming. Don't worry.



     

    oh god we are screwed



     

    Yes...yes we are. =P

    can you make a "international gaming holiday"?

     

    xD

    well anyways seriously

    like i have seen atleast 5-6 animes which show america in a civil war by 2035



     

    *writes it down on the 'to do' list, right under 'rip congress a new one'*

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    i am worried about the next four years to come

     

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY



    i am worried about the next four years to come
     



     

    Honestly...I'm not thrilled about either of them. I'll support McCain, but only because I see him as the lesser evil. Obama just can't decide what he wants to do...and we need stability in the White House. If the President is shakey...the rest of the country and our armed forces will feel it. He'll be alright until we can find a true conservative that will actually decrease the amount of government and won't give tax breaks to the rich. They shouldn't even be basing the taxes on the amount of money you make. It should be based on how much you SPEND. Anyway.../rant over

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    xD yea, but last i heard our gov was in trillions of dollars in debt...

    well anways enough politics, more escaping! :D

    image

  • jzuskajzuska Member Posts: 418

    Why is this a big deal? Can't you just fit in with all the rest of us heterosexuals? Why does every "special" group need their own fucking GROUP. Like BET. Why do we have it? Oh, they need their own channel. Really, seems kind of oh I don't know. Racist.

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529
    Originally posted by BRYANBARTLEY


    xD yea, but last i heard our gov was in trillions of dollars in debt...
    well anways enough politics, more escaping! :D



     

    pay off the debts (they DO control the money making machine), cut down on our expenditures, then slowly get money back into the treasury. Another thing that ticks me off...pork barrel spending...earmarks. I could go on and on...but I'll stop here =P

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891
    Originally posted by jzuska


    Why is this a big deal? Can't you just fit in with all the rest of us heterosexuals? Why does every "special" group need their own fucking GROUP. Like BET. Why do we have it? Oh, they need their own channel. Really, seems kind of oh I don't know. Racist.



     

    {mod edit}

    We already ended the discussion.

    if they prefer to be with people like them let them be and quit bitchin.

    The BET channel is the same,

    if you don't like it dont watch it!

     

    image

  • miagisanmiagisan Member Posts: 5,156
    Originally posted by jzuska


    Why is this a big deal? Can't you just fit in with all the rest of us heterosexuals? Why does every "special" group need their own fucking GROUP. Like BET. Why do we have it? Oh, they need their own channel. Really, seems kind of oh I don't know. Racist.

     

    racism is descriminating against a race.....your looking for prejudice. And no it isnt....why are there all christian/aussie/east coast/etc guilds....its to suit the playstyle of those within a guild.

    image

  • AxumAxum Member Posts: 891

    ===============================END THREAD=======================================

    image

  • Capn23Capn23 Member Posts: 1,529

    I break the thread =P

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Guys! I'm hopelessly lost in a mountain of mole hills! Them damn moles!

  • miagisanmiagisan Member Posts: 5,156

    **mashes face on keyboard**

    xxghnjmkxyftgjnmfxnmy

    image

This discussion has been closed.