Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Star Wars: The Old Republic: The End of an Era and Beginning Anew

1246

Comments

  • Asmiroth20Asmiroth20 Member Posts: 346

    Originally posted by Sylviodrood

    my favorite part of swtor, is that first person story line that pertains to your character, i think that is really neat. though you have to do 4x the amount of side quests that mean nothing ....absolutely nothing whatsoever to your main story to the point where you forget you are playing ToR not just WoW in space. I LIVED TO SEE THE GREEN WALLS TO WHERE SOMETHING OF THE ACTUAL STORY OF MY CHARACTER IS GIVIN LIGHT. revolutionary my ass. with all that money they spent on voice acting, not to mention is steve blum and various other regulars in voice acting rehasing their voice but it is highly noticeable*commma*  they could have made a decent main story in which most quests pertain to your characters main story and do side quests for shits and giggles if you wanted to. IE mass effect, dragon age, KOTOR,etc....just such a huge disappointment to have a game made by bioware not feel like a bioware game, there are some aspects but core gameplay isnt. Then to hear about the payment model... they should just move over to a system LIKE GW to at least be compettiive to GW2 which launches in spring and by that time people will have aldraedy desubbed from SWTOR. Yea.... WoW in space. and dont get me wrong i love all the lore and story that goes into this game but witht the amount of resourses Bioware put into this game its really now just a polished piece of shit. I couldnt be more saddened by this.

     

    TL;DR WoW rehashed in space srs disappoint.

        I disagree.  It felt exactly like a Bioware game.  It was pretty solid for now, with the fact that they have time between now and December, they can make it even more solid.  It also had the feeling of Star Wars saturating it.  I really enjoyed the conversations, gave me more immersion than any other MMO I've played.  The stories that I went through had me wondering what was coming up next.  Sure there are some things that reminded me of WoW, but in a good way, the polished/though-out way.  I'm also glad to see they announced a traditional way to pay a subscription (figured they would do it this way).  

        I think GW2 will be a good game, will it take my attention away from TOR?  No way.  I can say that with certainty that I haven't really been able to say about any other MMO that came down the road.  So I guess, opinions are just going to have to be opinions here.

  • firefly2003firefly2003 Member UncommonPosts: 2,527

    Why want a MMO a pure sandbox or a pure themepark when it's possible to have both in a hybrid ? I think that is where most people are missing here, it's possible to have elements of both in one MMO, sandbox elements is a one shot development time.

    Say, let's take foraging/ getting rare components and finding treasure maps minimal time to develop and it's always there and never changes unless they add to it down the road, however themepark content (quests-raids) content always is developed and usually is blown thru by most gamers at breakneck paces making it difficult to keep up with the demand and keeping it exciting and fresh there is more work to do for the themepark gamer than it would be to develop the tools and content for the sandbox elements and player driven content, does sandbox elements add to a themepark styled MMO yes.

    Has anyone yet tried seriously to do this yet with the exception of SWG and less than a handful of MMOs? No , its time to experiment though and see what the reaction positive or negative could be.


  • catlanacatlana Member Posts: 1,677

    Originally posted by SaintViktor

    Originally posted by MMO.Maverick


    Originally posted by Terranah

     

    Yawn. Or not. The fact that the majority of people who playtested seemed to like what they played, while only a handful who are so burnt out that they can only enjoy MMO gameplay that 's completely different from what they played before didn't, says enough I think. To me, it looks like some people lack the ability to grasp that tastes and gaming preferences differ and mileage can vary, and that if they don't like something, that doesn't mean that the whole world doesn't like that something or even the majority dislikes it image

    A case of common sense and logic to me, which sadly is often quite lacking on this site, looking at the daily forum debates passing by.

     Considering that I was a tester for little over a month you're not telling me anything that  I don't already know. Also there is no way to tell if the majority in beta liked it or not. That is clearly subjective and an assumption on your part.

    I got a chance to play with a few guildies for the Beta. Your opinion was different than ours. Most of us are serious pvpers who also like pve thou. We will all be there for early access still. I am hopeful that bioware will not neuter the game for a few whiners.   

  • artemisentr4artemisentr4 Member UncommonPosts: 1,431

    Originally posted by Corehaven

    Originally posted by artemisentr4


    Originally posted by SaintViktor

     

     Oh please , almost anyone can see GW2 is leaps and bounds superior than what TOR will be offering but there is only the small handful of TOR fans that will think otherwise. Thats more than ok though! :)

    Hahahahahah!!!!!!! Stop, you are killing me. Have you seen the GW2 2D VO that just reads the text to you like you are an idiot? The fact that there are 3 different worlds for different play? The fact that it is just a port and play game for instant gradification of pew pew? Dynamic events that are just mob spawns to kill with a boring combat set up with the AoC dodge thrown in? The events that just cycle over and over again that again you just port to and pew pew?

     

    I wanted to play GW2, but the videos make it look very boring and nothing I would spend money on. So go ahead and run back to your 'precious', you can have it. I will enjoy TOR and all it will give me in my gaming entertainment I am looking for.

     

     

    You can look forward to and be a fan of Swtor, but if you're already putting down GW2 and laughing at it, you've likely got such bad taste that it has me seriously wondering if Swtor is going to be even worse than many already suspect. 

     

    Seriously liking Swtor is one thing and there's nothing wrong with that, but to laugh at GW2?  Yea, Im sure you wont be the only one laughing.  Anet will be laughing right along with you.  All the way to the bank.   They're totally breaking the mold, while Swtor is stuffing itself nicely inside it. 

     

    And if GW2 changes the industry?  Games like Swtor will become irrelevant faster than you can blink.  So enjoy it while you can. 

    That is what is so nice about B2P. You don't have to prove anything. Players buy your game and that is it. You never actually know how many are actually playing.

     

    Now if you follow my posting history, I don't bash like I did here very often. I did it this time to prove a bad point. And you may be a casualty as I have been from GW2 posts. I was just realy pissed from this GW2 fan and some others. And as I do, you can't take a few and extrapolate to everyone for any game. So sorry for the overboard post, even though I have come to that conclusion rescently from videos. But there are many decent posters and probably gamers in all games.

     

    And on your last point. The only thing that could change is the payment structure. F2P looks to be the future of gaming, not the type of game really. But the bottom line of all these games is the MMORPG. Regardless of the feature list. So nothing will be irrelevant and we will continue to see more and more MMOs in the future.

     

     

    “How many people long for that "past, simpler, and better world," I wonder, without ever recognizing the truth that perhaps it was they who were simpler and better, and not the world about them?”
    R.A.Salvatore

  • maskedweaselmaskedweasel Member LegendaryPosts: 12,195

    Originally posted by Corehaven

    Originally posted by artemisentr4


    Originally posted by SaintViktor

     

     Oh please , almost anyone can see GW2 is leaps and bounds superior than what TOR will be offering but there is only the small handful of TOR fans that will think otherwise. Thats more than ok though! :)

    Hahahahahah!!!!!!! Stop, you are killing me. Have you seen the GW2 2D VO that just reads the text to you like you are an idiot? The fact that there are 3 different worlds for different play? The fact that it is just a port and play game for instant gradification of pew pew? Dynamic events that are just mob spawns to kill with a boring combat set up with the AoC dodge thrown in? The events that just cycle over and over again that again you just port to and pew pew?

     

    I wanted to play GW2, but the videos make it look very boring and nothing I would spend money on. So go ahead and run back to your 'precious', you can have it. I will enjoy TOR and all it will give me in my gaming entertainment I am looking for.

     

     

    You can look forward to and be a fan of Swtor, but if you're already putting down GW2 and laughing at it, you've likely got such bad taste that it has me seriously wondering if Swtor is going to be even worse than many already suspect. 

     

    Seriously liking Swtor is one thing and there's nothing wrong with that, but to laugh at GW2?  Yea, Im sure you wont be the only one laughing.  Anet will be laughing right along with you.  All the way to the bank.   They're totally breaking the mold, while Swtor is stuffing itself nicely inside it. 

     

    And if GW2 changes the industry?  Games like Swtor will become irrelevant faster than you can blink.  So enjoy it while you can. 

    Firstly,  GW2 isn't going to change the industry in any different way then how its already changing.  Nobody is going to create GW2 clones,  and nobody is going to create SWTOR clones.  Everyone will be creating games with features that were implemented in GW2 and SWTOR.  These similarities will shape how games are created from here on out... cloning of one game or another --- not so much.

     

    Simply put the above arguments on GW2 and SWTOR, and the laughing, its all retaliatory.  GW2 has good and bad in it as well,  and no game is perfect.  I have played SWTOR,  I have preordered it,  and I have things I don't like about it too.  Nothing will be 100% perfect for everyone,  but those who can only enjoy 1 game... or can't let these games coincide without one being a winner and the other a loser...  those people are idiots,  and these games will launch - they will still be here complaining about the next round of games, regardless how good GW2 or SWTOR does, or how badly they "fail". 



  • DistopiaDistopia Member EpicPosts: 21,183

    Originally posted by Corehaven

     

     

    You can look forward to and be a fan of Swtor, but if you're already putting down GW2 and laughing at it, you've likely got such bad taste that it has me seriously wondering if Swtor is going to be even worse than many already suspect. 

     

    Seriously liking Swtor is one thing and there's nothing wrong with that, but to laugh at GW2?  Yea, Im sure you wont be the only one laughing.  Anet will be laughing right along with you.  All the way to the bank.   They're totally breaking the mold, while Swtor is stuffing itself nicely inside it. 

     

    And if GW2 changes the industry?  Games like Swtor will become irrelevant faster than you can blink.  So enjoy it while you can. 

    I don't think he's laughing at GW2, he was laughing at the statement he was quoting.

    Second what is up with the idea that because one game is different, all games will be different? I think it's somewhat silly to think both styles can't co-exist.

     

    For every minute you are angry , you lose 60 seconds of happiness."-Emerson


  • catlanacatlana Member Posts: 1,677

    Originally posted by SaintViktor

    Originally posted by Candomble




    Originally posted by Hendo0069










    Originally posted by SaintViktor



     

    BTW we shall see how GW2 will deliver all those revolutionary promisses they're making, but that will be a different chapter.

     

     Oh please , almost anyone can see GW2 is leaps and bounds superior than what TOR will be offering but there is only the small handful of TOR fans that will think otherwise. Thats more than ok though! :)

    Lol, we shall disagree. Btw, I have played both games. Granted my playtime on GW2 has been limited. However, my guild is going to SWToR for a reason.  

  • Asmiroth20Asmiroth20 Member Posts: 346

    Originally posted by catlana

    Originally posted by SaintViktor


    Originally posted by MMO.Maverick


    Originally posted by Terranah

     

    Yawn. Or not. The fact that the majority of people who playtested seemed to like what they played, while only a handful who are so burnt out that they can only enjoy MMO gameplay that 's completely different from what they played before didn't, says enough I think. To me, it looks like some people lack the ability to grasp that tastes and gaming preferences differ and mileage can vary, and that if they don't like something, that doesn't mean that the whole world doesn't like that something or even the majority dislikes it image

    A case of common sense and logic to me, which sadly is often quite lacking on this site, looking at the daily forum debates passing by.

     Considering that I was a tester for little over a month you're not telling me anything that  I don't already know. Also there is no way to tell if the majority in beta liked it or not. That is clearly subjective and an assumption on your part.

    I got a chance to play with a few guildies for the Beta. Your opinion was different than ours. Most of us are serious pvpers who also like pve thou. We will all be there for early access still. I am hopeful that bioware will not neuter the game for a few whiners.   

        You must've had the same kind of experience I did.  I feel the same way.  Shortest 3 days I've ever seen, still waking up wanting to play.

  • MavacarMavacar Member Posts: 328

     

    I gotta stop coming to these forums. The GW2 fanboys are pissing me off and the SWTOR fanboys are pissing me off. Why arguing about games that most people haven't even played and that's two different genres?

    I'm starting to believe that the flaming is because the hype has been going on too long, when you've been waiting years for a game you really don't want it to fail, you want it to be good to the point where you start trying to convince yourself it's better then everything els out there. 

    The one thing I don't wanna happen is that the GW2 guys will buy SWTOR and start bashing it ingame and SWTOR guys buying GW2 and bash that ingame, GREAT for the companies who's gonna make money with more people buying the game but it's gonna suck for us players who wants to enjoy both games...

    I just really hope both games will have some very nice Ignore functionality if this will go on


  • StruggsStruggs Member Posts: 205

    I am a huge SW fan. I pre-ordered the game. I can't wait to play it. I have no doubt I will enjoy it.

    I also, put money down at games stop already to pre-order GW2 when it goes on pre-order. I have never play GW1 well a trial recently and actually didn't care for it to much.

    However, I have done my research on both watched videos, read forums etc. I feel both will offer great things and that since one is P2P and one is B2P I can enjoy both for a while to come.

    I don't understand the fanboi bashing either, I hope it doesn't show up in either game. I also quesiton why I read the forums often. I guess its bc every now and again you get some good convo if you can filter the crap, sometimes you get some hilarious responses and sometimes you get some good articles form the writers.


    imageimage

  • hikaru77hikaru77 Member UncommonPosts: 1,123

    Originally posted by SaintViktor

    The problem is that fans have to get over that "I'm a fanboi" mentality and really look at what we're getting here and how it is being done. Sure, I'm a fan of many titles but seriously I leave my fanboi mentality at home when I post on forums. If you look at what TOR is offering and what has been done before there is very little distinction at all since Everquest. I'm also a big Star Wars fan and I was not impressed at all. I cancelled my pre-order and got Mass Effect 3 instead.

     

    So you just cancel a pre-order of a Bioware game to buy another Bioware game?. you know that TOR is a MMO right?, and  im not sure what is this ¨innovation¨ that people really wants, at this point it doent matter ill be playing tor in december.

  • StruggsStruggs Member Posts: 205


    Originally posted by hikaru77

    Originally posted by SaintViktor
    The problem is that fans have to get over that "I'm a fanboi" mentality and really look at what we're getting here and how it is being done. Sure, I'm a fan of many titles but seriously I leave my fanboi mentality at home when I post on forums. If you look at what TOR is offering and what has been done before there is very little distinction at all since Everquest. I'm also a big Star Wars fan and I was not impressed at all. I cancelled my pre-order and got Mass Effect 3 instead.
     
    So you just cancel a pre-order of a Bioware game to buy another Bioware game?. you know that TOR is a MMO right?, and  im not sure what is this ¨innovation¨ that people really wants, at this point it doent matter ill be playing tor in december.


    I find that pretty fun as well not to mention isn't the game set to release even later then SWTOR, I haven't followed ME3. I'm sure if I could chose to play a SRPG vs a MMORPG with their single player qualites implemented in the story telling I would choose the MMO, especially when its from the same company and its released first. Thats just me.

    imageimage

  • Mari2kMari2k Member UncommonPosts: 367

    I played SWG for many mounth, had a great time... the beginning was very hard. Started as a poor Droid crafter and ended as  a rich weapon mogul with an own city. But in the end it was also boring... did the same things everyday, glad that I was not stupid enouth to work to unlock the Jedi.

    The fact is that everything gets boring with time, so I enjoy everything new.

  • IsturiIsturi Member Posts: 1,509

    If you are referring to WoW as the 800lbs gorilla I do believe that gorilla has lost some weight and is looking more and more famish. I think TOR will take over the number one spot. Just as I mention before in prior post.

    image

  • BlackUhuruBlackUhuru Member Posts: 770

    Originally posted by Isturi

    If you are referring to WoW as the 800lbs gorilla I do believe that gorilla has lost some weight and is looking more and more famish. I think TOR will take over the number one spot. Just as I mention before in prior post.

    Maybe for about 2 months then the masses will start to fade away...... Far far away ....... Onto the next console game.

     

    "It would be awesome if you could duel your companion. Then you could solo pvp".--Thanes

  • NormikeNormike Member Posts: 436

    Originally posted by Mari2k

    I played SWG for many mounth, had a great time... the beginning was very hard. Started as a poor Droid crafter and ended as  a rich weapon mogul with an own city. But in the end it was also boring... did the same things everyday, glad that I was not stupid enouth to work to unlock the Jedi.

    The fact is that everything gets boring with time, so I enjoy everything new.

    Comparing SWG to SWTOR is liking comparing Daggerfall to Baldurs Gate 2. One is more sandbox like, the other is more story, drama, dialogue choice, character (aka cinematic) focused.

     

    And for the people complaining about more control in their story. You can either have a completely tailored, personal and non-movie like story or you can have a slightly tailored, somewhat personal cinematic like story. It's either one or the other. You can either have your sandbox or you can have your cinematics. One or the other, not both.

     

    I love both techniques but whichever it is it should be done well.

     

    SWTOR though, for a game that has put the RPG back in mmoRPG, it has a lot of grumpy bitter haters. How can you spend time on a website called MMORPG and not like an MMO that has moved the MMO genre forward in terms of the RPG? I get that some people love the combat, combat, combat in their pvp MMOs. And some love the sim, sim, sim aspect of their sandbox type MMOs. But what about the RPG part?

  • Biggus99Biggus99 Member Posts: 916

    Originally posted by BlackUhuru

    Originally posted by Isturi

    If you are referring to WoW as the 800lbs gorilla I do believe that gorilla has lost some weight and is looking more and more famish. I think TOR will take over the number one spot. Just as I mention before in prior post.

    Maybe for about 2 months then the masses will start to fade away...... Far far away ....... Onto the next console game.

     

     

    Gonna hold you to this prediction.  Lets discuss this again in February and see if the "masses" have actually faded away from SWTOR.  I have a feeling you will be disappointed, Nostradamus.

     

     

  • waynejr2waynejr2 Member EpicPosts: 7,771

    Originally posted by Biggus99

    Originally posted by BlackUhuru

    Originally posted by Isturi

    If you are referring to WoW as the 800lbs gorilla I do believe that gorilla has lost some weight and is looking more and more famish. I think TOR will take over the number one spot. Just as I mention before in prior post.

    Maybe for about 2 months then the masses will start to fade away...... Far far away ....... Onto the next console game.

     

     

    Gonna hold you to this prediction.  Lets discuss this again in February and see if the "masses" have actually faded away from SWTOR.  I have a feeling you will be disappointed, Nostradamus.

     

     

    Since he doesn't give you specific numbers and those can be hard to get, he can pretty much get away with it unless the game sells like hot cakes.  You need to get him to nail down specifics that can be measured and verified.

    http://www.youhaventlived.com/qblog/2010/QBlog190810A.html  

    Epic Music:   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAigCvelkhQ&list=PLo9FRw1AkDuQLEz7Gvvaz3ideB2NpFtT1

    https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_msdos?&sort=-downloads&page=1

    Kyleran:  "Now there's the real trick, learning to accept and enjoy a game for what it offers rather than pass on what might be a great playing experience because it lacks a few features you prefer."

    John Henry Newman: "A man would do nothing if he waited until he could do it so well that no one could find fault."

    FreddyNoNose:  "A good game needs no defense; a bad game has no defense." "Easily digested content is just as easily forgotten."

    LacedOpium: "So the question that begs to be asked is, if you are not interested in the game mechanics that define the MMORPG genre, then why are you playing an MMORPG?"




  • DraemosDraemos Member UncommonPosts: 1,521

    Originally posted by precious328

    I personally feel like we have went backwards.

     

    SWG (before Jedi) was a Star Wars game for the adult, e.g., player driven economy, gigantic worlds with player housing, player cities, player malls, superior crafting, in-depth surveying and harvesting, endless clothing options, deep space content, randomized item stats, incentives to use the social tools (cantinas / med centers) etc.

    Most everything about SWG was self-sustaining. There was always something to do.

    SWTOR, however, is a Star Wars game for the youth. It has story (not yours of course), which will ultimately come to an end. And what of end-game? Can I start a store? Can I plant a house? Can I go off and explore gigantic worlds? Can I go dicken' around in my starship? Can I plop down a guild hall? Can I do anything other than talk to quest giver, collect bear paws, and participate in redundant instanced PvP (Warzones)? NO.

     

    SWTOR is so tied down and linear it's not even funny.

    Funny, most adults don't have time for the game you describe as an "adult" game.  Maybe you should have said "unemployed/highschool/college student" game.

    I'm coming up on 30.  When I was in college and highschool, I wanted SWG.  Now?  I don't have time for that shit, and neither does any other adult w/ any sort of responsibilites.

  • IsturiIsturi Member Posts: 1,509

    Originally posted by BlackUhuru

    Originally posted by Isturi

    If you are referring to WoW as the 800lbs gorilla I do believe that gorilla has lost some weight and is looking more and more famish. I think TOR will take over the number one spot. Just as I mention before in prior post.

    Maybe for about 2 months then the masses will start to fade away...... Far far away ....... Onto the next console game.

     

    Sorry I'll have to disagree. I feel very strong about my opinion that TOR will take over the number one spot and not just for a few month but for a long time to come why?

    1. There has been a huge fan base for Star Wars alone since '78

    2. there has been a huge fan base for KotOR since '03

    3. Gamers are freaking sick of blue skin elf and orcs.

    4. A Sci Fi MMO is relatively new a few has tried and died but not do to lack of fan base (Tubla Rasa)

    5. Other Sci Fi MMO's (EVE) have pretty much leveled out.

    6. Only other major contender to a Sci Fi MMO is WildStar but that is still in the works.

    7. Bioware

    8. WoW has been losing player base for some time now and if the keep cramming x-patch down players throats they will lose even more. I promise I probably will never go back to WoW. Been there done that and I am sure im not the only one who feels this way.

    Anywho those are just a few facts that I can think of why TOR will be number one and I dare say in 2012.

    image

  • Biggus99Biggus99 Member Posts: 916

    I'm not convinced that SWTOR will take over the #1 spot from WoW.  At least not right away.  WoW just has too much history going for it.  But I do know SWTOR is going to be HUGE, and may eventually take over that spot  if BioWare can churn out enough content and if Blizzard continues to be lazy on their end.  

  • DevianeDeviane Member UncommonPosts: 108

    Originally posted by Whacko

    We will see ...but seriously these articles are getting redundant.


     

    i agree  i get  the  writers work is make articles but is like it is getting old  to talk about  what  would happen or  we hope to happen...players  discuss these things on daily basis on forums no need for a article for that imho

  • Trixey4795Trixey4795 Member Posts: 42

    Christ, if TOR

    1)gets a good healthy playerbase

    2) becomes a game that appeals to a lot of players that go on to enjoy it and keep playing it

    3) Makes its development money back via sales and subs etc

    4) Gets good content updates at acceptable levels

    5) Comes out 'polished' and in a healthy state ready to play and maintains that... and so on.......

    then how does it f****** matter what WOW , GW2 or any other game is doing?

    They're different games that will be played by different people with different tastes, likes, dislikes etc.

    Do you people really think anyone gives a toss whether GW2 is this, TOR is that, WOW has this many subs etc when they're

    not playing those games or going to play them?

    Seriously, some of you need to get over yourselves already before you really do permanent damage to the human gene pool.

     

    image

  • IsaneIsane Member UncommonPosts: 2,630

    You just have to laugh.

    SWTOR is releasing. Developed by a 100% professional outfit based around a great IP.

    Nothing else really matters. It is all about the now...





    The article above is of poor quality an also a poor approach misleading and applicable to probably delided MMOers' which I guess the writer has to cater for on this site.

    ________________________________________________________
    Sorcery must persist, the future is the Citadel 

  • LatronusLatronus Member Posts: 692

    Originally posted by Trixey4795

    Christ, if TOR

    1)gets a good healthy playerbase

    2) becomes a game that appeals to a lot of players that go on to enjoy it and keep playing it

    3) Makes its development money back via sales and subs etc

    4) Gets good content updates at acceptable levels

    5) Comes out 'polished' and in a healthy state ready to play and maintains that... and so on.......

    then how does it f****** matter what WOW , GW2 or any other game is doing?

    They're different games that will be played by different people with different tastes, likes, dislikes etc.

    Do you people really think anyone gives a toss whether GW2 is this, TOR is that, WOW has this many subs etc when they're

    not playing those games or going to play them?

    Seriously, some of you need to get over yourselves already before you really do permanent damage to the human gene pool.

     

    Too late, many of them have already poluted it.

    image
Sign In or Register to comment.