Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Lineage 2-- BEST MMORPG BY FAR-WORST REVIEWS!! WHy?! i tell you why

1246789

Comments

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129

    I /sign with the OP. Lineage2 definitely deserves a re-review.
    The game's come a long way since release and it's only getting better.. and all expansions come free of charge. ^.^

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • DekothDekoth Member Posts: 474



    Originally posted by Laserwolf

    Lineage II: The Chaotic Chronicle is the current one right? This thread has finally pushed me to getting this game. I have been going back and forth on wanting L2 for about 2 years now and when I first saw the thread I changed my mind 5 or 6 times reading all the posts. Then I realized that I am not on the same wave length with many MMORPG fans. I loved UO, and the only other MMORPG I really enjoyed was ShadowBane though I have played damn near every major MMORPG out there.
    Anyway, I am going the Amazon route because I like to have a tangible game. Chaotic Chronicles is the newest version right?



    *Shrug* My enjoyment of UO being that I still play it when I want PvP is one of the primary reason's I dispise L2, mostly because to me its everything PVP should never be. To each their own I suppose.
  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129

    I may play L2 but I'm no starry eyed fangirl so I'll tell it to you straight.
    (And btw I play on a real server)

    L2's fortes are:
    1. Graphics.. easily the best out there atm
    2. Political PvP
    3. Mass PvP
    4. PvP PvP PvP

    The Game is for:

    1. Hardcore Gamers
    I do not say L2 is 'hardcore' because of the grind. I say it because of the time it takes to succeed and resultingly, the amount of respect you earn once you do succeed. If you're a hardcore player you want to stand out from the average crowd and have something to show for it.. L2 gives you plenty of opportunities to do that.
    While some may argue that 'Hardcore' should be purely about skill.. I argue that it's both time and skill. You can'y play professional piano without practicing 8 hours a day no matter how gifted you are. The logic applies even moreso to gaming 'cause there definitely isn't as much to it skill-wise.

    2. Politics Freaks
    Ask any high-lvl L2 player why they stick around and they'll tell you it's the politics.
    If you love inter-clan drama and the post-battle forum trashtalk than L2 is for you. People get so emotional over this game it's ridiculous. (Check out l2orphus.com or l2blah.com if you don't believe me.. two forums entirely dedicated to trashtalk.)

    The Game is NOT for:

    1. PvE players
    If you want to play for PvE, don't bother with L2. The quests are terrible, crafting is a joke, and the grind can get unbearable at times. I treat L2 PvE simply as a necessary evil to strengthen my char for PvP ..and for e-ego. There's no e-ego like L2 e-ego that's for sure hehe. Oldschool EQ-style players that look for PvE/Raids type gameplay should stick to WoW or EQ2 ^.^

    2. Casual Gamers
    If you can only put in 8-10 hours a week or less into L2, chances are you'll have a hard time getting past your 50s and will therefore never see the core of the game: mass PvP and castle sieges. You'll only ever see the grind and the generally terrible L2 PvE content. Unless you have infinite patience and enjoy torturing yourself for long-time goals, find another MMO. L2 will drive you insane. 

    I love L2 but it's got more than enough of its share of faults. I understand it's a niche game and I expect most people to never understand its attraction.
    But if you love it.. you'll LOVE it.. and you'll never know if you love it until you've gone deep into it yourself.

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • HolyCircleHolyCircle Member Posts: 73


    Originally posted by Rockk
    Lineage 2 has a superb story : Legend of Lineage II, every aspect of the story is integrated in the game as part of design and quests too.I play free on a private server and i enjoy every second of it. THere is no hard level grinding, if u go in party you won t even notice the level grindig. The rates were jsut 5x, so it s not that big of a difference i think.From what u `ve wrote about the official server, u totally scared me about it, i think i`ll never play there.The game in my opinion is jsut plain superb and gorgeos. I never called nobody here morron or stupid, so i don t know what problems do u have with me, mr Chris don t know who, but i won t make of this thread a fight between opinions.THis is my opinion about something and u should respekt it. But then again i don t really care at all.Everybody has the right to choose whatever he wants. It s about personal tastes. ALl i do was to describe what i feel and how i see this particular game. I feel that it s beeing underrated unfairley.THERE IS CRAFTING!! there is an entire Race which skills are CRAFTING-- dwarves are artisans, only they can craft from items, and only they can make b graded armors. U can craft anyitem, it s super kul :D
    Oh, and in my smal country, ROmania (that s Europe), on the private server where i play there are 4200 k Players!!! so don t sayLineage 2 is not catching up. It s damned Addictive!


    Kid, don't be ignorant. You'r original post stated that whoever doesn't like L2 is ignorant, carebear, and needs to go play WoW or EQ, so don't say you respect anyone's oppinion. Ignorance is a bliss, isn't it?

  • anarchyartanarchyart Member Posts: 5,378



    Originally posted by HolyCircle




    Kid, don't be ignorant. You'r original post stated that whoever doesn't like L2 is ignorant, carebear, and needs to go play WoW or EQ, so don't say you respect anyone's oppinion. Ignorance is a bliss, isn't it?



    YOU said the game sucked because it was full of asians. Ignorance is bliss, eh? Check the mirror.

    image
  • anarchyartanarchyart Member Posts: 5,378



    Originally posted by Laserwolf

    Lineage II: The Chaotic Chronicle is the current one right? This thread has finally pushed me to getting this game. I have been going back and forth on wanting L2 for about 2 years now and when I first saw the thread I changed my mind 5 or 6 times reading all the posts. Then I realized that I am not on the same wave length with many MMORPG fans. I loved UO, and the only other MMORPG I really enjoyed was ShadowBane though I have played damn near every major MMORPG out there.
    Anyway, I am going the Amazon route because I like to have a tangible game. Chaotic Chronicles is the newest version right?



    NOOOOOO! Don't buy it!!! You can download the free FULL version with Chronicle 3 at www.Lineage2.com ! Phew I hope you read this before you bought it. No reason to buy it now, the download is free.imageimage

    EDIT: I see you like to have a boxed game, but if you do buy the boxed version you're still gonna have download C1, C2 AND C3, which is more data than the original game. I lost my bought copy lol and thank goodness you can just download it now. I HATED Lineage 2 back when it came out, me and my gf played for about 3 months before I just said that's enough! But boy they have spiced this puppy up a TON since then! New everything basically. I love quests especially in a game that takes a lot of exp to level, and the quests made me love it again.image

    image
  • GreatnessGreatness Member UncommonPosts: 2,188

    Lineage 2 can be underated sometimes(mostly from the people who scared to take the time to lvl). Believe me, I am truly a casual gamer, when the game first released in retail version. Took me 2-3 months just to get to 20(but it was fun image) then I made a new char without rerolling and took another 2-3 months(this time a dwarf so ten times harder). Finally, I got bored cause my rl friends quit until the free buddy key month trial thing. My friends and I exchanged them from our newsletters and started playing again. This time I got to lvl 20 in less than a month! And this was not in the summer like the time it took me 2-3 months to get to 20! I was amazed and plus that was only Chronicle 2. Chronicle 3 is out and it is so easy to get to 30's it scares me. 30+ is when some PvP action starts to take place but 40+ is even more.

     I quit now though since my friends quit again lol. Peer pressure image. Anyway, I recommend Lineage 2 not because of the easier grind though, but because of the PvP. It is very political and if your in a guild, and have a rival guild, prepare for many PvP run-ins. The world is huge too(you can hide if your scared image). And the good ol' music is amazing. Usually I listen to my Ipod when playing mmos but for Lineage 2, didn't need to. Though, I do not recommend for the people who thinks this game suxs just cause many cheaters(it is fun to train them, maybe get some good items image).

    ~Greatness~

    Currently Playing:
    Nothing

  • GameloadingGameloading Member UncommonPosts: 14,182

    "1. Graphics.. easily the best out there atm"

     

    this is NOT true! the game with the best graphics out there at the moment is Everquest 2.

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129



    Originally posted by Gameloading

    "1. Graphics.. easily the best out there atm"
    this is NOT true! the game with the best graphics out there at the moment is Everquest 2.



    Lineage 2 Armor Graphics

    image

    EQ2 Armor Graphics

    image


    Lineage 2 Architecture

    image

    EQ2 Architecture

    image

    Maybe it's a matter of preference but I've found EQ2 graphics to be plastic.. their water engine is great though. They've got great water.

    imo the only MMO out there that's open to western public (so this excludes upcoming Korean MMOs like Zera) whose graphics rival that of L2 are CoH and Guild Wars.

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • GreatnessGreatness Member UncommonPosts: 2,188

    I have seen cooler looking armour in Lineage 2 than that. Also, Aden Castle is amazing!! What an amazing looking castle!

    ~Greatness~

    Currently Playing:
    Nothing

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129



    Originally posted by Greatness

    I have seen cooler looking armour in Lineage 2 than that. Also, Aden Castle is amazing!! What an amazing looking castle!



    For those of you interested in seeing more L2 armor graphics, these are some good links:
    Elven: http://www.l2orphus.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=86167 (scroll down for more)
    Dark Elven: http://www.l2orphus.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=86455
    Human: http://www.l2orphus.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=90686

    It's a shame Syia didn't do Dwarves and Orcs.. dorf girls are so cute ^.^

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • 92165449216544 Member Posts: 1,904


    Originally posted by Esorlleh
    Originally posted by Gameloading
    "1. Graphics.. easily the best out there atm"
    this is NOT true! the game with the best graphics out there at the moment is Everquest 2.Lineage 2 Armor Graphicsimage
    EQ2 Armor GraphicsimageLineage 2 Architectureimage
    EQ2 ArchitectureimageMaybe it's a matter of preference but I've found EQ2 graphics to be plastic.. their water engine is great though. They've got great water.imo the only MMO out there that's open to western public (so this excludes upcoming Korean MMOs like Zera) whose graphics rival that of L2 are CoH and Guild Wars.


    You show a screenshot of a high level armor suit for L2, and then the very first armor set you get in EQ2. Also, the EQ2 screenshot of the guildhouse is about 3 years old and PRE beta. You screenshot comparing could use some work.

    EDIT: Excuse me, the screenshot of EQ2's building is from Freeport I think, and it is current. Still though, there is much better looking buildings.

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129

    921 I can't read your entire reply ><

    Yea you're right I just went to the EQ2 site and linked the first character screenshot I saw image
    I'd love to see good EQ2 screenshots tho if you don't mind linking some. ^.^

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • DekothDekoth Member Posts: 474

    Some of you might want to take a closer look. Even with the basic armor in the EQ2 screenshot it clearly shows how much better the EQ2 graphic engine is compared to L2. Look at the arms of the characters, notice how angular they are? This is precisly what I was referring to when I mention L2 made crappy models. The only thing they put any amount of polys into are the Tits and Ass. Now look at the EQ2 model, you will notice the arms are round and reasonably natural looking. Also take the time to notice that the Armor in L2 does not Sit on the character, but is rendered as part of the character model. In EQ2 you can clearly see the Armor has Depth and sits on Top of the character model, and does not look like a fancy paint job.

    As far as the plastic comment, first off I agree its one of the things I found irritating about EQ2. However do not confuse Texture with Graphics. If someone took the Same graphics engine in EQ2 and retextured it, the graphics in EQ2 blow anything on the current market away if they simply textured it right. L2 graphics at Best are on par with EQ1.

  • GreatnessGreatness Member UncommonPosts: 2,188

    Everquest 2 might have better graphics because it was made later than Lineage 2. For me, as long as graphics are good(I don't care if they ultra amazing) than I am fine.

    ~Greatness~

    Currently Playing:
    Nothing

  • DekothDekoth Member Posts: 474



    Originally posted by Greatness

    Everquest 2 might have better graphics because it was made later than Lineage 2. For me, as long as graphics are good(I don't care if they ultra amazing) than I am fine.




    That is a perfect stance. To want good graphics is a fine, in this day and age of hardware and gaming we should Expect Good graphics out of games. However those attempting to state that L2 has better graphics then EQ2 are just dead wrong and the screenshots prove it. Its about absurd to try and compare the two graphically as there is no comparison.

    Now From a texture perspective, I agree L2 did a much better overall job with their textures. Heck I will be the first one to Slam EQ2 over their lousy textures as I effectively has the same looking armor from level 20 to 50, even half my Fabled Gear looked the bloody same as crap I had.

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129



    Originally posted by Dekoth

    Some of you might want to take a closer look. Even with the basic armor in the EQ2 screenshot it clearly shows how much better the EQ2 graphic engine is compared to L2. Look at the arms of the characters, notice how angular they are? This is precisly what I was referring to when I mention L2 made crappy models. The only thing they put any amount of polys into are the Tits and Ass. Now look at the EQ2 model, you will notice the arms are round and reasonably natural looking. Also take the time to notice that the Armor in L2 does not Sit on the character, but is rendered as part of the character model. In EQ2 you can clearly see the Armor has Depth and sits on Top of the character model, and does not look like a fancy paint job.
    As far as the plastic comment, first off I agree its one of the things I found irritating about EQ2. However do not confuse Texture with Graphics. If someone took the Same graphics engine in EQ2 and retextured it, the graphics in EQ2 blow anything on the current market away if they simply textured it right. L2 graphics at Best are on par with EQ1.



    Dek, I'm not sure I understand you when you say the arms are more 'angular' .. I believe that's just the style of the armor? To me the EQ2 model looks bulky and awkward while the L2 one is more graceful.. although admittedly more stylized. (But that comes down to preference).

    I understand that L2 graphics aren't modelling heavy and they prefer to do most depth-work through texturing.. which is fine by me since it seems to allow more detail without adding to lag.

    I'm still not convinced EQ2 graphics are any 'better' than L2.. the feel of the EQ2 world and characters just isn't upto par. Need to see better screenshots!

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • 92165449216544 Member Posts: 1,904

    Well I just took some screenshots of Freeport and Qeynos. I would have got some more shots of armor but I did not run into any high levels. It was night in Freeport so its a little harder to see.

    Freeport

    image

    Interior

    image


    image

    This shot is beatiful in day time, because the light flows through the windows into the room.

    image

    image

    Findical- Lvl 33 Barbarian Berserker. His breast plate looks like crap, but its better in stats then the one that goes with the armor set.

    image

    image

    Qeynos- It was raining in all of these shots, but it is kinda hard to see in some of them.

    image

    image

    image

    image

    image

    image

    image

    Thats all of them. In my opinion EQ2 is by far better in graphics then L2. The armor in EQ2 is a bit more realistic, there is no spikes coming from your hips or ankles. Freeport and Qeynos are magnificent, they are huge and are both very well engineered.

    After taking all these screenshots I realized how much I like EQ2. I almost got killed taking one of those screenshots after trying to take my berserker to a waterfall for a good shot. ::::02::

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129

    Nice screenshots 921 ^.^ Changed my mind about EQ2 graphics
    Wish I didn't have to scrroll so much to see em ><
    And their water really is greaaat.. really is.

    I still prefer the L2 graphics as I like their style and texturing better but
    to each their own :)

     

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • DekothDekoth Member Posts: 474



    Originally posted by Esorlleh

    Dek, I'm not sure I understand you when you say the arms are more 'angular' .. I believe that's just the style of the armor? To me the EQ2 model looks bulky and awkward while the L2 one is more graceful.. although admittedly more stylized. (But that comes down to preference).

    I understand that L2 graphics aren't modelling heavy and they prefer to do most depth-work through texturing.. which is fine by me since it seems to allow more detail without adding to lag.

    I'm still not convinced EQ2 graphics are any 'better' than L2.. the feel of the EQ2 world and characters just isn't upto par. Need to see better screenshots!



    Specifically look at the arm's in the Elbow region. you will notice the shape of the arm's are diamond shaped in regards to the circumfrence of the arms, where as the EQ2 ones are rounded. Again I am making reference to the model it's self, and its not an armor texture here that is shaped by the base model.

    I wish I had not wiped my hard drive when I uninstalled EQ2 I had some excellent High res pictures that really showed off how impressive the engine was. Its just a pity that the EQ2 art team was as uninspired as they were when it came to armor texture, I will give you that L2 hands down has far better looking armor as far as texture is concerned. Leave it like this, Let the L2 art team, get ahold of the EQ2 engine and character models and you would in fact have the most visually stunning game on the market hands down.

  • brostynbrostyn Member, Newbie CommonPosts: 3,092

    A lot of people who played and quit have really torched this game. Complaining of hackers and grindfest. Thats not an enviroment most of us want to be in. If so many are complaining about these two topics then that suggest its a valid point.

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129



    Originally posted by Dekoth
    I wish I had not wiped my hard drive when I uninstalled EQ2 I had some excellent High res pictures that really showed off how impressive the engine was. Its just a pity that the EQ2 art team was as uninspired as they were when it came to armor texture, I will give you that L2 hands down has far better looking armor as far as texture is concerned. Leave it like this, Let the L2 art team, get ahold of the EQ2 engine and character models and you would in fact have the most visually stunning game on the market hands down.



    I can agree with that ^.^

    If only we could mix and match MMOs the way we mix and match clothes!
    I could so go for an MMO that combines somthing like.. WoW quest content + Saga of Ryzom NPC/Mob/Environment programming + L2 art , PvP and flying mounts + AO character implants and stat system + CoH customization .. etc etc


    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • LaserwolfLaserwolf Member Posts: 2,383



    Originally posted by anarchyart



    Originally posted by Laserwolf

    Lineage II: The Chaotic Chronicle is the current one right? This thread has finally pushed me to getting this game. I have been going back and forth on wanting L2 for about 2 years now and when I first saw the thread I changed my mind 5 or 6 times reading all the posts. Then I realized that I am not on the same wave length with many MMORPG fans. I loved UO, and the only other MMORPG I really enjoyed was ShadowBane though I have played damn near every major MMORPG out there.
    Anyway, I am going the Amazon route because I like to have a tangible game. Chaotic Chronicles is the newest version right?


    NOOOOOO! Don't buy it!!! You can download the free FULL version with Chronicle 3 at www.Lineage2.com ! Phew I hope you read this before you bought it. No reason to buy it now, the download is free.imageimage

    EDIT: I see you like to have a boxed game, but if you do buy the boxed version you're still gonna have download C1, C2 AND C3, which is more data than the original game. I lost my bought copy lol and thank goodness you can just download it now. I HATED Lineage 2 back when it came out, me and my gf played for about 3 months before I just said that's enough! But boy they have spiced this puppy up a TON since then! New everything basically. I love quests especially in a game that takes a lot of exp to level, and the quests made me love it again.image



    Here is a hitch. I went ahead and DL'd the game and am now trying to get a L2 account going but it asks for a Serial Code that I do not have. So to play I have to purchase one for $49.99. I think I'll just wait for my Amazon order of $20 to come in so I can use that serial. I did try to cancel after your post but item was already shipping so I couldn't, which turns out for the best it seems.

     

    image

  • EsorllehEsorlleh Member Posts: 129



    Originally posted by Laserwolf


    Here is a hitch. I went ahead and DL'd the game and am now trying to get a L2 account going but it asks for a Serial Code that I do not have. So to play I have to purchase one for $49.99. I think I'll just wait for my Amazon order of $20 to come in so I can use that serial. I did try to cancel after your post but item was already shipping so I couldn't, which turns out for the best it seems.



    I think maybe he meant you could try it on a private server or something. Personally I think private servers are a waste of time so I think what you did is best.

    Hope you enjoy L2 ^.^
    Let me know if you're gonna play on Bartz maybe I can help you out with some noobi gear image
    (Come to think of it I have some adena left on Kain server also)

    MMO Fav List:
    Lineage 2 | 5x Silver Ranger, 7x Shillien Elder <- Active
    WoW | 6x Rogue, 1x Priest
    Anarchy Online | 8x MetaPhysicist
    Saga of Ryzom | Matis Light Armourer

    Waiting for: Age of Conan, Lineage 3

  • LaserwolfLaserwolf Member Posts: 2,383

    Bartz it is. I would have most likely threw a dart at the screen blind-folded, but this works too.

    I'll pass on the noob gear though. I like a challenge.

    image

Sign In or Register to comment.