Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

The reason this game actually needs to fail.

123468

Comments

  • VandragoVandrago Member UncommonPosts: 230

    Originally posted by Nazgol

    Originally posted by Caldrin


    Originally posted by kzaske

    You guys make this game sound worse than SW: Galaxies.

    Yes a lot worse than Pre-NGE thats for sure...

     

    I was there at the start of SWG and played for quite some time, its one of my all time favorite MMOs and i had great fun playing it. Sadly SOE/LA managed to brake the amazing game they had...

     

    SW:TOR is just a bland themepark game, during the beta it was entertaining for a few days but sadly it did not last more than that.

     

    I feel sorry for people who brought the silly expensive box set thing..

     Don't feel band for me for buying the CE. I enjoy it and like supporting the game.  If SWG was that good, then why is it not still around? Why did they even change it to compete with WOW with the NGE?

    SoE, next question.

    image

  • DeadlyByDezDeadlyByDez Member Posts: 152

    Reading these threads I honestly feel like I am playing a different game. i absolutely love the game, maybe I am mad or is my taste that bad?

  • LeucentLeucent Member Posts: 2,371

    Originally posted by Pilnkplonk

    Originally posted by Nazgol


    Originally posted by Pigozz

    The "I told ya" moment is slowly crawling out

    the most fun thing about it is that I dont even have to say it out loud - because even the fans admit the game lacks a lot 

     The I told you so moment from the same people screaming this game will fail before it was released. HAH. The game does need some more polish, but it's just sad we see the same hater names starting the same tired topics, seems like they would just move on, but guess some people have too much time on their hands.

    So some people are allowed to be critical of the game and some are "haters" so it does not count.

    Sorry, man. But just because some people didn't need to actually buy the game to see that its crap, simply because they have more experience with mmos or just simple common sense to smell a dud before it came out (and there were PLENTY warning signs) doesn't mean they are psychotic "haters." It just means that they happened to be right and you happened to be wrong so just be a man and admit it. No one will think less of you. God knows I've hyped some games that turned out to be real stinkers, lol.

    I'm a "hater" and I feel justified in my "hating." From Biowares' almost frightening reliance on "story, story, STORY" to exclusion of everything else down to the christmass release date which in EA's track record usually means one of two things a) they're pushing the game unfinished just to make christmass box sales and b) everybody will buy any shit when its christmass, better to ride it out than rely on retention which we know isn't forthcoming because the game is crap . Sadly, both of those proved true this time. Ill rather gnaw my leg off than buy another EA game. They really deserve to burn.

     

    Forget hater, I think yours in an obsession that needs to be diagnosed. Wow, take a break from anything gaming before you pop a vein, they re games lol.

  • oubersoubers Member UncommonPosts: 855

    Originally posted by DeadlyByDez

    Reading these threads I honestly feel like I am playing a different game. i absolutely love the game, maybe I am mad or is my taste that bad?

    your not the only one m8.....loving it also.....but i do have to admit that it still has flaws, but still very enjoyable game imho.

    ps: loads of gamers realy need a break from powerlvling imo...they rush to the end* just to complain there aint enough content in it......makes me lol.

    * because thats where the fun is???? repeating dungeons (flashpoints; whatever the name).

    My highest char is 30 and working on about 4 other chars as well......enjoying every little story detail untill now.....have not roleplayed a mmorpg in years like this.......so i like it ALOT.

    just my 2 copperz.

     

    image
  • KanubisKanubis Member Posts: 112

    No, this game needs to succeed.

    Then other publishers and studios will realise that only by having a huge budget can WoW's sub number be even remotely neared in the standard model of thempark MMOs.

    Not many will be able to commit that kind of budget so they'll be forced to try and innovate instead.

  • LeucentLeucent Member Posts: 2,371

    Originally posted by oubers

    Originally posted by DeadlyByDez

    Reading these threads I honestly feel like I am playing a different game. i absolutely love the game, maybe I am mad or is my taste that bad?

    your not the only one m8.....loving it also.....but i do have to admit that it still has flaws, but still very enjoyable game imho.

    ps: loads of gamers realy need a break from powerlvling imo...they rush to the end* just to complain there aint enough content in it......makes me lol.

    * because thats where the fun is???? repeating dungeons (flashpoints; whatever the name).

    My highest char is 30 and working on about 4 other chars as well......enjoying every little story detail untill now.....have not roleplayed a mmorpg in years like this.......so i like it ALOT.

    just my 2 copperz.

     

    It s pretty simple really. There are a select few , that do nothing but whine that the game wasn t catered to their style. It s a good quality game, that as they say is severly lacking. Not at all, I never once logged in and had to look for quests, I could always hit a button and join a warzone, flashpoints, yep theres plenty, titles to gain, yep, space combat, oh ya a mini game they re adding to, open world pvp they re adding to and improving now. Raids, yep they re there.

    Bottom line is, it s a good themepark game, with a great story added. The select few whiners are so butt hurt, they have to rehash the same crap over and over and over, to I guess sound important.

    It is rather amusing to me anyways, and they keep me entertained, while I m getting ready for work, and dont have time to log into SWTOR.

  • sirphobossirphobos Member UncommonPosts: 620

    All right another 14 page thread for TOR haters to whine and complain.

  • drbaltazardrbaltazar Member UncommonPosts: 7,856

    it is true i dont mind critic but hate formed as critic from the same 10 people ?

  • LidaneLidane Member CommonPosts: 2,300

    Originally posted by sirphobos

    All right another 14 page thread for TOR haters to whine and complain.

    image

    Yep. Another day on these boards, another whine thread. It's like clockwork.

  • Darth_OsorDarth_Osor Member Posts: 1,089

    People are delusional if they think that if TOR fails, suddenly devs will see the light and we'll see a string of big budget sandboxes lol.  If TOR with its' big name IP and big budget fails, good luck selling investors on ANY big budget MMO again...much less a niche format like sandbox, unless Blizzard's new MMO is a sandbox and it does really well long term.

  • drbaltazardrbaltazar Member UncommonPosts: 7,856

    Originally posted by Margulis

    Preface - Before I ever played this game I spent 5 months in preparation, I read every book, comic and lore piece and also replayed through KOTOR 1 and 2 entirely.  That's how excited I was for this game, what I figured to be my final MMO home.  Now a month after release, not only have I cancelled my subscription, but I hope this game fails more than any other game I have played.  Actually, I can't think of another game I've played where I can honestly say I desire it to fail, but this one I sure do.

     

    Why?????

     

    It's because a game like this sets a tone for the future of mmo gaming - the more successful it is, the LESS we as gamers get in the future.  The more we reward mediocrity, the more mediocrity we will get.

     

    Let's be honest here, after the voice acting and cut-scenes, this game is as generic as they come, and there are countless upon countless of game features and mechanics that not only do not measure up to the competition of the last 3-5 years, but fall WELL below the competition.  If you have fun playing the game, that's fine, good for you, but that doesn't mean the game isn't lacking in tons of areas.  Personally I find it insulting that a game company can give us this sort of product in 2012 and offer equally lackluster customer service to boot.

     

    Not only that, but it's scary that so many people seem to eat it up without question.  Is it because their only experience is with games released early to mid 2000's and that's all they have to compare to?  Is it just the honeymoon period of a new game?  Perhaps, like myself, they planned on this being their final MMO home and to admit it isn't what they hoped would break their sense of comfort  Who knows, but I know the more positive praise and results a game like this gets, the more other developers will think to themselves "hey, we can skip on adding this or that feature, or polishing this aspect up, it doesn't seem like the gamers really care that much, so why should we spend the money on it?"

     

    Bioware, perhaps without knowing it, has started to conduct an experiment with the MMO community - what is the LEAST that we can get away with  without the gamers caring, paying attention, noticing, and ultimately affecting profits?  If we put a sparkling cherry on top (story, VO, cutscenes), will that be enough to make up for the stale melted sundae it sits upon?

     

    It looks like to some people, yes, it is enough.  Not for me.  And from what I've seen on this site and many others, looks like a lot of people aren't content with just that cherry.  This is good!!  The less evidence we give to other developers that they can give us crumbs, the better products we will get down the line. 

     

    lets compare!its like the gaming community all joining up and yelling here margulis need to fail in his life!does it make sense!you dont know the people gees!as for the industry being stuck  in this genre etc .let get this straigh out most company use console to gage how to design their title ,this is the main reason you dont see game in 64 bit with tessalation dx11 is often lacking in the title.it isnt because they cant they chose to stick with the console power curve .so when ps4 or xbox 460 come out it will be the same they ll design with console in mind first not computer!

  • hikaru77hikaru77 Member UncommonPosts: 1,123

    And what about all the people who actually is in love with the swtor?. I mean, you know guys? people is having a lot of fun playing swtor, and at the end, when you play games is all about how fun it can be.  Haters gonna hate, and for some reaso swtor is growing, i wonder why?

  • SovrathSovrath Member LegendaryPosts: 32,941

    Originally posted by Kakkzooka

     

    So bad products should be bought because there's a small possibility it could impact other good products in that market? How about harmful products? How about the 1974 Pinto?

    No, you are mistaking what I am saying for "you must buy products that you hate or don't like'. Not saying that at all. I am saying that if a lot of money keeps getting invested in these products and they never do well then you will find less people investing in them.

    @ Yamota:

    You have a very good point. But I wonder how many millions of dollars can be invested in products that just don't seem to be making healthy returns. So sure, there are people who will analyze a product so that they can find better ways to create these products for better returns but this market is very fickle, it takes a huge amount of money to make these things, they never seem to have enough time and it takes too long to make them just to have them bring very little to the table.

    And people are already looking at these products and analyzing them and this is what we have gotten for that effort. I"m not saying that mmo money is gong to dry up but it does seem like a horrible investment given what has been released over time.

    Like Skyrim? Need more content? Try my Skyrim mod "Godfred's Tomb." 

    Godfred's Tomb Trailer: https://youtu.be/-nsXGddj_4w


    Original Skyrim: https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrim/mods/109547

    Try the "Special Edition." 'Cause it's "Special." https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/64878/?tab=description

    Serph toze kindly has started a walk-through. https://youtu.be/UIelCK-lldo 
  • IcewhiteIcewhite Member Posts: 6,403

    Skating on slippery slopes.

    Self-pity imprisons us in the walls of our own self-absorption. The whole world shrinks down to the size of our problem, and the more we dwell on it, the smaller we are and the larger the problem seems to grow.

  • FalcomithFalcomith Member UncommonPosts: 831

    Originally posted by Margulis

    Preface - Before I ever played this game I spent 5 months in preparation, I read every book, comic and lore piece and also replayed through KOTOR 1 and 2 entirely.  That's how excited I was for this game, what I figured to be my final MMO home.  Now a month after release, not only have I cancelled my subscription, but I hope this game fails more than any other game I have played.  Actually, I can't think of another game I've played where I can honestly say I desire it to fail, but this one I sure do.

     

     

    It sounds like you got yourself too hyped. I have been playing mmos close to ten years, and one thing I learned is not to get yourself hyped up, because in the end you are just going to be disappointed. However, if you have been following SWTOR since it was announced like I have, the game reflects everything Bioware has announced before release. I dont see why you think it would be anything different then any other cookie cutter mmo out there.  Take this from the Bioware developer Greg Zeschuck...

    "It [World of Warcraft] is a touchstone. It has established standards, it's established how you play an MMO. Every MMO that comes out, I play and look at it. And if they break any of the WoW rules, in my book that's pretty dumb," Zeschuk said."

    http://massively.joystiq.com/2011/02/10/bioware-wow-is-the-touchstone-for-the-old-republic/

    That quote there,  was all over the internet at the time. It should have brought your hype way down. Dont get me wrong, I like SWTOR for what it is, but never got to excited about it.

    Now for the other part you said about hoping it would fail. Why would you hope for something that is harmless to fail? You are talking about peoples jobs? You think that all of those people that were hired to make the game would keep there jobs if it failed? No. It is just like someone saying to you that they wish you would fail in what you do. How would you take that?

    Just because something doesnt live up to your expectations doesnt mean it should be banished from existence.

  • drbaltazardrbaltazar Member UncommonPosts: 7,856

    cause there are 90% casual gamer and 10% of pro gamer!

    and also this game is actually good

  • MothanosMothanos Member UncommonPosts: 1,910

    For a single player story telling level trough all contend SWTOR does a good job.

    It keep going to get better and better up to level 30 when you finish act 1.

     

    We are around the 30 day mark now and i stopped que for pvp warzone's.

    PvP (even with state of the art pc's) is horrible.

     

    Ability's responce time feels late, not like wow at least wich have the best responce time in any mmo i ever played.

    Level 50's with massive amounts of expertise rampaging down on level 10/49's who participate. ( new patch fix that with L50 bracket) patch postponed on the last second.

    Since today i get discoonected without any reason every 15 min, happens in pvp or any other place in the world.

    For my son it started last night but he has wireless so i tought stuff like that could happen once in while.

    Trying to play again tonight and if the problem still excists i think i quit SWTOR and wait for something else.

     

    I can tell many things why SWTOR is losing appeal to me, but people have to find out for themselves why they play or going to quit.

    I played on a medium server wich is now deserted, rerold last week on a full server out of fear of Warhammer/Aion dejavu's.

    The forum is plagued with pvp buggs and no real answer is given.

    The testers dont tell much info either but say many pvp problems still be the same in patch 1.1.....

    For me this is a sign that Bioware is focusing on PVE contend alot like Blizzard does.

    A dragon for pve contend needs to be hotfixed asap and pvp contend can wait a long time for attention.

     

    I knew this but still i tought things cant be that bad.

    But i need to say this, i always HATED questing in any mmo's i played, in SWTOR i love it.

    But it stops around level 30 and after making 6 alts for the Empire and all around level 20/35 i notice the 1st real cracks in SWTOR.

     

    Still this game is young and like all infants it needs to grow, but will it get to that stage ? i hope so, but the forecast aint pretty for pvp players and SWTOR has ALOT of pvp players in their house.

     

     

     

  • niceguy3978niceguy3978 Member UncommonPosts: 2,051

    Originally posted by Hatefull

    @ Nazgol,

    Pre-NGE SWG was not bleeding subs at all.  The NGE happened because the vocal minority (read; Forum whiners) were busy whining and crying about the game, while the majority were busy playing said game.

    Was SWG perfect? lol no, not even close, it had bugs and yes you had to spend quite a bit of time running to dungeons etc etc. the community and the fact that there were no games around that could compare to it kept people playing.

    I do not think SWG would ever have posted the numbers WoW has, but I think had they fixed bugs, and kept adding content (there were huge amounts of content already) they would still have a decent player base.  But the NGE killed that, and as we sw, last month it died for good.  As far as I know.

    I know you don't want to believe it, but it has been said by more than one of the previous devs that the game was "bleeding" subs and they had been told to right the ship so to speak.  In the months leading up to the NGE the game was losing at least 10k subs a month, which may not sound like alot, but for a game that peaked at 300k subs 10k is alot especially when it is happening every month.  Could they have done something different to curb the losses and attract players back?  I'm sure they could have, but they did what they did.  They didn't do it because of "forum whiners" that did it because of "suit whiners" who expected a mmo with Star Wars on it to do much better than it was doing.  At its peak it had 40 percent fewer subs than EQ (EQ at around 430k and SWG at around 300k).  I'm sure it didn't please LA to have one of the best known IPs in the world being outsubbed by a previously unknown IP.  Thus we received the NGE.  Goodie for us.

  • TheLizardbonesTheLizardbones Member CommonPosts: 10,910


    Originally posted by drbaltazar
    cause there are 90% casual gamer and 10% of pro gamer!
    and also this game is actually good


    There are people getting paid to play SWToR? How do I get that job?

    I can not remember winning or losing a single debate on the internet.

  • GoparuGoparu Member UncommonPosts: 18

    SWTOR is just old simple stuff with shiny new skin, I mean for god's sake there's a ball pvp game in it, it's ridiculous.

     

    Totally agree with OP

  • RedcorRedcor Member Posts: 426

    Originally posted by Margulis

      The more we reward mediocrity, the more mediocrity we will get.

     

    Amen Bro. +1  . Let it burn.

    Civilized men are more discourteous than savages because they know they can
    be impolite without having their skulls split, as a general thing.
    -Robert E. Howard

  • ZekiahZekiah Member UncommonPosts: 2,483

    Originally posted by Rzep

    This game does not set shit. The death of this or WoW will not change shit. You cant change lazy devs.

    Wrong.

    Stop paying for crappy/subpar games and they'll scurry away along with the rest of the rats into obscurity.

    "Censorship is never over for those who have experienced it. It is a brand on the imagination that affects the individual who has suffered it, forever." - Noam Chomsky

  • drbaltazardrbaltazar Member UncommonPosts: 7,856

    i must have done something wrong cause i did all content and i am 36 and still havent met this act 1 end, i must be on the proper planet then!

  • jeremyjodesjeremyjodes Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 679

    Well not sure i want it to fail. real people do work there. and that would be cruel to want 100's of people to loose income because it's another whatever you want to tag it.

    The game could suffer low expectations and subs and the good of that would be to get crackin on those features they promised would be added after launch.you can't expect to ride high on the premise it's starwars. people still will leave the game if it's the same old suck we played since 2004

    wish they would swing it to add some sandboxie features and get that dam space rail mini game replaced. get those dam guild ships in now and make the ship a home you can drop your shit it in pronto. but they wont many of us know that from experience.

    image

  • SagremorSagremor Member Posts: 24

    A little tale of me... as an interlude to this magnificent thread. 

    I remember the time when I was a teenager.. waiting for my first sexual experience with a woman... Hype was so high... after watching the porn and expecting some great partners doing it all...  I even had books and lube and condoms... tried them just to know the feeling... and it finally arrived.

    And then...after the same first time, I felt so delusional and disappointed on how it was quick and dirty... and I thought to myself, this girl wasn't good since I did not enjoy it. I went on a trip to find the perfect woman for me... I slept with countless women only to find myself expecting much of the next one.. feeling more and more disappointed each time. 

    Finally, after this crusade of looking for the good woman, I found out I was gay... True story. 

    Moral of the story? 

    No, I am not saying that "haters" are gays but having a great hype of a game will only end with dissapointment and delusion. The game is fine and will be polished over time as all other games were. 

    Redefine the reasons you play MMOs is what people should do. I play MMOs because of the social aspect of it. I play with friends. Some like to steamroll people in PvP because they can feel superior. Some people want to play the economy by amassing pile of money. 

    To each his own but if you don't find what you were looking for, just continue your journey. No need to spill your hate or dissappointment expecting consolation and convince people you have been tricked by a mega corporation like EA to buy this game like they were using a cheap Jedi mind trick. 

    When the hype is so high, the fall is long and painful.

This discussion has been closed.