It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
I'll be the first to admit that Michael Moore's Documentarys are not the kind you find on Nova or even the History Channel. However I also strongly believe that they are more fact than fiction, and that almost every documentary ever made has had motive behind it.
I saw Sicko in theaters this previous weekend. I also saw Bowling for Columbine and Fahrenheit 9/11 in theaters when they came out. I liked all 3 and very much respect Michael Moore as a filmaker. Out of the recent 3, Sicko had the most impact on me. This is probably because it was about an issue I wasn't quite sure on. I always liked the sound of Nationalized Health Insurance, but I also made sure to hear the other side who brought up points about longer waits for transplants and limited operations per year. After seeing Sicko I've decided I would much prefer a Nationalized Health Insurance or at least anything better than Private Health Insurance Companies and HMOs.
However I also recognize a Nationalized Health Insurance is probably not in the cards for us anytime soon.
For those who enjoyed his other movies Sicko is not the funniest, though it has its funny parts of course, but it edged out Fahrenheit 9/11 on saddest and Columbine on most informative.
Comments
I am not a Michael Moore fan. In fact, Michael Moore and I probably, in a general way, disagree on most issues philosophically.
Nevertheless, SICKO is a must-see documentary. It is accurate. It is fair. Conservatives and liberals alike and agree with the film.
I think his documentary on columbine and gun control was complete and total crap. His farenheit (sp, wow, that is a hard word to spell!) 9/11 movie was crap as well. Sicko is not crap. Actually, it is so good I seriously recommend all Americans view it.
Edit: fahrenheit.
-----
WoW and fast food = commercial successes.
I neither play WoW nor eat fast food.
*sigh*
Private health insurance is really not that private at all because there is sooooo much government interference in it, and THAT makes it cost more for people! Moore said it himself when he talked about the laws and shareholders.
It is not my responsibility to pay for anyone's medical bills except for my family. I take issue with anybody saying I ought to pay for their bills. Most people have a hard enough time paying for their own bills. Most Americans live paycheck to paycheck and would hate to have more money stolen by the loving government. If government just got out of health care then private companies could provide a service just like every other business. America is where many innovations are made, especially in health care....because we aren't completely socialized yet! Socialized countries are infamous for providing subpar services, and free countries are known to expand and become advanced.
How about universal groceries? Tons of people are starving in America.
How about universal auto repair? We all could use that.
How about universal phone service?
How about universal fuel?
Of course all of these universal deals would be "free" for everyone.
edit: ugh sorry for the grammar...
______________________________
"When Saddam flew that plane into those buildings, I knew it was time to kick some Iranian ass!"
-cheer leading, flag waving American
The government needs more control over your lives, they need to control everything you do, and every bit of medicine that you take...more government control in our daily lives!! Monolithic government for the freaking win!!
/sigh is damn freaking right.
Your argument is like a two legged dog with an eating disorder...weak and unbalanced.
I have not yet seen the movie, and while I agree the medical system is in serious trouble, I do not believe in nationalizing health care. I think it would be disaster.
If nothing else, look at the one medical system the government does run, the VA. If that's the way they'll run all health care, I'll take my chances with private insurance.
Right, lets get universal health care in America. We did so well with Medicare/Medicaid and don't forget about social security, why not sink another 15% of are paychecks into another wonderful program like these.
Good idea, but it should stay as just an idea.
If only i could find a troll with a tin foil hat. =(
And stop making this a "american system" versus "evil commie, and you call it socialism, system" bullshit.
Switzerland has universal health care and that country produces most medical innovations compared to its size.
France provides the BEST health care. Not the cheapest. The BEST. The very best mankind has to offer. For LESS money than the US manages.
The money isn't stolen. It makes sure everyone can reach their potential. Saving the government trillions because otherwise people would fall victim to petty accident and would be unable to work.
Do you honestly think such a large part of the world is wrong? It's not the dumbest part of the world either. Nor is it the poorest part.
Rank Country
1 France
2 Italy
3 San Marino
4 Andorra
5 Malta
6 Singapore
7 Spain
8 Oman
9 Austria
10 Japan
11 Norway
12 Portugal
13 Monaco
14 Greece
15 Iceland
16 Luxembourg
17 Netherlands
18 United Kingdom
19 Ireland
20 Switzerland
21 Belgium
22 Colombia
23 Sweden
24 Cyprus
25 Germany
26 Saudi Arabia
27 United Arab Emirates
28 Israel
29 Morocco
30 Canada
31 Finland
32 Australia
33 Chile
34 Denmark
35 Dominica
36 Costa Rica
37 United States of America
I've underlined the countries with universal health care that are on the map.
The wealthiest nation on earth, and yet ranked 37th...
If you value your countries researc habilities, then please read this product of it. Note that all countries in the test that performed better than the US had universal health care.
Now, go on. Deny all of that. Deny that you pay much, much, much more than the rest of the world for OTHER people their health care, while they receive inferior quality.
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
Michael Moore is a master of spin. I'm sure you've all heard the stories of people waiting months for "free" medical care that cost them their lives. I'm sure you've all heard of wealthy citizens in Britian who choose to go to private clinics even though they have access to free care.
In fact, the administrator of the British national health administration recently admitted that one in eight patients had to wait more than a year for treatment. That is absolutely unheard of in the United States. And if you think that it would work in the United States, which is 100x bigger and has a 4x bigger population you're nuts.
http://society.guardian.co.uk/health/story/0,,2098276,00.html
You can find link to articles about the problems in Britian's healthcare system here.
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html#britain
Michael Moore is a master of spin. I'm sure you've all heard the stories of people waiting months for "free" medical care that cost them their lives. I'm sure you've all heard of wealthy citizens in Britian who choose to go to private clinics even though they have access to free care.
In fact, the administrator of the British national health administration recently admitted that one in eight patients had to wait more than a year for treatment. That is absolutely unheard of in the United States. And if you think that it would work in the United States, which is 100x bigger and has a 4x bigger population you're nuts.
http://society.guardian.co.uk/health/story/0,,2098276,00.html
You can find link to articles about the problems in Britian's healthcare system here.
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html#britain
Translation:
"WTF do you mean, water helps to put our fires? There's this guy who used water when HE was on fire... And guess what. He still had burns. What's the deal with that? There's even people who prefer CO2 extinguishers. That just proves water does shit versus fire. So I know why I choose to pray nest time I'm on fire in stead of trusting what didn't help this one guy, thank you very much."
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
I wish bad things on Michael Moore.
Why should I be taxed (pay for) someone else's health care?
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
And I so look forward to waiting 10 months for a surgery I need tomorrow.
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
The ranking of countries and their health care on the previous page takes into account waiting times. That means that far less people have to wait less time for better and cheaper medical care. Is the penny dropping in that head of yours?And I so look forward to waiting 10 months for a surgery I need tomorrow.
So other country
better medical care
on all levels
for less money,
correction,
far less money,
and for a whole lot more people.
For example, in my country I will be hard pressed to not be operated within two days. The same day (= immediatly) if I really need the surgery. If I go to my docter now then I can see a specialist tomorrow. If I'm willing to sit on a bus for 20 minutes I'll be able to see one tonight ( 7.30 pm at my place right now). Of course I'll pay a total of about € 10 for both visits. Would be less if I had less money.
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
I was going to make this big reply with charts and graphs to counter yours... but then I decided to attack the root of this argument. I simply don't give a sh** what you or anyone else thinks is a better system for health care. I'm unwilling to share my wealth with the "less fortunate" in this country, since I did earn it with my blood and sweat, while they choose to work at McDonalds or receive the welfare checks I'm already forced to pay them. It is very easy to get ahead in the American economic system. Save more than you spend. Unfortunately the majority of the poorer classes here feel a sense of entitlement to my income.
If and when I choose to give, it will be to the charity of my choice... not the governments choice.
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
Personally I blame the lack of healthy self-criticism on unhealthy patriotism.
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
Michael Moore is a master of spin. I'm sure you've all heard the stories of people waiting months for "free" medical care that cost them their lives. I'm sure you've all heard of wealthy citizens in Britian who choose to go to private clinics even though they have access to free care.
In fact, the administrator of the British national health administration recently admitted that one in eight patients had to wait more than a year for treatment. That is absolutely unheard of in the United States. And if you think that it would work in the United States, which is 100x bigger and has a 4x bigger population you're nuts.
http://society.guardian.co.uk/health/story/0,,2098276,00.html
You can find link to articles about the problems in Britian's healthcare system here.
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html#britain
Translation:
"WTF do you mean, water helps to put our fires? There's this guy who used water when HE was on fire... And guess what. He still had burns. What's the deal with that? There's even people who prefer CO2 extinguishers. That just proves water does shit versus fire. So I know why I choose to pray nest time I'm on fire in stead of trusting what didn't help this one guy, thank you very much."
Umm...what?
Personally I blame the lack of healthy self-criticism on unhealthy patriotism.
I think it's a bit odd that people take this "I refuse to share my wealth," attitude as if that is the main issue. To me, they come off as rather small minded in that you miss so many things that are included in the "big picture." Let's suppose that we get national health care and are taxed more heavily. In exchange for this tax there would need to be an overall increase in payroll period. A big selling point of anyone's salary is knowing that they get benefits (medical, dental, etc.). If we have national health care the money companies budget for health packages then becomes more or less free money they can then re-invest back into the company and hopefully the employees.
If I stood back and really looked at just how many times I go to any doctor, in any given year; the amount typically comes out to about six visits averaging about 20-30 bucks to me each visit. [I'm being very conservative as I make it a point to see my eye doctor three times a year, my general health doctor twice a year, a dermotologist at least once a year, and other specialty doctors for cancer checks/ physicals twice a year] Now I've been told that I go to the doctor more times than a normal healthy American but I'll have to take my numbers as the norm simply because I don't much feel like looking up statistics. Having seen the actual bill from these offices for the tests they run I'm often astonished at just how much all the crap cost, and this is just PREVENTATIVE tests. I'm quite healthy save for dodgy vision. My bills alone for just going in when nothing was actually wrong with me rounded out to approximately 2500 for the year, most which was covered by my medical benefits leaving me to only foot the bill on co-pays.
The point I'm trying to make is that in one way or another you get screwed over on the medical end of things as it is. The question I'd pose is if you'd rather be screwed while helping each other (read: fellow man) or screwed while only "thinking" you're helping yourself. Of course I'm just an average joe with little to no knowledge of the in's and out's of the industry. Maybe I'm the one with the narrow view on things.
Besides, you would pay for someone elses health because health bills are the main reason for bankruptcies in the US, costing the country billions each year. Not to mention the larger poverty have a very bad effect on the economy. A healthier popullation is a healthier country.
Personally I blame the lack of healthy self-criticism on unhealthy patriotism.
Conclusion:
Universal health care = cheaper (for the tax payers)
universal health care has long term revenue private health care doesn't have
Universal health care is better in terms of waiting lines, service, ...
CLICK HERE TO GET A LIST OF FREE MMO LISTS!!!
We have a system of Universal Health Care in the US. The Military has it. Guess what we have worse service then in the private sector. I have a condition that is potentially life threatening and I have to wait 5 months just to see the Surgeon for a consult. Yes my health care is free and in some cases that is nice. For instance in the Military they are more willing to do tests just to confirm an outcome and not worry about the cost. But you have to wait a lot longer. If you have the money to get good health care then private health care is a lot better. Heck if you have the cash to not even have health insurance that is the best care possible.
Currently playing:
LOTRO & WoW (not much WoW though because Mines of Moria rocks!!!!)
Looking Foward too:
Bioware games (Dragon Age & Star Wars The Old Republic)
We arnt Fing France, where the US. Just because France has a working system that seems cheaper then are system doesn't mean we can just push there plan into the system without crap hitting the fan. We are inefficient, wasteful, are bloated with large companies.
Honestly do you want another Social Security, 3x as expansive?
If only i could find a troll with a tin foil hat. =(
What we need is less government not more. Let the states each finance healthcare if they want. The federal government should do foriegn relations, Post service, and Military. They really shouldn't be involved in much else imo.
The problem with the healthcare system currently is that the government is too involved now. We have these bloated systems with tons of red tape that causes problems. If you can't afford your own healthcare then I guess you better not get sick. There is no reason that our citizens should be made to care for other people. And especially not people outside of their own communities. What do I care if there is someone in California with no Healthcare. How does that affect me over here on the east coast? The last thing I want to do is have more taxes taken out to provide more social programs. Our country needs to let people fail and leave it up to the communities to help each other out.
Currently playing:
LOTRO & WoW (not much WoW though because Mines of Moria rocks!!!!)
Looking Foward too:
Bioware games (Dragon Age & Star Wars The Old Republic)