Originally posted by colddog04 I think in order to judge WoW raids side by side with TSW raids, at least 1 person on the planet (excluding people testing them under an NDA) should go through the TSW raids at least once.
The only reference we have for TSW raids is AoC.
So then the first question you should be asking is...
Will TSW raids be as good as AoC raids?
And that question is also unanswerable because no one has seen a TSW raid.
Actually the question is WoW or AoC who has the best raids?
Right, that is literally his question at this point. Which has better raids, WoW or AoC?
And then he just assumes TSW will have the exact same quality level and "fun factor" or whatever as AoC raids.
Arn't we all assuming Mist will have the same quality as Cata?
You should have pointed out MoP instead of WoW. And then this would really be a debate over the unknown. Filled with assumptions and empty arguments that will probably end up in a WoW vs TSW thread
Originally posted by colddog04 I think in order to judge WoW raids side by side with TSW raids, at least 1 person on the planet (excluding people testing them under an NDA) should go through the TSW raids at least once.
The only reference we have for TSW raids is AoC.
So then the first question you should be asking is...
Will TSW raids be as good as AoC raids?
And that question is also unanswerable because no one has seen a TSW raid.
Actually the question is WoW or AoC who has the best raids?
Right, that is literally his question at this point. Which has better raids, WoW or AoC?
And then he just assumes TSW will have the exact same quality level and "fun factor" or whatever as AoC raids.
Arn't we all assuming Mist will have the same quality as Cata?
You should have pointed out MoP instead of WoW. And then this would really be a debate over the unknown. FIlled with assumptions and empty arguments that will probably end up in a WoW vs TSW thread
Please, saying WoW has good raiding anymore. Unless MoP pulls something crazy out, not happening. TSW... eh... can't really comment enough, I just know its not my type of game. I do think its a nice game but not my type.
Speaking as a current HC raider in WoW, its raids have become a joke, and I think the latter bosses in each TSW dungeon already put them to shame. Hence I suspect TSW raids are going to be a lot more of a challenge, with more interesting mechanics than MoP. Also MoP is supposed to be easier than Cata (by design), with just challenge modes added to force one to repeat content at yet another tier.
I can honestly see WoW gaining subs upon MoP's release, but within a month or two the decline will accelerate. HC raiding guilds are already on the decline, being replaced by guilds that previously struggled. They still would, if things hadn't become so easy.
My answer is WoW. No question as far as I'm concerned. That doesn't mean that TSW raids will suck. They will probably be good, but c'mon.....WoW raids are, well....WoW raids.
Please, saying WoW has good raiding anymore. Unless MoP pulls something crazy out, not happening. TSW... eh... can't really comment enough, I just know its not my type of game. I do think its a nice game but not my type.
Shout out to RIFT. Regrdless of subs it's a good game.
Comments
You should have pointed out MoP instead of WoW. And then this would really be a debate over the unknown. Filled with assumptions and empty arguments that will probably end up in a WoW vs TSW thread
You said the only thing we have to go by for TSW is AoC. Im not sure what is my generalization.
Changing the title
You are also assuming that the same people who made AoC's raids will be the ones making TSW raids.
Anyway, all of these are assumptions and speculations. I suppose it's fun to argue about but we just have no knowledge about them right now.
Thats more representative
Let the guessing begin!
Personally I have no clue. Havent raided in WoW and havent raided in AoC. Giving this one to WoW since its the most popular for raiding.
I have raided both and enjoyed AoC's raids a bit more. However, that may be in part because I enjoyed AoC's combat a lot more than WoWs.
This thread has been the biggest waste of my time on this site to date...
Anyways, everyone knows Hello Kitty Island Adventure has the best raids.
Rift: Storm Legion
Please, saying WoW has good raiding anymore. Unless MoP pulls something crazy out, not happening. TSW... eh... can't really comment enough, I just know its not my type of game. I do think its a nice game but not my type.
Speaking as a current HC raider in WoW, its raids have become a joke, and I think the latter bosses in each TSW dungeon already put them to shame. Hence I suspect TSW raids are going to be a lot more of a challenge, with more interesting mechanics than MoP. Also MoP is supposed to be easier than Cata (by design), with just challenge modes added to force one to repeat content at yet another tier.
I can honestly see WoW gaining subs upon MoP's release, but within a month or two the decline will accelerate. HC raiding guilds are already on the decline, being replaced by guilds that previously struggled. They still would, if things hadn't become so easy.
***Edited for spelling***
My answer is WoW. No question as far as I'm concerned. That doesn't mean that TSW raids will suck. They will probably be good, but c'mon.....WoW raids are, well....WoW raids.
President of The Marvelously Meowhead Fan Club
Shout out to RIFT. Regrdless of subs it's a good game.